BUSINESS

Watching Us Save, One Cart At A Time

Wal-Mart has a unique vantage point for tracking the recession. How it's playing in the grocery aisles.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Rick16830 @ 05/06/2009 7:07:30 PM

    Walmart wants to help me "Live Better, but our local Walmarts prices are higher than our neighboring towns Walmart. Of course our Walmart has little competition while the neighboring towns Walmart does. Before Walmart, our town had 4 supermarkets and 2 department stores. 3 of the supermarkets and both department stores closed so Walmart is just about the only place left in town and they know it, thus they charge accordingly. Live Better with Walmart, just not in Clearfield, PA.

    • Posted By: stewartjason @ 05/29/2009 9:27:55 PM

      Comment about Clearfield Walmart is true. They admit to higher prices and say it's due to local competition. What competition? If a customer says a product is cheaper at another Walmart, they are supposed to match it. With this atitude, I'd rather shop at JG or Dubois Aldi's for groceries. Don't give in to the greedy jerks at Walmart.

  • Posted By: Jayshree @ 05/14/2009 3:36:48 AM

    Very interesting!
    Incidentally there is an interesting website that is specifically dedicated to recession victims.It offers help and discusses all issues related to recession-www.angstcorner.com. It???s worth a visit!

  • Posted By: Dredd @ 05/11/2009 10:25:23 AM

    Wall Mart seems to have mastered the Rules of Acquisition:

    http://blogdredd.blogspot.com/2009/05/life-in-ferengi-home-world.html

  • Posted By: biswal @ 05/10/2009 9:27:47 PM

    sorry for the extra posts, i had gotten an error message and thought it hadn't posted.
    to add one more point PBS had a documentary on how Wal Mart treats its suppliers -- even worse than its employees, if that's possible. Imagine each year being told to supply the same, or better thing, for at least 5-10% less, or else you lose the business. either way you end up bust. it also tells how Wal Mart basically bankrupt rubbermaid, when it refused to display it they way it used to because it was angry that rubbermaid raised prices after a worldwide increase in the cost of raw materials. rubbermaid went broke.

  • Posted By: biswal @ 05/10/2009 9:24:49 PM

    you are paying the price of shopping in walmart - in the form of state-funded healthcare that most walmart employees are eligible for, because they are so underpaid, in the form of tax incentives and holidays that local governments give it to set up shop. add all that up and you are paying through your nose for your alleged savings. everyone needs to read this Pulitzer winning series on Wal MArt
    http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-walmart-pulitzer,1,2534607.htmlstory?coll=la-home-headlines

  • Posted By: hornedherefords @ 05/05/2009 1:33:25 AM

    I do not shop at Wal-Mart, nor the Home Depot, and it is no more expensive at the smaller stores. People like you are selfish and worry only about youself. I am a self employed small business man, selling lawn equipment. The big box stores sell garbage, i see it everyday and those who thought they were saving money end up screwing themselves. They then end up coming to a local business wanting us to help them out of their mess. And yes if necessary i will pay more more american made goods, I don't know what you do for a living but you mentality is what is driving down the standard of living for all americans.

    • Posted By: cajademierda @ 05/05/2009 10:46:24 AM

      First of all, the prices at Walmart are well below most small businesses. The differences on grocery prices are so great that I really don't see why anybody shops at actual grocery stores anymore. Walmart saves me money and thus improves my standard of living. If it puts some small overpriced mom and pop stores out of business then too bad. Stores are just middle men. They produce nothing. So having them take a smaller cut of the sales price is good for the economy. If some store can't survive on that smaller markup then they should go out of business and we'll all be better off for it.

      • Posted By: biswal @ 05/10/2009 9:24:16 PM

        you are paying the price of shopping in walmart - in the form of state-funded healthcare that most walmart employees are eligible for, because they are so underpaid, in the form of tax incentives and holidays that local governments give it to set up shop. add all that up and you are paying through your nose for your alleged savings. everyone needs to read this Pulitzer winning series on Wal MArt
        http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-walmart-pulitzer,1,2534607.htmlstory?coll=la-home-headlines

      • Posted By: biswal @ 05/10/2009 9:20:49 PM

        It doesn't save you money because you are paying for the healthcare for the underpaid and uninsured employees, not to mention all the tax incentives and tax holidays your local government gave to walmart to set up the store in the first place. you all need to read this pulitzer winning series about walmart: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-walmart-pulitzer,1,2534607.htmlstory?coll=la-home-headlines

      • Posted By: biswal @ 05/10/2009 9:20:12 PM

        It doesn't save you money because you are paying for the healthcare for the underpaid and uninsured employees, not to mention all the tax incentives and tax holidays your local government gave to walmart to set up the store in the first place. you all need to read this pulitzer winning series about walmart: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-walmart-pulitzer,1,2534607.htmlstory?coll=la-home-headlines

      • Posted By: Osama Bin Login @ 05/05/2009 6:08:05 PM

        "Walmart saves me money and thus improves my standard of living."

        Enjoy your melamine, Slappy.

    • Posted By: beccabob @ 05/05/2009 8:31:05 AM

      It is obvious that you have not shopped at WalMart. While I admin Home Depot's prices are worse than the local store for almost everything, the prices at WalMart beat just about everything else around. I do most of my grocery shopping there, and the only place cheaper is Aldis. They are normally even less expensive than Sav-A-Lot. As for the produce quality, it is better than the local mom and pop grocery store, at 1/2 the price, along with almost every thing else. I normally only buy meat and sale items locally, as the local store prices are normally way out of line.

    • Posted By: beccabob @ 05/05/2009 8:30:55 AM

      It is obvious that you have not shopped at WalMart. While I admin Home Depot's prices are worse than the local store for almost everything, the prices at WalMart beat just about everything else around. I do most of my grocery shopping there, and the only place cheaper is Aldis. They are normally even less expensive than Sav-A-Lot. As for the produce quality, it is better than the local mom and pop grocery store, at 1/2 the price, along with almost every thing else. I normally only buy meat and sale items locally, as the local store prices are normally way out of line.

    • Posted By: beccabob @ 05/05/2009 8:27:30 AM

      Obviously you have never shopped at Wal-Mart. I do the majority of my shopping there. I live in a small town, with a small mom and pop grocery store. Their prices are quite often almost double of Walmart's price. I do shop for better quality goods elsewhere for some things, especially electronics, but overall, their prices are way lower than the mom and pop stores.

  • Posted By: Mwalimu @ 05/07/2009 6:38:06 PM

    So Karisa Sprague happily works 12 hours a day just to serve Wal-Mart customers.
    However, Daniel McGinn leaves a few disconcerting questions unanswered. Does Ms. Sprage get paid time and half overtime for putting in a 12 hour shift. Or are the extra hours "off-clock" unpaid time that Ms. Sprague is forced to put in because she is a "manager." McGinn conveniently forgets that several years ago Wal-Mart promoted all of its employees to a managerial status to avoid dealing with pesky issues like an 8 hour day or over time.

    McGinn also fails to tell us how much Ms. Sprague earns. What sort of medical insurance does she receive? Do her wages enable to buy a house in the suburban Denver area where she works, or can she even afford a crummy rental in a trailer park? With a 6 AM to 6 PM schedule, does Ms. Sprague have time to watch her children play soccer or attend parent conference night at the school her children attend? In fact, do her children see their teachers more frequently than they see her. (I'm a retired school teacher, so trust me - I know the answer to that question.)
    Does Ms. Sprage get time off to go to church?
    McGinn's article sounds like the sort of puff propaganda piece you'd get from an official newspaper in North Korea. Substitute Sam Walton for Kim il-Jong, as the Father of the People, and the analogy is complete.

    P.S McGinn should read Barbara Ehrenriech's book Nickled and Dimed. He should follow Ms. Ehrenreich's example and actually get a job working at Wal-Mart

    • Posted By: cautionarywhale @ 05/09/2009 8:56:35 PM

      My husband is an Assistant Manager at a Supercenter in a medium sized Oklahoma town. His starting salary for his position was twice what he could have made starting out at a teacher in this state. His store manager makes 120,000+ per year. So, don't worry about the store managers, they are very well compensated; especially considering that many of them never attended college and started their careers as cashiers, unloaders, stockers, etc.... I'm not a fan of Wal-Mart, I feel like I never see my husband because of his hellacious schedule. However they definately do provide a lot of good jobs, for people that would not have that opportunity otherwise.

    • Posted By: cautionarywhale @ 05/09/2009 8:55:57 PM

      My husband is an Assistant Manager at a Supercenter in a medium sized Oklahoma town. His starting salary for his position was twice what he could have made starting out at a teacher in this state. His store manager makes 120,000+ per year. So, don't worry about the store managers, they are very well compensated; especially considering that many of them never attended college and started their careers as cashiers, unloaders, stockers, etc.... I'm not a fan of Wal-Mart, I feel like I never see my husband because of his hellacious schedule. However they definately do provide a lot of good jobs, for people that would not have that opportunity otherwise.

    • Posted By: Holly Garfield @ 05/08/2009 1:11:58 PM

  • Posted By: Mwalimu @ 05/07/2009 6:43:18 PM

    I should add a few comments to njacovino's observations.

    First of all, shopping at Wal-Mart is like playing Russian roulette. A lot of Wal-Mart's bargain basement products come from sweat shops in third world countries - some of which use child labor. Also some of Wal-Marts products contain toxic substances. Thanks to Wal-Mart's lobbying campaign both the FDA and Consumer Protection Agency are horribily understaffed. Things might get better of Obama's budget passes Congress - but only if we hire more employees.

    Finally, living in Los Angeles, I clearly remember the grocer's strike. Shut out of Von's, where I buy most of my groceries, I was forced to patronize non-union food warehouses like Wal mart. A lot of the specials"" were high-fat junk food. I discovered that I can do just as well at Von's, a unionized store, if I take advantage of the discounts offered by my Von's club card and keep track of when things go on sale. So basically Wal-Mart is a fraud.

  • Posted By: njacovino @ 05/07/2009 7:48:59 AM

    I am surprised that Newsweek did not check it's fact before publishing this article. Wall Mart should be listed on the rip off report. I spend a lot less money and live a lot better from not shopping at "Wall Mart" and it's rips off products. They do not sell quality products, employees are rude and lie to create a violent and unscrupulous society that we now live in. Wall Mart ripps of people because they do not sell qaulity products and you have to buy the same product several times. It is a waste of money and they do not look out for their fellow American. The only place that Wall Mart and it's CEO's belong are on the FBI's most wanted listed for sinking this country to the point it is at now.

  • Posted By: jm1234 @ 05/06/2009 1:27:28 PM

    Tollet Paper is Toilet Paper...I don't need carpet under my feet or a sales clerk to explain what it does. Love Walmart! Get in and out and save my money for other things I'd rather have. Shopping for my eggs, bread, or cheese does not necessitate an expeience either. We own two Cadillacs and a Corvette, own a great house, have an MBA, and take nice vacations...because I don't need the "fancy" marketing of other stores to make me feel like I'm a trendy person.

    • Posted By: Osama Bin Login @ 05/06/2009 3:39:51 PM

      "have an MBA"

      Useless eater.

  • Posted By: tired and old @ 05/06/2009 10:04:00 AM

    ATTENTION ! SHOPPERS.

    I SPEND MOST OF MY GROCERY MONEY AT WALMART.

    I HAVE WATCHED THE FOOD PRICES ESCALATE AT THE STORE.

    THE STORY IS USUALLY BUSY AND AT TIMES THE CASHIER LINES ARE SLOW.

    GREAT PRICES WHEN ITEMS ARE ON SALE.

    THEY TREAT THEIR EMPLOYEES LIKE CHILDREN , THEY DISAPPROVE OF UNIONS ( MAY WORRY THAT THE BLACK PREZ WILL GIVE THE UNIONS A MAJORITY SHARE OF THE COMPANY ), THEY SOMETIMES VIOLATE LABOR LAWS.

    I WORRY ABOUT CHINA LEAD TAINTED TOYS AND AVOID BUYING THINGS THAT MAY HARM MY GRANDKIDS.

    WHY DO I SHOP THERE STILL; BECAUSE, OF A LACK OF CHOICE.

    LOCAL STORES OVER CHARGE ------- ANYONE WANT TO PAY $ 1.50 FOR A MEDIUM TOMATO ?

    • Posted By: Jurr @ 05/06/2009 12:10:49 PM

      Wal-Mart is trash, they undercut all their competition under they go out of business then jack up their prices....

      Their produce is trash, that's why it's dirt cheap.

      Their merchandise is trash, that's why they don't even offer a 30 day money back guarantee anymore.

      They suck local economies dry while giving nothing back except some minimun wage jobs.

      Do you know why you get lead paint and inferior products from Wal-Mart? They know how much a manufacturer makes per unit & squeezes them where so that the manufacturer is making LESS THAN a penny per unit. Then Wal-Mart has been known to come back & renegotiate that contract WHILE withholding payment to get even a better deal- no wonder the manufacturers cut so many corners.

      Those $20 sunglasses you bought a Wal-Mart cost them less than $.50 each, think about that next you make any purchases.

      • Posted By: jm1234 @ 05/06/2009 1:32:16 PM

        We all choose where we work and where we shop. Complaining about it will not change this.

  • Posted By: mbct3 @ 05/06/2009 10:26:41 AM

    I read the WalMart Article and am in total agreement regarding the prices. it was a shocker, BUT and this is a big BUT, in the newly opened WalMart in Scarborough Maine, there are three (3) isle of processed foods. Far more than any of our local, regional food stores. There is a very telling DEMOGRAPHIC which they believe they are serving. There were few if any items that are a higher end or of Gormet naure. Just plain Healthy would be great.

  • Posted By: JPACTS @ 05/04/2009 4:35:09 PM

    stop using WalMart and small town shops will return across the US

    • Posted By: spaschal4 @ 05/05/2009 4:27:23 PM

      That is NEVER going to happen. Ever. In the history of ever. Big box stores, like Wally World, are here to stay. People will always shop at Wal-Mart.

      • Posted By: drsyko1 @ 05/06/2009 3:56:00 AM

        That's not true. I NEVER shop at Wal-Mart. I hate that store. It's dirty, they always have about 15 people in line, the merchandising is terrible and they sell a lot of cheap crap. Give me a good Target store any day. And I shop at Trader Joe's which has great prices on food, and my local grocery store has very good specials. You just have to know what to look for.

      • Posted By: drsyko1 @ 05/06/2009 3:55:29 AM

        That's not true. I NEVER shop at Wal-Mart. I hate that store. It's dirty, they always have about 15 people in line, the merchandising is terrible and they sell a lot of cheap crap. Give me a good Target store any day. And I shop at Trader Joe's which has great prices on food, and my local grocery store has very good specials. You just have to know what to look for.

      • Posted By: Osama Bin Login @ 05/05/2009 6:04:48 PM

        Yes, whatever would they do without their cheap plastic crap and toxic toys from China?

  • Posted By: Osama Bin Login @ 05/05/2009 6:15:08 PM

    The only good thing about WalMart is playing "Walmart Bingo". You can search and download the cards on google images. When you see something described on the card, you mark it off...the first person to get a straight line wins. The free square is "mullet". Other squares include a morbidly obese woman in a sports bra and spandex shorts, unattended kids crying in the aisles, frozen food thawing on a non-food shelf, a 500 pound person on a Rascal with an oxygen bottle trailer, etc.

    Good times.

  • Posted By: wildechild66 @ 05/05/2009 2:11:43 PM

    There's a reason people call it "Volde-Mart". It's the cheapest, but not really the nicest place to shop.

  • Posted By: sp2000 @ 05/05/2009 1:34:42 PM

    WM Customer Service Sucks. Also, thier kids and ault not all but most clothing material is of not good quality, its below average and little beter than dollar store. Pricing wise yes they are little bit cheaper than Target but of you are smart shopper you will save more by shopping at Target than WM. Also, Target customer service is way way better.

  • Posted By: shankm @ 05/05/2009 11:04:49 AM

    There's a reason their prices are cheaper - with the exception of food, their products are of very poor quality and tear or break after only a few uses and their service is dismal. Over the course of a lifetime, you can easily end up wasting more money on cheap goods at stores like this than if you had bought a higher quality good for a little bit more money. Buy a real Oak desk for more money instead of 5 cheap plywood ones over the span of a lifetime and you'll see what I mean. 60 years from now, the Oak one will still be in your family.

    And I'm disappointed by the people who think small mom and pop stores should go out of business. Those mom and pop stores typically carry specialty goods you can't get anywhere else and let a town retain its sense of identity.

    Long term, Wal Mart hurts tourism and commerce in a town - because if you can get the exact same goods in any Wal Mart you go to in any town you visit, then what's the point of going to those other towns?



    • Posted By: jjaffie @ 05/05/2009 1:23:32 PM

      Those Mom & Pop stores also keep their money in the local economy whereas Wal-Mart ciphons out as much local cash as they can get away with. All the service agreements are with out of state companies, so they put nothing back into your town except some low paying jobs.

  • Posted By: thumper 54 @ 05/05/2009 11:27:37 AM

    WalMart* is not my store of choice, even when I need to pinch pennies. Their store brand is terrible. The produce is cheap because most of it is past its time. I have seen the price of one particular item that I did purchase from them, rise 50 cents over the past 4-5 months. I can't speak for all the WalMarts, but the one in my town needs to teach proper hygeine and clothing choices for the employees. Now that they have went to their "uniform", the employees look worse.

    • Posted By: jjaffie @ 05/05/2009 1:18:09 PM

      Their produce is like that because they store it in temperature/light/humidity controlled warehouses to make it last longer so they can save money at your expense. That's why it turns so quickly after purchase- had some bell peppers one time that were rotten on the inside but looked nice & fresh on the outside. Another time bought bananas that turned from lime green to brown in 2 days- that's when I researched Wal-mart's produce practices.....

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse