Fact or Fiction?

Do Hand Sanitizers Work?

Lots of us carry little bottles of these alcohol-based gels to use as an alternative to hand washing, but do they work as well as soap and water?

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Janey594 @ 09/24/2009 10:26:25 AM

    Only anti-viral or very high alcohol hand sanitizers protect you. Most products in stores are only anti-bacterial...flu strains and pandemics are caused by viruses so these products offer no protection. I am a nurse and was at a conference yesterday I tried a product called Mentholatum responsebeta it is an anti-viral hand sanitizer that claims to be scientifically tested to kill H1N1 Influenza A Virus (swine Flu) as well as other viruses and bacteria (including E-coli) that I could potientially come into contact with daily. I got a free sample but would recommed that we all protect ourselves and others from the spread of viruses and bacteria. Prevention is better than cure after all. It ticks all the boxes. It is only available from boots however their website is www.mentholatumresponsebeta.co.uk where you can see exactly how and what is protects against.

  • Posted By: gracej @ 09/16/2009 5:25:33 PM

    I just learned that you should be washing your hands just as frequently as putting on hand sanitizer. <a href="http://purellhandsanitizers.com/">Hand sanitizer</a> is less effective unless you are washing your hands frequently. Originally designed for doctors in hospitals who wash their hands all the time.

  • Posted By: explorr @ 02/18/2009 4:03:44 PM

    I started using a "green" corn ethanol based hand sanitizer gel by It'sCleanUSA.
    They also have their own portable silverware cleaning wipes thats ingestible for dining out. This is GREAT when your at a restaurant and the flatware has been sitting on the table for who know how long. I forgot which stores have it but my wife orders it at www.itscleanusa.com

  • Posted By: thegerminator @ 10/30/2008 8:40:04 PM

    Yeah, I've used SkinWear too, and it really works. Their official website is skinwearusa.com. You can buy it there.

  • Posted By: aztoca @ 02/23/2008 11:42:39 PM

    www.HandHealthUSA.com or www.SkinWearWestCoast.com The only product you need. It is not alcohol based and it kills germs and bacteria up to 8 hours. Check out the site and read for yourself. I use it everyday!

  • Posted By: ItKillsGerms.com @ 01/31/2008 1:37:53 AM

    Wash your hands and wash them regularly. Friction, water, and repitition are the best solutions to removing the microbes and germs that cause illness. When you don't have water you can use the alternative, gels and foams. Purell, GermX, PureWorks by ItKillsGerms.com and mony other products are a good solution for maintaining healthy skin and can be used as a part of anyones hygiene regimen.

  • Posted By: ItKillsGerms.com @ 01/31/2008 1:36:44 AM

    Wash your hands and wash them regularly. Friction, water, and repitition are the best solutions to removing the microbes and germs that cause illness. When you don't have water you can use the alternative, gels and foams. Purell, GermX, PureWorks by ItKillsGerms.com and mony other products are a good solution for maintaining healthy skin and can be used as a part of anyones hygiene regimen.

  • Posted By: janiceb @ 11/24/2007 2:33:17 PM

    Washing with soap and water is always the smart defensive strategy. But those subscribing to CDC's 1996 hand hygiene recommendations i.e. "use alcohol-based hand sanitizer gels" are exposing themselves to a set of dangerous problems. Amazing that CDC makes no updated mention of alcohol-free hand sanitizers introduced during past 6 or 7 years, including Soapopular. These products are as effective and SAFER.

  • Posted By: janiceb @ 11/24/2007 2:30:34 PM

    Absolutely-WASH YOUR HANDS.. But that's not always convenient. The CDC hand hygiene recommendations haven't been updated since 1996--and anyone that is subscribing to outdated recommendations re: alcohol-based hand sanitizer gels is making a potentially dangerous mistake. Newer, alcohol-free hand sanitizing products, including those made by Soapopular, are as effective and safer!

  • Posted By: aztoca @ 11/03/2007 12:53:07 AM

    Modern technology has allowed us to now offer an antibacterial hand cleansing gel that kills germs and bacteria for up to 8 hours without any alcohol. SkinWear! Go to www.SkinWearWestCoast.com This is an amazing product that is biodegradable and non-toxic. SkinWear is also a soil repelent and moisturizer. It blocks soilants such as dyes, paint, grease, oils, dirt and much more from absorbing into the skin, therefore, making washing your hands much easier.

  • Posted By: kuroshio @ 10/28/2007 7:33:52 PM

    In order for alcohol to have any antiseptic effectiveness it must soak for 10 minutes, fact. The effectiveness of alcohol-based gels like purell is based mostly on the quick drying time of alcohol, which in itself kills most bacteria. C-Diff is one of the only ones its not effective on. So, in closing, yes it is effective. And if you blow your nose or sneeze into your hand, GO WASH YOUR HANDS!

    • Posted By: love2stamp @ 10/29/2007 7:25:33 PM

      Also, let's get better about sneezing...sneeze into your ARM, not your hands.

  • Posted By: DSisson @ 10/26/2007 4:01:16 PM

    Wow! That sure was informative..................................

    • Posted By: vmartin65 @ 10/27/2007 1:35:06 AM

      do you think you people could learn to spell??

    • Posted By: vmartin65 @ 10/27/2007 1:34:28 AM

      do you think you people could learn to spell?

  • Posted By: shenyin @ 10/27/2007 12:46:04 AM

    i believe sanitizers works well

  • Posted By: shenyin @ 10/27/2007 12:41:07 AM

    i believe sanitizers works well.

  • Posted By: love2stamp @ 10/26/2007 9:53:43 PM

    There's no data that suggests that hand sanitizers kill viruses, so using them after you sneeze because of a cold probably wouldn't do a damn thing.

  • Posted By: scirdan @ 10/26/2007 5:31:33 PM

    It seems that hand sanitizers would be a good alternative when one would normally not be washing their hands at all. An example is sitting at your desk and blowing your nose. Most people would never go to the washroom to wash their hands, but hand sanitizers should prevent the spreading of a cold at leest a little bit

  • Posted By: scirdan @ 10/26/2007 5:31:30 PM

    It seems that hand sanitizers would be a good alternative when one would normally not be washing their hands at all. An example is sitting at your desk and blowing your nose. Most people would never go to the washroom to wash their hands, but hand sanitizers should prevent the spreading of a cold at leest a little bit

  • Posted By: scirdan @ 10/26/2007 5:31:29 PM

    It seems that hand sanitizers would be a good alternative when one would normally not be washing their hands at all. An example is sitting at your desk and blowing your nose. Most people would never go to the washroom to wash their hands, but hand sanitizers should prevent the spreading of a cold at leest a little bit

  • Posted By: scirdan @ 10/26/2007 5:16:48 PM

    It seems that hand sanitizers would be a good alternative when one would normally not be washing their hands at all. An example is sitting at your desk and blowing your nose. Most people would never go to the washroom to wash their hands, but hand sanitizers should prevent the spreading of a cold at leest a little bit

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse