The Writing On The Wall

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: amfm @ 11/04/2007 2:42:37 PM

    My daughter is 4 and attends a montessori school where cursive writing is taught at the same time as printed letters. It appears very much to help minimize her reversing both letters and numbers and is teaching her an ease with expressing herself. I am glad to see that others are taking this seriously.

  • Posted By: debmark1211 @ 11/04/2007 2:37:12 PM

    As a mother of four children, 3 of which are graduated, I was completely shocked to learn that my youngest cannot even sign his name properly. As a sophmore in high school, I thought that, like my other three, he could sign his name. When I questioned him about it he said that his teachers didnt care how he wrote his name as long as it was on the paper. I later confirmed this with the teachers at his school that cursive writing was no longer a priority. I say shame!!! I dont see how that cursive writing can affect your inability to express yourself. On the contrary, cursive handwriting is a lost art form in itself. If it wasn't a way to express yourself, would not everyone write the same way, like we were taught? As a child wanting to impress my elders, I can remember practicing for hours how to perfect my cursive letters. Not because it was required, but because I wanted to. I thought it was neat how you didnt have to stop and start to form a whole word. When my youngest child prints, it looks like something a fourth grader would write. No offense to any fourth grader, but he is in tenth grade. He brought home a paper last week where the teacher had written(in cursive) "good penmanship". What? Suffice it to say, my tenth grader brought it home because he couldn't read what it said. I guess the old adage is true,"practice, practice, practice".

  • Posted By: RON-CAT @ 11/04/2007 2:34:50 PM

    Thank's for bringing the handwritting issue up. The pen and paper will keep a little more what we want too remember, in mine.

  • Posted By: swgrad @ 11/04/2007 2:26:20 PM

    It seems our researchers are discovering what the Chinese have known for centuries, that writing is a physical manifestation of the intellect and even the soul of a man. There are still adults today, in China, who practice their writing for a half hour of so each day. It is a little like the daily walk, in that I keeps ones mind and body healthy and expressive.

  • Posted By: magrob @ 11/04/2007 2:07:37 PM

    Somewhere, in the bottom of my mom's cedar chest, I have my penmanship pin from completing the "Palmer Method of American Cursive Writing". It came as part of a kit that included: a Sheaffer's cartridge-filled fountain pen, an instructional workbook, and a fifty-page writing pad that had primary-writing ruled paper. These days, I still write with a Sheaffer's fountain pen but it didn't come in a blister-pack and it doesn't use cartridges for its ink. Fountain pens are more comfortable to use if you do a great deal of writing. Plus, they don't give you as much of a "writer's cramp" as ballpoint pens. Over the years, I have developed my own style of cursive writing. But, I still feel a bit of a twinge when my cursive letters don't look like the text-book Palmer letters.

  • Posted By: magrob @ 11/04/2007 2:07:14 PM

    Somewhere, in the bottom of my mom's cedar chest, I have my penmanship pin from completing the "Palmer Method of American Cursive Writing". It came as part of a kit that included: a Sheaffer's cartridge-filled fountain pen, an instructional workbook, and a fifty-page writing pad that had primary-writing ruled paper. These days, I still write with a Sheaffer's fountain pen but it didn't come in a blister-pack and it doesn't use cartridges for its ink. Fountain pens are more comfortable to use if you do a great deal of writing. Plus, they don't give you as much of a "writer's cramp" as ballpoint pens. Over the years, I have developed my own style of cursive writing. But, I still feel a bit of a twinge when my cursive letters don't look like the text-book Palmer letters.

  • Posted By: same @ 11/04/2007 2:01:01 PM

    The written word has the power that no other method of communication has. If you write a letter, that would be handwritten, to your parent or child they will remember it for longer and teasure it more than any card or e-card that you could ever send.

  • Posted By: Greenoaks @ 11/04/2007 1:50:56 PM

    I attended school in Oak Lawn, Illinois. Handwriting was crucially important, as our teachers gave various assignments requiring us to handwrite many papers. I remember our most crucial 8th grade assignment had very explicit guidelines which had to be followed and counted for two-thirds of our final grade in English. The assignment was to choose a career which we intended to follow We were required to have three hard-covered books on the chosen career, with notes taken in our own words--no plagerism allowed, a properly formatted bibliography, and the final product: the paper in our own words, in our own handwriting. I worked on it for three weeks straight, every day after school until dinner and every night after dinner until 11:00-11:30 until it was complete. My teacher told me that I was writing at a college level. I received an A+ for that paper and was very proud of my efforts and the grade I received. I wonder how the kids of today would fare with the very same assignment (equivalent to a college level assignment in 8th grade).--that was back in 1959 and up north. It was most beneficial to each and every one of us.

  • Posted By: JosephWisdom @ 11/04/2007 1:48:42 PM

    I find I am far more impressed by a hand written card or letter... especially if I know the person has a computer and a printer. It shows me that they really cared and wanted to take the time and sacrifice to get their point across. A handwritten card or letter is like looking into someones eyes. You can see more of who they are.

  • Posted By: jojoc10 @ 11/03/2007 9:35:35 PM

    I wonder if this article was typed or handwritten?

    • Posted By: PrairieMom @ 11/04/2007 10:28:35 AM

      We are in a society that is completely thrown when the power goes out! Bottom line is everyone should have a back up resource of communication and handwriting works well for that.
      However, let's be real. In this age, computers rock the world and even older grandparents who grew up without this incredible technology, are learning the daily need for it!

      • Posted By: nursewelch @ 11/04/2007 1:46:53 PM

        I love to write leters and have done so for years. One of he first things I taught my children to do was to write lettrs to their grandparents especilally thank-you notes. The grandparents have treasured these notes and kept them for years. My husband on the other hand could not write a two page letter to his mother if his life depended on it. He often chides me for writing 19-12 pages to my mother where I cover evertything from the meals to the garden. I think it makes her feel like she is with us with these letters. My handwriting is not the greatest, and many times I use the computer, but sto;; try to give a letter that counts. Unfrortunately my daughter has learning problems and the spell check and computer have been her salvation. Still I encourage her to look at writing as a means of cmmunication. Like someone wonce said. " My favorite modern invention is the pencil", and I find that true with writing.I still ama abele

  • Posted By: Carolean @ 11/04/2007 1:19:41 PM

    I used to have very nice handwriting, very legible, and I have always been higher than average in grammer, spelling, and sentence structure. However, I am also over 100 wpm on a typewriter (computer) keyboard, having been a typist for many, many years. Now I have rheumatoid arthritis and find it very difficult to handwrite, and significantly easier to type.

    • Posted By: Carolean @ 11/04/2007 1:45:35 PM

      I'm replying to myself. Guess I should have done a better job of proofreading since I misspelled "grammar." Good thing no one I know will be reading this!!!!

  • Posted By: michelle_b_may @ 11/04/2007 1:39:01 PM

    I live in Pierce County, WA and teachers have told several of my friends that they no longer teach cursive writing because things are "done mostly on computers now".

  • Posted By: michelle_b_may @ 11/04/2007 1:37:37 PM

    Actually, in WA State, handwriting is not taught at all. Teachers have told several friends of mine that they don't teach cursive writing because "everything is done mostly on computers now".

  • Posted By: Architect @ 11/04/2007 10:19:21 AM

    Mind your p's and q's is not about handwriting it is about minding your pints and quarts when you work in an Old English tavern.

    • Posted By: socal john @ 11/04/2007 1:13:52 PM

      'Tis true!

    • Posted By: lbopeep @ 11/04/2007 12:30:44 PM

      "Mind your p's and q's" is from the Guttenberg press era when individual backward letters were placed in the press. As they were removed from the press and placed in cases (upper and lower) it was important not to get the p's and q's in the wrong cases. It didn't matter how many pints or quarts you had, you still needed to watch your letters.

  • Posted By: socal john @ 11/04/2007 1:05:04 PM

    I was educated in the fifties here in California. Back then penmanship was VERY important with drills everyday! They used to put three white lines on the chalkboard for us to practice our cursive writing . Handwriting is patently dead these days. I remember how much I looked forward to writing and receiving love letters. There's nothing like a love letter with a hint of perfume on it!! It becomes VERY personal! Emails don't quite convey that message of intimate moments.

  • Posted By: nothingbutyael @ 11/04/2007 1:02:17 PM

    I completely agree, as a student currently enrolled in high school. I see the firsthand effects of public education's failure. My peers still lack the ability to spell correctly, or even understand how to read script! I am one of the lucky ones who were taught the proper methods of penmanship, but it sickens me to see others with child-like handwriting still.

  • Posted By: nothingbutyael @ 11/04/2007 1:02:10 PM

    I completely agree, as a student currently enrolled in high school. I see the firsthand effects of public education's failure. My peers still lack the ability to spell correctly, or even understand how to read script! I am one of the lucky ones who were taught the proper methods of penmanship, but it sickens me to see others with child-like handwriting still.

  • Posted By: nothingbutyael @ 11/04/2007 1:01:23 PM

    I completely agree, as a student currently enrolled in high school. I see the firsthand effects of public education's failure. My peers still lack the ability to spell correctly, or even understand how to read script! I am one of the lucky ones who were taught the proper methods of penmanship, but it sickens me to see others with child-like handwriting still.

  • Posted By: socal john @ 11/04/2007 12:58:47 PM

    I was educated in the fifties. We were taught to form each letter with specifics as to how far above or below the lines they should protrude. The blackboards back then had three white lines on them so we could practice in front of the class. Letter writing is patently dead these days. When was the last time you got a love letter in the mail? Just a thought. I use to look forward to them. I could smell the perfume on them. It was VERY personal. Ever smell perfume on an email???

  • Posted By: wawaluvr @ 11/04/2007 12:14:44 PM

    I began meeting with my son's teachers in middle school (at my request, not theirs) about his handwriting and spelling. I was consistantly told that neither would matter when he reach college. He is now a student at a local technical college where he was advised several weeks ago by his English instructor to drop the class because of his handwriting and spelling. I think it is nearly criminal that our public education system is so out of touch with the requirements of our nation's colleges. Or maybe they just don't care very much about our children.

    • Posted By: sapphire43 @ 11/04/2007 12:55:09 PM

      Wow, wawaluvr -- I don't care about our children? That is why my husband and I both have dedicated our lives to teaching high school and middle school, respectively. Receiving no respect for our career choices because we are "only teachers" (I've heard this from PARENTS, to my face!) In many cases I, and the other teachers, are the only "adult" influence these children have. I try to stress handwriting in my Social Studies classes, and have the support of the administration, but I receive ALL of my complaints from parents. Perhaps if parents don't like their childrens' handwriting they should do what I did (and what my parents did for me) and teach it themselves. I agree it is vital, but please don't make the teachers your scapegoats, we have enough problems already!

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse