
0.cached.png
By Anna Husarska
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Three subjects dominate the news from Afghanistan these days: the Anglo-American offensive in Helmand province, the election planned for Aug. 20, and the constant attacks on schools. The three issues may seem unrelated. In fact, they're directly connected.
Start with the link between the election and the military offensive. Trying to secure the country ahead of next month's ballot is, according to British and American politicians, one of the main reasons the Coalition has stepped up its efforts in recent weeks. Already the push has resulted in more casualties—but this was bound to happen around the election anyway, even without a new Coalition assault. Whether the operation is actually working is much less clear. So far, the insurgents have not put up much of a fight, often melting back into the civilian population or slipping away to the hitherto relatively peaceful north and west when the Coalition strikes.
The connection be-tween the Helmand offensive and the attacks on schools is also clear. The insurgents are doing what guerrillas tend to do when confronted by overwhelming firepower: use whatever tools are available (in this case, improvised explosive devices), attack easy targets, and hit where it hurts most—by killing the innocent.
Read More on World
As for the link between the school attacks and the upcoming election, this might seem less obvious, but the connection is just as direct. To understand it, you must first recognize that Afghanistan is not a simple postconflict situation; it is a country at war. On one side are the Afghan government and the Coalition forces. On the other are the insurgents. Caught in the middle are the Afghan civilians.
The security situation today is deteriorating: when I visited Afghanistan recently after a year away, the signs were everywhere, in the extra barriers and checkpoints and the shrinking space for humanitarian organizations to operate. According to one security expert in Kabul, until a few years ago Afghanistan was a stable country with pockets of instability. Now it is an unstable country with pockets of stability. Even the Afghan Interior Ministry concedes as much: the color-coded maps it uses for briefings with foreign journalists show that broad swaths of the country—including Helmand, Kandahar, Nimroz, and Uruz-gan provinces—are now firmly, partly, or intermittently under the control of the government's enemies (not all of whom are hard-core insurgents; some are freelancers).
These armed opposition groups view all state employees, their offices, administrative build-ings, health centers, and schools as symbols of the hated regime and of the invader—and hence as legitimate targets. Elections are anathema to the guerrillas; a Taliban spokesman made this plain when he said in June that "we will double our efforts to sabotage the elections anywhere in the country." My Afghan colleagues at the International Rescue Committee report that insurgents now regularly leave "night letters" in public places warning communities of dire consequences if they dare take part in the upcoming vote.
All of which highlights the irresponsibility of the Afghan election commission's plans to set up polling stations in schools and health centers, especially in Afghanistan's unstable east and south. Earlier this year, international and nongovernmental organizations cautioned that bringing ballots into clinics would endanger patients and health workers by exposing them to attack. Insurgents have already destroyed two health centers, in Kunar and Kandahar, that were being used for voter registration. In May, the Afghan government dropped its plan to use health centers as polling stations. But no such decision has been made—yet—about schools.
This means that the insurgents, who have already thrown acid in schoolgirls' faces, attacked others with poison, and repeatedly threatened educational institutions with violence, will have one additional reason to target schools. That could be avoided in the most volatile parts of the country by putting polling stations in banks or courthouses instead, or in tents, as was done in Bosnia.
A humbling postscript: during my recent visit, I went to the Bibi Aisha High School in the eastern town of Jalalabad. It has 4,900 pupils, all female. We did not discuss military offensives or the election; instead, I asked them what they wanted to do after graduation. Half of them said they aspired to be teachers. I was elated by such a defiant response; these young women are bound to bring positive change and some gender equality to Afghanistan, despite the insurgents' best efforts. Yet when school was over and the girls got up to leave, I was stunned to see every single one of them reach under her desk for a blue burqa. It was a potent reminder of the way things still work in Afghanistan.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines