VIEWPOINT

A Mother’s Day Uprising

Why the moms of America need a whole lot more than one Sunday a year.

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: RyanC @ 05/22/2009 11:23:31 AM

    ..But now that you mention it, that woman was annoying so I owe you and apology -looks like I got a little knee-jerkish myself. Ah humility.

  • Posted By: RyanC @ 05/22/2009 11:19:40 AM

    (and my first comment referred to two comments ago when you said to quit b*tching -I'll keep the divorce court thing in mind though)

  • Posted By: RyanC @ 05/22/2009 11:14:25 AM

    I wouldn't say totally, but yes, I think to understand people in this world and have successful relationships you have to be a little feminized -so you're right. Try to get over the homophobia of "getting in touch" with your feminine side, or developing a feminine side because you might not have to be condemned to being a single father forever.

  • Posted By: RyanC @ 05/20/2009 4:59:35 PM

    Wow, people. I thought this was a genuinely conceived, well-written, thought provoking article. The only "rant" that I can see coming out of this is from people with sweet nicknames like "jimbo," talk about getting a grip -you poor f'ing thing. Take offense to a 'whiney post' then follow it up with one of your own and show the world how one-dimensional you are -well you can check that off your 'to do' list, Jim (and all the other knee-jerk-reacting, self-righteous dildoes who think that debasing someone's shared life experiences will make them appear so valiant in the eyes of article comment readers everywhere). If you have to lash-out about this article do it in front of an audience that can hear you and see you; just remove your emotion and include a point of your own. It'll make you feel better and you won't come across as having an ego disorder.

    • Posted By: jimbo3800 @ 05/21/2009 10:07:13 PM

      Excuse me, Mr totally feminized male. There is nothing whiney at all about my previous post; it is short, to the point, and based on my life experiences and observations.

  • Posted By: poet059 @ 05/21/2009 12:47:28 AM

    I agree that Mother's Day should be abolished. Not because, as you suggest, one day is inadequate to celebrate the ovarian and uterine talents of certain members of our society ... but because it's so excruciating for women who don't share those talents, but contribute to the world in countless other unseen and uncelebrated ways while all the while yearning for the gift of motherhood. As a woman who has struggled with infertility and who has just endured yet another annual celebration during which the entire universe celebrates what I can't have ... I've had just about enough of listening to mothers complain about how HARD it is. I've spent thousands of dollars, endured painful medical procedures, and shed countless tears in pursuit of what you find so burdensome. Please dial back the martyr routine a bit, and take a moment to be grateful. And have some empathy. A lot of people would give everything they own, and everything they will ever achieve, to be your kind of tired.

  • Posted By: sarahkv01 @ 05/13/2009 1:22:31 PM

    Not sure how anyone WITHOUT children can even comment on HAVING children. You can't miss what you have never had. Only those without kids seem to think their life would be ruined. Pretty selfish, probably shouldn't have kids anyway, you would probably ruin their life as yours seems to be :))

    • Posted By: totallydude @ 05/20/2009 8:04:04 PM

      I don't have kids but I have helped raise a few and I think it more selfish to have kids when you are not ready for them.

  • Posted By: Deesgusted @ 05/09/2009 9:35:54 PM

    Well gee, why don't we just make EVERY DAY MOTHER'S DAY? In fact, why not just make EVERY DAY WOMEN' DAY? In fact, why doesn't the Government just take all the money from all the men and give it ALL to ALL the WOMEN?

    • Posted By: jimbo3800 @ 05/18/2009 8:46:18 PM

      If you ever find yourself in divorce court, you will see exactly that in action. Because in court, and this is important to remember, "all women are victims, and all men are predators". And that is exactly how the system will treat you the second you walk thru the door and without knowing the first thng about you, your wife, or your situation.

    • Posted By: Chaunceythe3rd @ 05/09/2009 10:33:37 PM

      Because they know the women will blow it all at the first sale they find.

      • Posted By: irateredhead2008 @ 05/11/2009 1:00:05 PM

        Not unlike "men" with the first strip joint/porn site/interested 20 yr old floozey they run across? Just thought I'd add that to the mix while we're throwing out inaccurate and insulting sexist drivel. That sort of stereotype of genders a disservice. Not just the one you're currently bashing. If you make statements about others,, you're then stuck with having to embrace all the negative and stupid generalizations that are made about you or be called out for the big-mouthed fool you've shown yourself to be.

    • Posted By: abideinmystery @ 05/10/2009 8:29:03 AM

      deesgusted, you seem to be a very angry person. what do you do to contribute in your household and with your family that makes you so angry?

  • Posted By: D. Marzi @ 05/17/2009 5:52:53 PM

    What makes me angry about this article-and many others- is the fact that the trite subject of whether working moms can "have it all" assumes that it is mothers, not fathers, who are still supposed to be the primary caretakers and the ones who cook meals. I am infuriated by the fact that as progressive as Newsweek is, it still publishes articles like this one, where everything falls on women, not men. How come there are never any articles tirading about how modern fathers can or cannot have it all? How modern fathers can balance work AND raising a family? Articles like this one only support and spread the stereotyped notion that it falls on mothers-whether working or not- to do everything. Why feel the pressure of cooking dinner and taking the kids to soccer practice as kelley suggests; why not talk about how dads should be a part of that? And no, I don't mean merely as "helpers."
    The problem with this article is that is accepts the "natural" assumption that there is extra pressure to be a working mother because you ARE a mother, rather than pressure to be a PARENT, period. Working fathers do not feel that pressure, but it is high time that they do, as they are also a parent.

    • Posted By: jimbo3800 @ 05/18/2009 8:42:48 PM

      As a single father, I take offense at your whiney post. Most dads that I know are, in addition to the primary breadwinner (and gee, that must be because of the 'glass ceiling', huh?) are also heavily involved with their kids and take them to doctors appointments, parent-teacher meetings, etc, etc. What we don't do is constantly grouse about our lot in life, complain insessantly to our friends about how 'stressed' we are, and lay around watching Lifetime, Oxygen, or some other woe-is-me TV channel 24x7.

      Quit your b*tchin and get a grip.

  • Posted By: wyofire @ 05/09/2009 8:26:16 PM

    Happy Mothers Day to all. I'm a single father of a mostly wonderful 9 year old girl. Nope not part time, It's just been the two of us since she was 1 year old. I tip my hat to all you moms. I know it's not always easy but boy some of you sure make it look so.

    • Posted By: wyofire @ 05/13/2009 11:20:35 PM

      Thank you both. I've been kind of shocked reading some of the ultra-hatred on this comment forum. Even though most of us don't know what we are getting into when we step into parenthood. Single or not, It's a weird world that we all try and make the best of and yes we are human. How about we all give everybody a break or maybe a helping hand when it looks like someone cerebellum is about to pop from stress.

    • Posted By: vintner @ 05/11/2009 10:24:39 AM

      Mostly wonderful, LOL! I'm right there with you; my 15 yo is "mostly, uh, wonderful" and I would probably be berated unmercifully if I said that in front of my mostly wonderful female friends. We moms (and women who aren't and are bitter about it) are WAY too hard on moms who make mistakes and get tired. Let's give each other a break, and while we''re at it we should give dads like YOU a break and bring them into the fold. Viva good-enough parenting!

    • Posted By: jlmaly @ 05/10/2009 4:49:08 PM

      Happy Mothers Day to you, too. You've been both. God bless you for that.

  • Posted By: rfk1967 @ 05/13/2009 8:46:17 PM

    Everything costs something. The price of having kids is often the loss of free time, spontaneity, and a boatload of cash, among other things. The price of not having kids is, well, the loss of that whole experience, the love, the pride, the connection. Some people don't want that, and I respect that. I think that if you don't want kids, no one should tell you that you have to have them, that your life is incomplete without them. But I bitterly resent the fact that many people who choose to remain childless feel so free to belittle my choice to have them.

  • Posted By: sgdulac @ 05/09/2009 11:18:02 PM

    I say, you can have kids and ruin your life or you can have dogs and ruin your carpets, I got dogs. And could not be happier.

    • Posted By: NoKidsForMe @ 05/11/2009 9:18:38 PM

      The ruin your life with kids OR ruin your carpet with dogs is my favorite line/joke ever!!! I got my tubes tied at 30 - 4 months before I met my husband. We have 3 dogs, and yes, we got new carpet in June last year. Personally, I think getting new carpet is fun and enjoyable. AND I think having kids not only ruins your life, but probably your carpets, too, as I see at restaurants how kids trow/drop food all over the floor.

  • Posted By: One Tired Mom @ 05/10/2009 12:09:24 PM

    One more comment: he didn't get me one blessed thing. My girls made gifts for me, but nada from him, not even a Happy Mother's Day.

    • Posted By: mamatoria @ 05/11/2009 2:06:54 PM

      Um, leave him? We make our own choices in life, and children learn by what they see and hear. Not only should he man up, but you need to get a backbone. Honestly.

  • Posted By: Deesgusted @ 05/09/2009 10:40:55 PM

    Wah Wah Wah! I'M A WOMAN, AND I AM INDEPENDANT, AS LONG AS YOU MAKE ALL THE EXCEPTIONS FOR ME! NO! I say NO!

    • Posted By: nimodahooligan @ 05/11/2009 1:57:22 PM

      ever been a mother?

      ever been a parent?

      no AND no?

      well then, SHUT UP and go about your life that is devoid of priorities and responsability and please continue to act with such disregard for women and mothers, im sure its really helping your relationship/sex life alot...

      with that out of the way, my mother was/is independent, gave birth to me at the age of 21 while married to a drunken sailor... left him knowing he would never help (and he never did, no child support, no physical support, no emotional support... only emotional/verbal attacks from 3,000 miles away), moved us across the country, put herself through college while working full time and raising me. now she makes a six figure salary, has another child from her second marriage (my little sister who is 10) and is doing it all over again, with a smile on her face to boot.

      apparently mommy wasnt around for you to appreciate all the things that they do and accomplish while your still hanging on her teet you ungrateful little man....

      now, take the bottle out of your mouth, pull up your training diapers, and go to your room and think about what you said.

    • Posted By: irateredhead2008 @ 05/11/2009 1:07:26 PM

      Sounds like most irresponsible college kids I 've met, especially the frat boy types. I know you're here to try to smear women (seriously, I bet you don't get many potential partners male or female with an attitude like that), but what you're describing here is a very immature yet HUMAN tendancy. Not a female tendancy, not a male tendancy. It is human. You've proved this by showing that you are exactly what you are complaining about repeatedly on this board.

  • Posted By: loveforall @ 05/11/2009 12:55:21 PM

    It is sad, the day has come when no one can have an opinion. Everyone's life has a story and no two stories are alike. What we need is understanding, even when we don't know the other person's story. May you all be Blessed Mother's, Father's and those that were not given the chance. What is all the anger for????

  • Posted By: One Tired Mom @ 05/10/2009 12:05:40 PM

    I am so grateful for a holiday that recognizes mothers! I do all the cooking and cleaning in my house, although right now I am looking for work. Just early this morning, about 1:30 am, I had to clean up a trash can that got knocked over, do dishes, and mop the floor. No help from my husband. I took out the trash, etc. He is supposed to be working but as a pizza delivery person, he can't right now because our car is being worked on, so he's out back watching TV and playing his PS3, while I am making sure the kids, cats, and fish are fed, while at the same time doing dishes and laundry yet again, checking my blood sugars as I am diabetic, and trying to get food myself. I even do the catboxes because he won't, although I'm not supposed to, as we are expecting a third child and I run the risk of getting toxoplasmosis. With winter, he trashes the back yard. He didn't lift one finger to get it cleaned up this spring; I did it myself. I mow the lawn, even; something that is SUPPOSED to be a man's job! When there is plumbing work or other house repairs to be done, guess who does it? ME! Yes I love him, he is my husband, but he is the essential eternal teenager.

    So all you men out there who say women don't do enough around the house to deserve ONE day off a year? Kiss mine. Besides, your holiday is coming up next month-or are you saying you don't believe there should be a Father's Day either?

    To bed by three in the morning, up by eight to take care of the kids, while my husband sleeps all day, and spends all night watching TV and playing on his PS3. Hmmm, and I'm irresponsible? All this, while trying to find work as well in an economy that is worker unfriendly.

    • Posted By: irateredhead2008 @ 05/11/2009 12:50:10 PM

      Sounds like you married a boy. Which is unfortunate. I would unplug the PS3 and chuck it out the window or into the sink if I had to ask repeatedly for help with an overflowing workload while my partner sat around playing whatever game after a hard day of NOT being at work .And yes, I was laid off for months last year and terribly depressed about it. Still I didn't sit around playing games, visiting the beach or going shopping while there was work to help with at home. Neither have any of the family oriented neighbors I've had who have also been laid off in the last year or two.

      Tell Boyo to pick up a mop or a cooking pan and get cracking. Or help with the kids' homework. Better yet, schedule an errand so he HAS to sit at home and fuss with a to-do list for a change. If only our obligations stopped when a job did! Then I would have actually enjoyed unemployment 4% more...

    • Posted By: Monado @ 05/10/2009 12:44:36 PM

      Is he unconscious of what needs to be done? If someone else did it when he was growing up, he might be. Can you ask him what he likes in his home environment, e.g. supper, clean sheets, and then give him the frequency and duration of those jobs and ask him which ones he wants to do?

    • Posted By: Monado @ 05/10/2009 12:43:49 PM

      Is he unconscious of what needs to be done? If someone else did it when he was growing up, he might be. Can you ask him what he likes in his home environment, e.g. supper, clean sheets, and then give him the frequency and duration of those jobs and ask him which ones he wants to do?

  • Posted By: maddykins @ 05/10/2009 8:55:53 AM

    what are you all whining about????? at least you ARE MOTHERS. Some of us never had the luxury. What do you think Mothers Day is like for those of us who never or couldnt have any kids?? No one cares about us, dont understand and just tell us to "get over it". Be happy that you have kids, period. And yes, you should have more than just one day.....I just wish that people would be more understanding about those of us who wish we could feel what you are complaining about for just ONE Mothers Day.

    • Posted By: lcube @ 05/11/2009 12:32:22 AM

      I had a very difficult time having my children and definitely relate to & sympathize with your position. It took over 8 years and a lot of heartache. I would not change having them for anything & love them more than anything. My response to these posts is due to posters who are attacking the moms with horrible and ignorant comments. The best things in life don't come easy and have to be worked at. This generation is expected by ourselves and others to do everything and perfectly at that. All I would think would be the best family situation for husband, wife and especially the children is for the parents (mostly failing on the father's side) to work together and a family and have appreciation for all that is done. Instead many of todays men wants to do as little as possible, take advantage that their wives will break their back to keep it all going and then feel they have the right to belittle and complain.

  • Posted By: jwmdyck @ 05/10/2009 10:36:34 AM

    M is for the money that she cost me.
    O is for the other things as well.
    T is for the treats she sometimes tossed me.
    H is for the life she turned to hell.
    E is for each thing she said to hurt me.
    R is for the reasons that she gave

    Put them all together; they spell mother,
    A word to drive a strong man to his grave.


    F is for the fun that I was having.
    A is for ass that I???ve become.
    T is for the time when I was single.
    H is for the home I???m running from.
    E is for the ease with which she caught me.
    R is for the reason I???m so dumb.

    Put them all together; they spell father,
    Convicted of one tiny drop of ***.

  • Posted By: maddykins @ 05/10/2009 9:41:08 AM

    what are you whining about??? at least you ARE mothers. Some of us will never know what its like. Life is hell without children, Be glad you were able to have kids and be a mom. Mothers day is really hard for those of us who dont have kids. I dont go to church on Mothers day, because I dont want to hear the sermon about how kids are a blessing. no one understands the pain of infertility and no one wants to, people just tell you to "get over it". But, Im good to MYSELF on this day, because that helps. I will have foster kids and adopt them, so many kids need a mom....and I need a kid....a perfect match. be lucky you have kids and stop whining......you ARE BLESSED and you dont even know it. take it from someone who wishes she could just spend one Mothers day or ANY day in your shoes. maddykins

  • Posted By: malachite007 @ 05/09/2009 10:42:55 PM

    I am a mother of two (mostly wonderful) children ages 2 & 4. We made the choice as a family that I would leave my field of work and take waitressing job because it provided more flexible hours for me to be with the kids. It's been hard financially (I was the bread winner prior to the children) but we've made it work. My husband is a wonderful man who is as active in the kids lives as time allows and helps maintain the house. He doesn't always do things the way I do or want them done but that's my issue not his. As I write he is in the kitchen preparing a brunch for me and my mom for tomorrow. He has the kids Friday and Saturday nights by himself and I can't tell you how many nights I come home and he says "I don't know how you do it." I tell people my house is only clean 3 times a day (morning before kids are up, nap time, and after bedtime. There is not enough hours in a day and I would much rather run through the sprinker or play with the kids then worry about what I need to "get done." It's not easy and especiaaly not for me as my job was a big part of my identity and self-esteem but to know our kids are being raised the way we want and not by strangers is priceless.

    • Posted By: roxyfoxy72 @ 05/09/2009 11:32:59 PM

      That last part was priceless! I am a stay at home mom of 2 with 1 on the way. I planned on quitting work after my first, but in Ontario, Canada we get 1yr off mat leave provided we worked a certain amount of hours after a mat leave. I ended up pregnant before the year was up so I went back for that purpose. This last time I went back just for the benefits as my husband is self employed. I only worked 15-20hrs a week. I am now off for my 3rd mat leave and I am so grateful to have the chance to stay at home with my children. It was so hard when I was working because my boys are very close to me and Mommy not being available all of the time really affected them. My brother and sister in law both work fulltime and their children are not very close to them at all. Their children could care less if Mom and Dad were going out to work (or vegas for a weekend). Its a very different relationship than what I have with my boys who get upset when I leave and meet me at the door when I return. Some people look down on me because I don't have a "career" or a good paying job. I think my job is the most important of all. I may not do it perfect all of the time, or do it while pulling my hair out, but I do love what I do and believe I am giving my children the best possible chance by being available to them. The government should be doing much more for stay at home moms because they are the ones who are creating the future.

      • Posted By: don'thateonme @ 05/10/2009 9:31:12 AM

        i don't think your sister and brother-in-law working necessarily have anything to do with the kids not being close. that's sometimes the particular family unit. i've had to work and our family has always been close, problems yes, tht;s life, bet we have meals together, we discuss our day and actually listen to each other, our oldest now lives several states away and she still calls when she's having a criss, when she's haveng a fantastic time, when she's having dating issues; it wasn't about working, it was about loving. as far as a lot of the other comments, i personnaly didn't see the anger in the article, it was just a candid article tellling real life moms we are not celebrity scripts, life happens, what you do in your indiviidual relationship is your choice. you don't have to feel bad because you are not a claire huxtable, that's a writer's script. even though my children's friiends called us the huxtable family and when i was grwoing up, our friends called us the cleaver family, it was about values, love, respect and morals, and caring and responsibility being thrown in the mix of every day life.

      • Posted By: tamtam2 @ 05/10/2009 12:12:49 AM

        oh please, that is exactly what the writer is talking about when she says we should just basically all support each other. I work, my husband works and yet we have wonderful children who are very well adjusted and who absolutely do care if we are gone and we definitley haven't been to vegas. As to the person whose mother shot and killed herself and her father, God Bless you. You are right. Sometimes we need a reminder that it's not all about us. May you find peace. I am thankful to have a family and to be where I am at in life and for those in my life. I did enjoy the article.

      • Posted By: tamtam2 @ 05/10/2009 12:12:29 AM

        oh please, that is exactly what the writer is talking about when she says we should just basically all support each other. I work, my husband works and yet we have wonderful children who are very well adjusted and who absolutely do care if we are gone and we definitley haven't been to vegas. As to the person whose mother shot and killed herself and her father, God Bless you. You are right. Sometimes we need a reminder that it's not all about us. May you find peace. I am thankful to have a family and to be where I am at in life and for those in my life. I did enjoy the article.

      • Posted By: tamtam2 @ 05/10/2009 12:10:17 AM

        oh please, that is exactly what the writer is talking about when she says we should just basically all support each other. I work, my husband works and yet we have wonderful children who are very well adjusted and who absolutely do care if we are gone and we definitley haven't been to vegas. As to the person whose mother shot and killed herself and her father, God Bless you. You are right. Sometimes we need a reminder that it's not all about us. May you find peace. I am thankful to have a family and to be where I am at in life and for those in my life. I did enjoy the article.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse