The Ethanol Backlash

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

While I'm as susceptible to Malthusian thoughts as the next paranoid guy, I find much of the anti-ethanol case to be unpersuasive. In each instance, the haters would have us look at ethanol, and the ill effects its greater use would assuredly produce, largely in isolation. Might the production of corn ethanol cause pollution? Of course. Is it worse than the sort of pollution created by other types of energy production—i.e., coal and oil? Probably not. Does greater use of corn for ethanol help spur price increases for food? Sure, but so do many other factors, like, say, the transformation of China from a subsistence farming economy into a more modern one. Is ethanol more inefficient, and hence more costly, than gasoline? Yes. But our heavy use of gasoline imposes all sorts of other costs—from pollution to the hundreds of billions of dollars we spend each year in Iraq. Factor those in, and ethanol no longer seems like such an economic loser. Finally, the long-term worries of the ethanol haters are in large measure based on the assumption that ethanol will continue to grow for many years at the same blistering pace it has recently. Such proclamations of boundless growth, which are a recurring feature of bubbles, frequently don't materialize as promised. Remember Dow 36,000?

© 2007

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
NEWSWEEK's 20/10
NEWSWEEK's 20/10

Our decade-in-review project recalls the highs and lows of the last 10 years.

Obama's Promises
Obama's Promises

Is the new president fulfilling his campaign pledges? Or falling short?

The Decade in 7 Minutes
The Decade in 7 Minutes

Video: A fast-paced review of the best and worst moments. Don't blink.

Accidental Celebrities
Accidental Celebrities

From Levi Johnston to Elian Gonzalez, these people never expected to be in the spotlight.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: SacramentoE85 @ 07/04/2009 1:41:53 PM

    American made ethanol.

    E85 ethanol fuel in my Flex Fuel Vehicle.

    No soldiers died for my fuel
    Today on Independence Day 7/04/09
    Nor any other day of the year!

  • Posted By: SacramentoE85 @ 07/03/2008 1:23:39 AM

    I certainly would not want to switch dependence on imported oil from OPEC to dependence on imported ethanol from South America. Just as Brazil built their ethanol industry with subsidies and protection, so will the United States continue to do so. Besides, Brazil already had a tariff-free way to export to the U.S. through a Carribean trade agreement, but failed to get close to meeting the amount allowed during 2007. Thus, removing the tariff would have done nothing to increase imports from Brazil in 2007. Big Oil would like to see imports from Brazil bankrupt the U.S. ethanol industry, buy up Brazilian ethanol production, and continue their reign of control over the fuel business. Shell and BP are looking into ways to buy up Brazilian ethanol production right now, while working to remove the tariffs. Brazilian ethanol on the world market will be good to keep the price of ethanol in check; yet the U.S. needs to continue to use primarily domestically produced ethanol. No sense switching one problem for another. --SacramentoE85

  • Posted By: almir @ 07/01/2008 11:34:09 PM

    (continuing previous post): In comparison to corn-based American ethanol or biodiesel derived from soybean oil, ethanol from sugarcane do not compete with food and is not subjected to cost pressure. Actually Brazilian food production has doubled in the past decade.

    Another persuasive fact for incentiving ethanol production in Brazil is the electric energy that is generated as a by-product of ethanol processing: taking into consideration the energetic balance, the electricity generated in sugar cane processing in Brazil is almost as large as its ethanol equivalence. It's like a two large scale hydroelectric plants generating electricity exactly when it's more necessary: in the Brazilian dry season! So the producers of ethanol are also having increasing revenues by selling electricity to the country's national electric system, which has become an strategic and reliable source of electricity. For all these reasons, ethanol in Brazil is a win-win game for the country, the farmers, the consumers and the environment.

    Off course Brazilian ethanol does not intend to concur with petroleum, but it could ease up current oil crisis by supplying a small part of the world energy demand. It is only necessary to look at the increasing demand from the non-oil countries like India and China to understand that the very high price of oil is here to stay. With the existing price of oil, the permanent threat of war in the Middle East, the international geopolitics, and the environmental problems, there seems to be no other easy solution for the energy problem away from the liquid ethanol produced out of sugarcane. This is certainly a very important aspect of the Brazilian economy for the next few years and the rest of the world will have to accept the reality of the liquid ethanol from sugarcane as the right and best solution for the oil crisis.

    The problem is that much of Brazil???s ethanol exports continues to face prohibitive tariffs and other barriers to developed markets in the US and Europe. The United States currently places a 54-cent-a-gallon tariff on ethanol imported from Brazil. Consumers in the country are being severely affected, particularly in areas such as the Southeast, where corn does not exist and the logistics to bring ethanol from the center of the country is practically impossible. It is difficult to understand the maintenance these tariff levels, except for political reasons. The developed world appears purposely myopic in relation to the opportunities Brazil presents, maybe it's because that would upset wealthy US and European farmers ??? a price apparently not worth paying.

    Almir R. Américo ??? Sao Paulo, Brazil (almiramerico@gmail.com)

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse