Death in Perugia

Italians are calling it casa degli orrori: house of horrors. It seems an unlikely name for the little villa at 7 Via della Pergola, here in the medieval city of Perugia. Part of a 17th-century palazzo, the house shares the neighborhood's air of decadent opulence, with a terrace overlooking the red and gold foliage of a lush Umbrian valley and glimpses of a medieval wall from its green shuttered windows. But it was in this now notorious residence—currently surrounded by red and white police tape—that Meredith Kercher, a 21-year-old British student, died an agonizing death in what investigators say was a gruesome sex crime.

Follow your favorite NEWSWEEK columnists

Customize the Newsweek homepage to feature the latest word from your favorite columnists.

 

Death in Italy

Barbie Nadeau

An Italian judge believes that a young Seattle woman instigated a vicious 'extreme sex' killing. Her student friends say she is just a dorky sweetheart. Deconstructing the grim tale of Amanda Knox.

Amanda Knox's Shaky Defense Team

Knox Takes the Stand

Italy Gears Up for Amanda Knox Trial Frenzy

Defending Amanda Knox

Sex Murder Prison Diaries

Murder Most Wired

Fourth Suspect in Kercher Murder

 

Three people have been arrested in connection with the killing: Kercher's 20-year-old American roommate, Amanda Knox; Knox's 24-year-old Italian boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito; and 38-year-old Congolese bar owner and musician Diya Lumumba, known locally as Patrick. Authorities are searching for a fourth person who may have been in the apartment, possibly a man seen on a closed-circuit TV tape nearby on the night of the killing, or a woman—there was a high-heel shoeprint left on the scene that does not match the victim or Knox.

The case has riveted Europe, tapping into prurient curiosity as more sordid details leak out from judicial documents as well as partisan political divisions in a nation divided over immigration. A 19-page report, released by investigating judge Claudia Matteini, tells a squalid tale of dangerous sex games and a disturbing tale about Knox, the blond, blue-eyed student from Seattle who adopted the online name "Foxy Knoxy." According to Matteini, "something went wrong" after the three suspects tried to get Kercher to submit to violent group sex. The judicial officer, saying that Kercher was tortured and repeatedly sexually assaulted, speculates that Knox held Kercher down while Sollecito, Lumumba and the mystery fourth suspect assaulted her. Forensic evidence shows that Kercher's neck was lightly scratched twice with a knife before a third and fatal swipe slit her throat. The coroner's office believes that she was conscious during the two painful hours it took her to die, but that her injuries made it impossible for her to call for help. Matteini surmises that the suspects wanted "to try a new sensation" when they initiated the sex. "And in the face of the victim's refusals they did not have the presence of mind to desist, but tried to force the will of the girl, using a knife that Sollecito always carried with him," she writes.

As the British and Italian media went into frenzies over the saga, they gleefully singled out Knox as the real villain in the tale. The judge wrote that she believes Knox instigated the sexual attack; one British tabloid called her a "maneater with mommy issues." Other papers published numerous Facebook and MySpace pictures posted by Knox—and mentioned in the judge's papers—showing the student with drug paraphernalia and pointing what appears to be a machine gun at the camera. Knox, who was studying creative writing and Italian, also apparently published on her MySpace page, now shut down, a turgid story she wrote about rape. At one point Kyle, the rapist in the story, tells his brother Edgar, "A thing you have to know about chicks is that they don't know what they want." The story continues, "Kyle winked his eye. 'You have to show it to them. Trust me. In any case,' [sic] He cocked his eyebrows up and one side of his mouth rose into a grin. 'I think we both know hard A is hardly a drug'."

In Seattle a more complex picture of Knox has emerged. Local court records show she was fined last summer for a "residential disturbance" during a party at her house; the Seattle Post-Intelligencer said she had to pay a $269 penalty. However, Knox's friends at the University of Washington say the junior was not the party girl portrayed in the media. She grew up on the working-class outskirts of Seattle with her mother, math tutor Edda Mellas, after her parents divorced when she was two. The young woman attended Seattle Prep, a Jesuit school that is one of the city's fancier private institutions, and worked part-time while studying at the university. The invitations to the party that led to the fine included typical college talk of kegs and live bands, but also a line that seems to suggest a civic-minded student: "Because we are moving out, there will be few/no furniture in the house so bring a sleeping bag because no one is drinking and driving here." Jeff Tripoli, a junior who says he was in Knox's social circle, described her as "a sweetheart" and "friendly." According to Tripoli, Knox's boyfriend—whom she broke up with during her sophomore year—used to hold "nerdy tea parties" in his dorm room. Her quaintly eccentric crowd, says Tripoli, was "dorky in a good way." "She didn't dress provocatively," he recalls. "She didn't work it. She dressed casually, and she was friendly and easygoing and studious."