Why Women Lose Weight—or Don’t

« Return to Article

Discuss

  • Posted By: Cotton Candy @ 12/08/2007 1:23:01 PM

    Anyone who spend's so much time juding others has some serious self esteem problem's. In this chat I have seen so many rude things being written. "Can't we all just get along". Fat, skinny, long hair, short hair,
    black, white in between. Hate come's in all forms. If you are fat then there is someone out there hateing you, if you are thin, there are people out their hateing you too. If you have blond hair there is someone out their hateing you , if you have black or brown hair they hate you too. Get the picture we can't please everyone. Believe me no matter what you look like there are people who will hate you for it. People hate others because of religion, because of nationality, because of race, creed, how you look etc. Try Loving one another and if you can't do that as least try to tolarate one another. Peace and Love to all of you. It is the season, no matter what we believe

    • Posted By: rich99 @ 12/08/2007 1:43:12 PM

      Good afternoon, daughter of Sigmund Freud. I am so pleased to meet you.
      Why do you think comments are judgements? Has some Left-wing liberals taught you to reject anything you disagree with as being a judgement?

      If I bowed before Saul Alinsky and started singing KUMBAYA, would that make you happy.

      Grow up- if I find something distasteful, disgusting, or ugly- I say so. That is not a judgement-- THAT IS AN OPINION. If I make a judgement, then I will try to compell you to my way of thinking. Start using words correctly- start with S.I. HAWAKAWA, if you've ever heard of him.

      And, take your "Can't we all just get along" sermon to the Middle East, where they will tell you what it is worth.

      • Posted By: Bellanieva @ 12/08/2007 2:30:32 PM

        I agree this person is an idiot, and has no clue what they are talking about, oh and your probabally right about the liberal lesson thing. HA

    • Posted By: Bellanieva @ 12/08/2007 2:05:19 PM

      i think you are dumb. Everything you just said has nothing to do with weight and fat people. The issue is that people are endangering their own lives and then blaming other people for their abuse. if they feel so hated then fix it. Plus people pay too much attention to what others think of them anyways.

  • Posted By: lee_lee @ 12/08/2007 2:22:24 PM

    I just asked that question because I used to be 98lbs before I started college. After 3 semesters (and 3 horrible months on Depo Provera) I am now 122lbs and my entire family is on my case about being fat- which I think is not entirely fair. On the upside I actually have boobs now!!! I don't know exactly how I should deal with my family telling me that I need to lose weight though- I don't know if I should or shouldn't.

    • Posted By: cpkerst @ 12/08/2007 2:30:20 PM

      Unless you are 4'2", 122lbs is NOT fat. Tell them to get off your case, or stop speaking to them. Annorexia is NOT healthy. Good Luck!

  • Posted By: realcows @ 12/08/2007 2:28:36 PM

    God warrior you have it right! life is about living and being a good person, not how cut you maybe and how it affects your thinking. To those who think otherwise go visit an old folks home or hospital!

    Mery Christmass to all and good day!

  • Posted By: InControl @ 12/08/2007 2:27:50 PM

    I know everyone says "It's not whats on the outside that counts, it's what on the inside". Although I agree that just because your fat/obese doesn't mean you're a mean, horrible, heartless person, I do think that what's on the outside is a direct reflection of who you are on the inside. For example, when you see a fit/healthy woman or man walking down the street that you've never met, you already know so much about them without even talking to them.... You know they're strong individuals with self control, determintation, will power and a decent self esteem. They're in control of themselves. On the other hand, you see a fat person, to me it screams lack of self control, maybe addiction, low self esteem, little will power, and possibly a physiological problem such as thyroid issues. I think, for the most part though,not saying it doesn't exist, the phrase "It's in my genes" is just a lame excuse to eat what ever you want and not get proper nutrition and exercise. I know, every woman in my family is obese except me and they all use that excuse!To each fat person out there, "You're not a victim of your life. There's so much you really do have control of. If what you're doing isn't working try something else....Educate yourselves! See a doctor, a nutritionist, a psychologist, whatever it takes to get healthy! Take small baby steps. Don't change everything all at once". The question is not "Will it work"? It's "Do you have the will power to make it work"?

  • Posted By: VenusinNJ @ 12/08/2007 2:27:06 PM

    Jester, on the one hand, you recognize all the things that are holding you back from getting in better shape (most of which, btw, are pretty lame - you hate veggies, you want to believe you have to spend a fortune eating better food and exercising - nope, sorry) you then ask for some empathy from someone who's been there. Well, how's this - I weighed 180 lbs after having been on Prednisone for a year. When I had finished tapering off it, I made a checklist of things to do/eat every day. Three servings of fresh fruit (which is cheap if you buy what's in season): Check. Go outside and walk for a half hour: Check. Eat two to three pieces of real, whole grain bread - one with each meal: Check. Get on the floor on a rug and do ten to fifteen crunches (which increased gradually over months): Check. Little by little, without my really having to turn my life upside down, I rediscovered how good it feels to feel good. I'm 5'6" and weight 118 lbs now. I'm not rail thin but I know that if I decide to have a rich dessert, I'll need to plan on walking a little longer. I don't consider my eating habits anything other than "normal;" but I do understand that self-discipline begins with setting a standard for myself and being willing to go the distance to achieve it. And that feels really good.

  • Posted By: silvertiburonfx @ 12/08/2007 1:42:41 PM

    I'm in the Marine Corps and there are very strict weight standards. I'm in the best shape of my life and am only 22. Obeasity is a personal problem everybody needs to personally deal with, no excuses. It is a reality that genetics make it harder for some to achieve a target weight than others, but what doesn't change are the methods required to get there. I have guys in my platoon that dropped 30 pounds to be in the corps. They weren't whining the whole time either, they were focused on their goal and sacrificing to serve their country. Some will have to work harder than others, and no it's not fair. Guess what; life is not fair. Complaining about all of your disadvantages isn't going to burn any calories, so why don't you do something that does. For all those of you who are comfortable with yourself being obease, it's a damn shame. Obesity is a problem that is driving up healthcare costs and plaguing our great nation. Really obesity isn't the problem, overeating and being lazy is. The Marine Corps has a place for obease people, they kick you ass back into the civilian world where ill motivated lazy fat people belong. All of you fat people depend on our armed forces to protect your skins and how do you repay myself and others for our service, by complaining about how hard you have it trying to loose 20 pounds. You know what, try being in the Iraqi desert when it's 112 degrees marching around with a 90 pound pack and a weapon. You'd never try it, because no one 50 pounds overweight could even comprehend handling a 9 kilometer hike in those conditions. You couldn't handle a 9 kilometer cawl on a treadmill in a climate controlled gym. Reading some of these comments make me sick. Quit whining and get it together. Motivate yourself to be a better more healthy person. Quit contributing to the problem and start being part of the solution. And your welcome for comitting myself to meeting the weight and physical standards required of our armed forces to serve our great country and protect you right to obeasity.

    • Posted By: cpkerst @ 12/08/2007 2:27:02 PM

      How dare you, you self-righteous turd, use your service to this country as a way to put people down! My husband is in the Military and has been for 11 years, and he, nor I, would EVER use that as an example of "I'm better than you". Your service in the Marines has NOTHING to do with this article or being fat or not. That being said, I do believe that people are over-all lazy and that restraunts are all too easily accessible, so that we as a nation would rather take the easy road out and get foods that are already prepared for us. That is just one of the factors that contributes to obiesity. As for the people who think it's easy to lose weight, you have never been over-weight then. For if you had been, you'd realize that it's not as simple as just changing what you eat. If it were, then we wouldn't be having this discussion, because not many of us would be fat. You also battle the pain that is caused when you do exercise, and then there is the mental aspect that you have to change. People get themselves into habbits that comfort them, and it is physically painful sometimes to let those things go. It's literally like losing a friend. I know, beacuse I have had to go through that process. I struggled with weight all my life. My whole family is fat, so there is a genetic factor there, and it's very easy for me to gain weight and hard to lose it. Also, I have an underactive thyroid, and though I take my medication for it every day, it's still VERY slow going to lose weight, which can be very depressing. I have lost 70lbs and continue to lose, but it has taken me two and a half years to lose that 70lbs due to my thyroid issues. That is an incredibly long time to lose that much weight and it's hard to stay positive and focused. So, I am living proof that it can be done, to prove some of yall's points, but I am also proof that it IS a hard thing to do. With or without a thyroid issue. If you haven't struggled with weight then you don't know what you are talking about, and you really have no right to put your two cents in, because you don't know what you are talking about. And if you have struggled, then my advice to you is, though it may be hard, and it's not always enjoyable, get up, get out, and just try a little harder to do some sort of exercise. It WILL make you feel better. Don't do it because the world says so, screw the world and their opinions. Do it for yourself, and how it will make you feel. You don't have to be skinny, who cares about that, just be healthy! Good luck!

  • Posted By: theotherjc @ 12/08/2007 2:23:00 PM

    quit being slothful!!!!!!!!!eat less of whatever you like!!!be happy!!!!!!!

  • Posted By: xxflyaway77xx @ 12/08/2007 2:22:22 PM

    To all the people making excuses for themselves on how they don't have the time lose weight, and they can't spend even 10 minutes to exercise, really need to take a look in the mirror. You are lying to yourself. I know this from experience. At my heaviest weight, I needed to lose 100 pounds to be a "normal" size. Now that is disgusting. I hated what I looked like when I looked into the mirror. I hated what I thought other people saw when they looked at me, but I just "didn't have the time." But when one day, out of the blue, I was having trouble breathing, and my leg was swelling to twice the size of my other one, I knew something was wrong. I went to the hospital, and it turns out that I had a severe blood clot in my leg, and some of it broke off and went to my lungs. I almost died that day. And did I mention that I was only 19 years old? Yeah, that showed me that I needed to lose weight and that I could not put it off any longer. so I joined Weight Watchers, and it is working. I have only just begun, but I know what I need to do,, and I am going to do it. So take my advice and stop waiting for that near death experience to get healthy. Your life really does depend on your health.

  • Posted By: VoiceofReason74 @ 12/08/2007 2:16:47 PM

    Personally, I don't think anybody is horrible for not losing weight. I just think it's horrible the lack of comparable women there are for men in America these days.........and it's very recent, maybe the past 10 years. Secondly, if any woman on here loses their weight and isn't happier for it, then I'll personally mail them a 20 dollar check for an all you can eat at McDonalds.

    • Posted By: buttafly @ 12/08/2007 2:22:04 PM

      The lack of comparable women for men?? What the heck is that supposed to mean? I'm a single woman and a pretty good catch, and I'm single because I can't find a man who is decently attractive and intelligent and takes care of himself physically AND mentally.

  • Posted By: wlcgblog @ 12/05/2007 1:25:14 PM

    Well, I for one think that a moderate amount of body fat looks (and feels) very nice on women in general. The very thin women in the media look sickly and unattractive to me as a general rule. I think it's nice that women who are more curvy and buxom are finally being appreciated!

    • Posted By: foxxy121 @ 12/05/2007 1:38:24 PM

      wow, we actually have a chubby chaser on this post! What a freak!

      • Posted By: freak @ 12/08/2007 2:20:55 PM

        I think what he said was "a moderate amount of body fat," as in a size 8-12. I take it you, foxxxy, are a size
        (negative) 4, right? I'm also sure that if you got caught in a windstorm, the wind would blow you down the sidewalk like a leaf.

      • Posted By: lady summers @ 12/05/2007 2:50:20 PM

        Liking women who are more curvy and buxom isn't freakish. It's extremely normal throughout the world. As are, as is clear from many of these posts, finger-pointing and idiocy.

  • Posted By: realcows @ 12/08/2007 1:56:40 PM

    There is fat, and there are large people and the 2 are totally different. As a former 6'2" 300ish Defensive lineman who also ran a 4.76, I am well aware of the extreme dfferences in what some people misconstrue as fat. My doctors want me down to 250-260 range as an ideal which i approached in the last 10 yrs and at that I was far more in shape than many many of my contempories at 180. Fat is what is right for you, and the quality of life and how you define it in your life. I would much rather be able to enjoy a steak once a week than live on cardboard. and rice cakes. That is NOT LIVING! Do I want to live 5 yrs longer so I cane enjoy wheeling down the Nursinghome corridors and looking at all the old ladies and men's incontinence? NO! Well Bill, you keep running because you have no personallity anyway and are wound way to tight for your own well being anyway! Enjoy some of life because it will slip away far too soon anyway!

    • Posted By: vonna117 @ 12/08/2007 2:20:47 PM

      you know being fat is a choice as well..I am a Big Beautiful Woman who is very proud of who I am..sure I could lose weight and some days I think it would be nice if I lost a few pounds..but this is my life..Im not going to hide or go away because Im big...I'm going this way once and Im going to enjoy my life the size that I am...The way fat is being thrown around by the media is like they throw around color or races..God made everyone different and as soon as all of us learn to accept people for who they are ..we of all sizes and shapes would be better off.....I would rather have a good attitude about myself and others than look for something to point the finger at.....none of us are perfect...yes you might be thin and healthy..but are you kind and considerate? or do you think your better than anyone who is large? I think not...once we learn to let people be who they are and strive for a better place in our world..maybe we could learn to focus on what is really important rather than the size of our clothes or the way others think we should look like...in theis world now with the many sea of colors and sizes..I am happy to say Im a part of this world and its ever changing differences....vonna

    • Posted By: rich99 @ 12/08/2007 2:06:08 PM

      Nice try, Bubba. But..............

      I don't really enjoy paying (through health insurance premiums) for your upcoming Coronary Bypass surgery, nor your years on hemodialysis, so you can enjoy fatty steaks and eating all you want so YOU can enjoy life.

      Selfish Bubba. Just plain selfish and really stupid, to boot.

  • Posted By: theotherjc @ 12/08/2007 2:20:20 PM

    quit being slothful beings

  • Posted By: realcows @ 12/08/2007 2:20:16 PM

    \Unfortuneately we are focosed on being skinny. Skinnies/Scrawnies are in vogue. They dont understand the rush I had sacking a quarterback as a D! lineman. We need to focus on quality of the person, who they are, what they think like, They think living to 102 is what it is all about. I would much rather enjoy a steak once a week or a bottle of wine with a nice lady than live to 99 and wheel down the nursing home in my wheel chair looking at other incontinence! Its about QUALITY OF LIFE BABY. Yes i want and need to lose, but too many are focused on size. a size 2 may be fat for some and a xxx maynot be for a large man. Its about muscle mass, what you do with it, and how you handle it, but if your obsessize and let it ruin your head then its just as much a SNOBBISH problem as it is a size problem!

  • Posted By: buttafly @ 12/08/2007 2:18:04 PM

    There is something equally unhealthy about being obsessed with weight to the point of being malnourished and having a panic attack over every pound, and not caring at all about what you eat to the point of putting your health at risk. MODERATION is the key. You can enjoy exercise (any enjoyable activity that gets you moving, not necessarily in a gym), sweet/salty/whatever foods in moderate amounts, etc. without being obsessed about any of it. Life is meant to be enjoyed; just be smart about it.

    ~from an athletic size 10 female who is happy to keep everything balanced!

  • Posted By: buttafly @ 12/08/2007 2:18:01 PM

    There is something equally unhealthy about being obsessed with weight to the point of being malnourished and having a panic attack over every pound, and not caring at all about what you eat to the point of putting your health at risk. MODERATION is the key. You can enjoy exercise (any enjoyable activity that gets you moving, not necessarily in a gym), sweet/salty/whatever foods in moderate amounts, etc. without being obsessed about any of it. Life is meant to be enjoyed; just be smart about it.

    ~from an athletic size 10 female who is happy to keep everything balanced!

  • Posted By: HappyPhatGirl @ 12/08/2007 11:33:00 AM

    here's a question... who the hell decided who should weigh what weight? I happen to weigh 265lbs, am 5ft 8in and I have no life threatening illnesses and I DO NOT eat super sized meals and junk food every day. I eat everything just as my 6ft 2in, 165lb brother eats. Those people saying that people are fat because they do nothing but eat unhealthy foods and what not is bullshit.... Ignorance is just one of the many reasons that 'fat' people are being sterotyped. The media is another, it gives standards through all it's channels as to what people should look like, if you're not a size 2, you're unhealthy and unattractive. Please... I'd rather have my curves and look like the woman I am suppose to be than look like my brother... How attractive a person is, is not based on their weight, it's based on how that person feels about themselves. And I have a word of advice for those whom feel otherwise... Don't like, don't look....Pehaps you should give a glance into the mirror and see if you truely like what you see before you judge someone else.

    • Posted By: ojacka02 @ 12/08/2007 2:17:27 PM

      Why would you think you need to eat the same as a MAN that is 6" TALLER than you? Who told you that was a good diet to follow? Men have more muscle mass, which burns more calories. You don't even need to eat the same as a man your own height, let alone one that is 6" taller than you. I am also 5'8" and weigh 127 pounds. You weigh 138 pounds more, that is another WHOLE PERSON. You are deceiving yourself. But you must not have have been totally successful in doing so or you wouldn't be posting about it on here looking for someone to tell you you're right. You should not eat what your brother does, obvisously, or he wouldn't be slimmer than you.

    • Posted By: 2peas_in_a_pod @ 12/08/2007 11:49:20 AM

      You just mentioned that you don't eat super-sized meals, but you also said that you're a woman who's eating the same things as a man who's 6 inches taller. That could be a huge contributing factor to your weight, since men and women don't require the same number of calories to maintain a healthy weight and he can also justify more calories because he's much taller. (Of course physical activity is also important in determining how mancy calories to consume.)

  • Posted By: VenusinNJ @ 12/08/2007 2:07:43 PM

    Gee, happyhappy - don't hold back - tell us what you really think. I hope you realize that when your comments get that foul, you basically negate any amount of regard people might have for your opinion.

  • Posted By: monimac @ 12/08/2007 2:04:32 PM

    When I was young I really hated my body. It was not just like the models' bodies in the magazines. Plus my mother got after me a lot about my weight. She was a former runway model herself, very fashion conscious, very chic. Looking back at photos taken at the time, I was never very fat as a youngster, but going into my 20's I put on a lot of weight, mostly out of self loathing, overeating, lack of exercise. I reached 185 in my senior year of college. By then I had stopped visiting my mom except on rare occasions because she was always so mean. It took me a lot of time to get my groove back so to speak. Today I am 55 years old, weigh 142, and have a BMI of 21. I take much better care of myself and love myself a lot more than when I was young. My life has never been better.

  • Posted By: Bellanieva @ 12/08/2007 2:02:22 PM

    I fully agree with jenart. If you are heavy you cannot keep excusing yourself and putting it off to another day.being okay with mediocrity and fat is not a good way to live your life! if you are okay with the fat and you accept yourself then you will never change. This article is full of bologna! They mention how if you are dissatisfied with yourself you are more likely to sink into a sedentary state and gain more weight but that is not fully true. Sometimes self loathing is the only way you can force yourself to change. Take it from me, last year I was testing for my black belt and i realized that because of my weight I was not only hurting myself but i was also pulling people down around me. For my test i had to run 40 miles, something that seemed impossible, but because of the disgust i felt for myself I forced myself to start running. I now have been running for about a year and i have lost 45 pounds but am still working on it, i have 35 left before i am a a good healthy weight. I know the despair that comes along with the weight and i know how hopeless it may seem at times but the more you realize how bad you really are the more motivated you can become to change yourself. The only difference between me and you is that i got sick to death of how gross i looked so i changed, and you are okay with your life threatening disgusting fat rolls. Quit with the pity and get over it and do something to change yourself! So for all of you people out there feeling sorry for yourself i have no pity, if you feel so bad about yourself go and change yourself! So go and look at yourself in a mirror and fill yourself up with disgust and then go for a brisk walk and even try to run for like 30 seconds and build up from there.

  • Posted By: schiebs @ 12/08/2007 1:28:13 PM

    I do not even need to read this article. Fat should never be accepted as te new normal.
    Overwieght Obesity is the more undrerated cause of medical problems.
    When men women any human is over weight they have problems with everything they do in life.
    Thet medical impact being the most critical area:
    Heart disease.Gi problems,bad back and knees.sleep disorders, increase cost for cloths, those are just the tip of the iceburg.
    As a medical professional in a very busy ER. Caring for the overweight is task we dislike the most.
    They are difficult to undress and dress, placement of cathters and IVs is more difficult and time consuming.
    getting out of bed going for test the list is endless.
    Yet is is our fault when we can not accomitate the special need of these population who have a problem that is generally self inflicted and treatable.
    The cost of there care is greater. I can not prove it monitarially but professionally they drain my provide energy and kill my back.
    LOOSE WEIGHT!!! Please

    • Posted By: slash @ 12/08/2007 2:01:01 PM

      However, if you read the article instead of just the title, you would know that the study is not suggesting that fat is in fact the new normal. I suspect many of these comments are bing submitted by people who read only the title and let their personal prejudices run wild. It's incredible that so many people who live in glass houses feel free to throw stones. Must be great to be perfect!

    • Posted By: frontncenter @ 12/08/2007 1:43:35 PM

      I hope your medical care isn't as sloppy as your typing!

    • Posted By: jenart @ 12/08/2007 1:35:24 PM

      THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENT! KUDOS!

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse