SPONSORED BY:

How Brazil Reversed the Curse

 

Email To A Friend

Please fill in the following information and we'll email this link.

Separate multiple addresses with commas

SPONSORED BY
 

The most rigorous of the CCT schemes is the decade-old Chile Solidario, which awards small two-year grants to families who must not only keep their children in school but also report to social workers and look for jobs. Mexico's Oportunidades, begun in 2002, tracks the progress of some 5 million families on a sophisticated computer database, which has caught the attention of officials from Ankara to New York. After a visit to Mexico, New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg launched his own version, Opportunity NYC, last March. The grandest scheme by far is Brazil's Bolsa Família, or the Family Stipend, which gives some 11.1 million families—nearly a quarter of the 183 million population—up to $50 a month for an unspecified period. (Officials are still debating a cutoff point.) Several stipend programs had been launched in the mid-'90s but they were unified and spread across Brazil after 2003, under the government of Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.

Economists generally applaud targeted cash transfers on the ground that paying the poor to improve their own lot is far more efficient than throwing money at top-heavy poverty-relief bureaucracies. It is also far cheaper. A textbook case is Brazil, where the government spends more than $500 billion, close to half its GDP, on social programs such as the loss-making pension system that mostly benefits the nonpoor. "With Bolsa Família you reach a quarter of the population by spending just 1 percent of GDP," says Neri. "That's a far better deal." Because of its sharper focus on the poor, Bolsa Família was just as effective in lowering Brazilian inequality as the massive pension system, at only a fifth the cost, Neri says.

Not everyone agrees, of course. In the wrong hands, aid can easily turn into an old-fashioned populist handout. Nicaragua's Zero Hunger project gives families a cow and three chickens, which is unlikely to change lives, while studies show Brazilian leaders crank up the stipend awards around election time. More worrisome, much less attention has been paid to getting people off the stipend. "There's something wrong when 50 million people are getting income transfers," says economist Eduardo Giannetti of Ibmec, a São Paulo business school. "I fear that Bolsa Família is being sold as a way of life and not as an emergency aid program." Skeptics also point out that the rising poor may sink again if the Brazilian economy softens and the government supply of cash dries up.

Longer-term, transforming society will take much more. "We have to improve education in order to see a real reduction in inequality," says Naércio Menezes, an education specialist at Ibmec. If not, critics warn, globalization can actually worsen the opportunity gap. "As countries grow faster and globalize, there's going to be increasing demand for people with tech skills. Unless the education system is geared to meeting those needs, you'll [find] that the benefits will go to a narrow group of people, and inequality will increase," says the IMF's Singh. And Belindia will re-emerge.

With Monica Campbell in Mexico City

© 2007

Label

Newsweek Top Stories
Visions of a Decade
Visions of a Decade

From 2000-2009, one photo per month.

The Failure of Copenhagen
The Failure of Copenhagen

Why there could be a silver lining in a failed climate treaty.

Sex Scandals of the 2000s
Sex Scandals of the 2000s

From John Edwards to Mark Sanford, the decade's memorable affairs.

118 Days in Hell
118 Days in Hell

A NEWSWEEK journalist recounts his captivity in Iran.

Discuss

Sponsored by

Member Comments

  • Posted By: gfinetti @ 10/14/2009 11:11:16 AM

    i´m sorry, kaitiepie, but Brazil don´t match your nessecities. brazil had a year inflation of about 20%. Those who had, by the time, money saved prospered putting it into government titles of short time wich used to pay 40% a year. It´s easy to make money like that, isn´t it?

    This explain why GINI is still so horrendous here although decreasing.

    Hope i´ve helped!

  • Posted By: gfinetti @ 10/14/2009 11:09:29 AM

    i´m sorry, kaitiepie, but Brazil don´t match your nessecities. brazil had a year inflation of about 20%. Those who had, by the time, money saved prospered putting it into government titles of short time wich used to pay 40% a year. It´s easy to make money like that, isn´t it?

    This explain why GINI is still so horrendous here although decreasing.

    Hope i´ve helped!

  • Posted By: kaitiepie @ 08/30/2009 1:32:35 AM

    Hi! Im currently writing a report on the history of Hyper Inflated economies, and Brazil is one of the countries that I am researching. I was wondering since you live there if you could help me with a topic? Part of the research Im conducting is to see what investment strategies were successful during this period of high inflation, or who prospered. Although most people dont during periods of high inflation, there tend to be a small percentage that do. I am writing this report in the event that the U.S. faces a similiar situation of high inflation and providing research on how some have been able to protect themselves against it. Any help on the subject you could provide would be great! THank you!

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

My Take

Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage
to feature your favorite columnists.

Customize Now