SPONSORED BY:
obama in russia, and russian opposition leader boris nemtsov
Photos: Getty Images
In Moscow, President Obama met with Boris Nemtsov(right) and other opposition leaders.

The Values Gap

How Obama looked past the Kremlin.

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

Barack Obama's schedule during his visit to Moscow was symbolic: after he dedicated the first day to official talks with President Dmitry Medvedev, he spent much of the second day in meetings with representatives of civil-society organizations, the business community, and leaders of the political opposition. With this gesture, the U.S. president sent a clear message that he does not consider Russia to be limited to the ruling circle around Medvedev and Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, and that he intends to "reset" relations not just with the Kremlin, but also with Russian society. This dual-track approach involves discussing urgent practical matters (such as securing a transit route to Afghanistan or agreeing on a joint position on North Korea) with the government of the day, while simultaneously engaging in a broader dialogue on values with the Russian people.

At the meeting with opposition leaders, including myself, Obama reiterated his view that in the 21st century only democracies can be truly successful at home and on the world stage. This question of values, indeed, is among the most difficult obstacles to his declared policy of "resetting" relations with Moscow. For while the United States promotes the ideas of freedom and competition, the current Russian leaders believe in censorship and monopoly in every sphere—politics, ideology, and economy. Politically, the year that has passed since Medvedev formally assumed the presidency has changed nothing: television coverage remains strictly controlled, elections are heavily manipulated, independent political activity is all but forbidden, judges are wholly subservient to the executive. It is clear that, contrary to our Constitution, which assigns the principal power prerogatives to the president, Putin remains the real ruler of Russia.

Economically, monopolization and bureaucratization have led to rampant corruption (according to Transparency International, Russia under Putin has descended to a shameful 147th place in its world corruption index) and has severely crippled our economy. Despite relatively high oil prices, the principal source of Russia's wealth, GDP contracted by 10 percent in April, while industrial production fell by 17 percent in May. Unemployment has already surpassed 10 percent. These are official government figures.

The very fact of Obama's meeting with the leaders of Russia's opposition infuriated the authorities. The signal he sent to Medvedev and Putin by meeting with us is clear: his administration will engage not only with those who are in the Kremlin today, but also with those who may be in the Kremlin tomorrow. In other words, the current rulers do not, in the view of the U.S., possess a monopoly on Russia. And increasingly, the voices of democratically minded Russians are being heard. In April, I ran for mayor of Sochi, host city of the 2014 Winter Olympics. Despite heavy manipulation by the regime during the campaign and of the vote count, I came in second place. The forthcoming legislative elections in Moscow this October will be another test of what the democratic opposition can achieve even in today's repressive environment.

Obama's approach differs greatly from that of his predecessor. When George W. Bush met with representatives of the Russian opposition a few years ago, it was to give us a public lecture on democracy and then walk off the stage. This time, Obama invited us so that he could hear our views on the internal situation in Russia and U.S.-Russia relations. I suggested to him that the necessary precondition for any reset in relations is mutual trust, and no trust is possible while such a pronounced values gap exists between the U.S. and Russian leaders. Indeed, the virulent anti-American propaganda, a constant feature on Russian television for the past several years, ceased for only two days during Obama's stay, and resumed immediately after he left Moscow.

During the meeting we gave Obama a list of Russian political prisoners and copies of expert reports detailing the abuses that characterize Putin's rule. We also raised the case of Mikhail Khodorkovsky, who has been in prison since 2003 on politically motivated charges and whose second trial is now underway in Moscow. The impression I got is that Obama has a good understanding of the contemporary situation in Russia and holds no illusions about the nature of the current regime.

It is, of course, not the job of the U.S. president to establish democracy in Russia. Nor would we want him to—this is a task for us, Russia's democratic opposition. Yet, from the international point of view, it is worth keeping in mind that a democratic Russia would be a much more stable, progressive, and predictable partner for the U.S. and Europe on the world stage than the current authoritarian regime.

Nemtsov is a leader of the solidarity opposition movement and was Deputy Prime Minister of Russia in 1997-98.

© 2009

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Gone Rogue
Gone Rogue

How Sarah Palin hurts the GOP … and America.

The Decade's Best Quotes
The Decade's Best Quotes

NEWSWEEK's 20/10 Project recalls the lines we'll never forget.

Best Celebrity Mugshots
Best Celebrity Mugshots

10 unforgettable arrest photos from the 2000s.

An Evolutionary Edge
An Evolutionary Edge

How grandmas may play favorites.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: TZ192583 @ 07/14/2009 7:20:25 AM

    SALUTE______ on success to reset two major Nuclear Power Presidents??? most recent deal as a first START to agree for a remarkable example for all UN members across the Globe to Cut Weapons, enabling to move ahead to carry on NPT signing of countries having Nuclear-Terror (either by power balancing Nuclear strategists within Middle-East , Gulf, South Asian regions or especially by highly-irresponsible North Korea).

    NO doubt, it???s not an easy and one day task to convert distrust in re-building of TRUST.

    Even, according to a Newsweek report: Putin replied in a steely voice "We cannot stand vraskoryachku,". This rarely used idiom means "an awkward position," Nevertheless, a time will come when Russia and its very short-temporarily allies will unable to take asylum from upcoming WTO, ECO, Financial rules & regulation, and Democratic Globalization along with our visionary NEW Millennium???s International Democratic Regulatory Authority i.e. IDRA (that will be milestone to overcome the global challenges, and as a Bottomline-Institution to resolve various Global solutions-of-Global problems with Democratic Development processing of Freedom of Expression & Free-Market Economy especially for Global Economic & Financial-reforms) under umbrella of a restructured & entirely Democratic UNO with an ???un-biased??? Global participation of each member country without any discriminations of religions, race, colors, languages and nationalities (without any undemocratic Powers & current failures of its Security Council).

    It's my pleasure, pride and honor to highlight the outcome of recent G-8 Summit and Top Brass-Meetings for +2 C 'Institutionalizing' control of climate to work out to save our Human-Planet , and, to laying Fondation STONE -for building Solutions To Nation-Wide Economies for sustainable national, regional & global Development leading to development of a peaceful environment for our generations on this Global Village, under 'outstanding' Political Leadership and a remarkable 'Statesmanship' of President Barack Obama/Obama Administration with Democratic Leadership. I honestly submit here with a historical responsibility that President "OBAMA" & "AMERICA" (under Obama -Administration & Democratic Leadership) emereged to Keep remaining as GLOBAL LEADER (not to control the World, but______) to Lead for Global Solutions-of-Global Problems. No doubt, I have also a pride to remain proud with our Peoples & Generation on this Global Village as a "Part-of-Solutions' and would like to remain contributing, practically, as a member of Democratic Leadership.

    Most important is GLOBAL SUMMIT next year i.e (of course) best decided, will be hosted in Russia for Global Solutions-of-Global Problems especially related with Nuclear Energy.

  • Posted By: jordan c. fan @ 07/13/2009 10:10:09 PM

    Russian President Medvedev Should Come Up With Smart Ideas Similar To Those Of Ex-Soviet Dictator Mikhail Gorbachev

    By: Jordan C. Fan, Prophet of Environment.



    The last entry of this discussion was about the SALT Treaty of nuclear reduction. The following are some extremely intelligent ideas dreamed up by Ex-Soviet Dictator Mikhail Gorbachev which should also be implemented by Medvedev:


    (1) Make sure his name sake Michael Jackson could receive address in Russia so that Mikhail can regain hi power and live in that address.


    (2) Tatooed his own forehead with the map of the Philippines Islands thinking that could make that nation unite with the Soviet Union.


    (3) Put Boris Yeltsin on top of his miliary tanks thinking that could make (Bor)is Yelt(sin) confessed to his (sin)s and a(bor)t his Revolution.


    (4) Invited Osama bin Laden to his Opium smoking party in Afghanistan because he thought whoever has a name starting with an "O" could increase his opium production there.


    (5) Invited Barack Obama to swim with him at his Black Sea resort so that no one could see or rescue Obama when he was drowning.


    (6) Didn't believe in the possible success of Reaganomic because Gorbachev thought Reagan was just acting.


    (7) "Tear down that (Berlin) Wall!" so that Russian tanks could roll into West Berlin.


    (8) Gorbachev thought China are only cups and dishes for drinking and eating. He was perfectly comfortable when China was rising and even enjoyed it thinking it was an act in the "Mary Poppins" movie.


    (9) Supported Soviet boycott of the Los Angeles Olympic anticipating earthquakes would destroy California. It would certainly save him money by not using nuclear missiles.


    (10) Replace Russian Black Market with his own "Free Market" to put African-American spy network in the Soviet Union out of business. Or is it really a "Flea Market"?


    (11) Endorsed the SALT Treaty thinking it was just a requisition for condiments. As a result all his nuclear missiles were destroyed.

  • Posted By: Reg373 @ 07/12/2009 12:05:53 PM

    You get to employ a carrot + stick approach when you are talking. When you isolate, it's just stick. So the opposite side hardens, and 3rd parties don't come over to your side of the matter -- found a cool site; Balkingpoints ; incredible satellite view of earth

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now