Why Women Lose Weight—or Don’t

« Return to Article

Discuss

  • Posted By: albo360 @ 12/05/2007 11:54:56 PM

    there are a lot of people who rather eat junk food and sit around rather than do anything constuctive.
    if your skinny and you got a beer belly you still got a beer belly. and so what if you like to sit around and let yourself get round. just dont jeer at me as im able to swiftly manuveure around the work. being out of shape is not something to be proud of, and alot of people today dont do anything for themselves to feel empowered and we have a culture that accepts laziness and voluptuous bodies you knoe personally come as you are but a real freind will ask is that the best you can do?

  • Posted By: quiltmaker @ 12/05/2007 11:40:26 PM

    I beleive that most over weight problems stem from unresovled issues. And util l these issues are resolved, these severely over weight people will always be suffering from ridicule ans being made fun of. No one wants to look and or feel so bad about them selves as I am sure they do. My heart goes out to them.

  • Posted By: quiltmaker @ 12/05/2007 11:36:03 PM

    I beleive that most severly over weight people have under lying psychological issues that have not been dealt with and that food becomes a comfort them which gets out of control. I try not judge them for I have not walked a mile in there shoes. They have to want it very badly for them selves in order to be successful at diet and exercise.

  • Posted By: vickyt520 @ 12/05/2007 11:32:04 PM

    Just a thought for those that say you can be 5'3 and weigh 180 pounds because you don't "believe" you have to be skinny to be healthy- you also don't have to "believe" you will die someday but that hardly makes it true.

  • Posted By: mackay @ 12/05/2007 11:11:37 PM

    Fat is ugly, fat is the sign of laziness, fat is out. Don't make excuses for fat people, promote articles that help them lose weight. FAT IS OUT!

  • Posted By: 2bcontinued @ 12/05/2007 10:03:51 PM

    as a former size 14 (now 6) i have long been aware of "vanity sizing"... there is a problem when a lady who weighs 140lbs cannot wear a size S from WalMart because it is too large...I think we are doing a disservice to everyone, along the lines of "dumbing down" to assuage vanity/ego issues.

    We can all agree, you can be thin, and not fit, as well as large and fit, and that fitness, does not necessarily equal health. There is mainly the issue of body shape to contend with. If you have a belly, you usually have great legs, and if you have a thinner midsection, maybe your bottom or legs are what is larger on you...basically, you have to learn to work with what you have...fit, proportion, and silhouette go a long way to making the most of what you have...but dressing like you mean it is another issue entirely.

    i may now know what it is like to be treated differently because of how you look...i have felt i have personally experienced sizism...people make too many assumptions about others...no one likes that, large or small...you never know where a person has been, or where they are heading....

    finally, to everyone who wants to make their body machine work as intended, and look hot as a side benefit, the ONLY way to do it is by eating conciously and moving your body ...anyone who tells you differently is selling something.



  • Posted By: JanByrn @ 12/05/2007 9:22:14 PM

    This caught my eye because I am currently a member of Weight Watchers. I have been a "Fat Kid", which was definitely not fun! And I have been both a "Fat Teen" and a "Fat Adult". I have had many attempts to lose weight, but nothing had really worked until I accepted the fact that I don't have to be perfect.

    The goal weight I have set for myself is 140 pounds. In my younger days I wanted to be 125 or so, but I know that neither my sister nor my mom have been skinny. Mom wasn't fat, and my sister has never been fat, but they were never super-skinny either. I have come to accept the fact that being active, and looking your best and eating healthy (at least most of the time), is more rewarding than following the "Beanpole" models in the magazines.

    Basically what I am saying is that nothing really worked for me until I realized I am not an actress or a model, I am my own self! So I take care of myself and work on being a good person overall.

    Body trend fads come and go, but you have to be a hero to yourself.

  • Posted By: Lang @ 12/05/2007 9:17:13 PM

    Ah, so Americans are proud to be fat?

    We're now in an age where the Americans are seriously mating with vegetables.

  • Posted By: ladycascadia @ 12/05/2007 8:48:11 PM

    It is amazing to me how many haters there are here. Who died and gave them the right to tell someone what size they should be? Yes, I am BIG...over 200 lbs, but guess what? I am still fit and healthy (according to my Dr.). I commute by bicycle to work 3.5 miles each way 4x a week (that's 28 miles...and if you count going around my town on weekends...I ride close to 35 miles each week!). I also do middle eastern dance, and am a for the most part a vegetarian. I am tired of the stereotypes out there about large sized people doing nothing but sitting on their butts and eating fast food. There are skinny girls who can't keep up with me...and I can definitely assure there are MEN who do look my way twice...with admiring looks, too! So all those size bigots can put it where the sun don't shine. You do NOT have to be a real or fake size 2 to be happy in life!!!

  • Posted By: invaderoperaghost @ 12/05/2007 6:09:30 PM

    I'm an underweight teenaged girl, and it seems like most of the pressure on me has been to not be underweight rather than to stay that way. My BMI is around 18 (5'6", around 110 pounds), but some people make fun of me and joke that I'm anorexic, even though I'm not and that seems like a very serious thing to joke about. It can be extremely annoying and sometimes it hurts. The only thing that annoys me about my body sometimes is when I look in the mirror and can see what looks like too many of my bones. But most of the time I wear large t-shirts and I don't really pay attention to any of that fashion stuff, so maybe that's why I don't feel much pressure to stay underweight. I'm happy with my weight though, and I really wouldn't want to be any more than 10 pounds away from my current weight either way. Most of the time I'm just not very hungry, though, and I can't stand to eat when I'm not hungry. This usually means that on most days I only eat about 1600 or so calories.

    • Posted By: california girl @ 12/05/2007 6:31:29 PM

      My daughter is in a similar situation to yours. She is almost 13 and a 00 is a bit loose on her. She eats well and is active in sports. She has some friends that say she is lucky and ask what she eats. They try to feed her extra junk foo to fatten her up. It saddens me that it is such an issue at this early age. It is hard enough to feel good about yourself when your body seems to be changing daily, kids don't need the extra comments. When will people realize that all these comments on ones shape don't help them.

      • Posted By: sweet caroline @ 12/05/2007 8:47:06 PM

        yeah same here i'm 16, 5 ft 5 inch and i only weigh 103, and i have a butt and 32C bra, but people always make rumours and stuff about how most of my friends and i are anerexic or belimic,which is rediculous, if i was one of those i wouldn't have any curves,but it still hurts, alot and i totally know what your going through, i actually didnt get casted in any of the past plays because my teacher was afraid i would faint on stage from hunger, which KILLED ME TO FIND OUT, but now i have that class fourth period and she lets us eat lunch in there,and i've found out I EAT MORE THEN ANYONE ELSE IN THERE! but then again i work out daily.but now they make remarks about how i eat too much,and now i'm practically labeled belemic, i'm now casted in the musical which helped a little but i'm still upset and i know how much it hurts!people say its a complement when they say OH MY GOSH YOUR SO FREAKING SKINNY! but seriously its like being called fat,it hurts alot,i've had concelers call me into their offices at church and school asking if i have an eating dissorder! I'm so sorry that you have to go through this! IT SUCKS I KNOW!! and i do feel a little pressure to stay this size,because well, guys comment about it,and it is in the magazines, but i also get confliciting pressure to gain weight. ITS REDICULOUS HOW EVERYONE WANTS PEOPLE TO BE HOW THEY THINK THEY SHOULD BE, I WANNA BE ME! SIMPLY ME! COME ON NOW!

  • Posted By: ladycascadia @ 12/05/2007 8:43:47 PM

    It amazes me that people still seem to think it's their business to tell you how you should look. Just because someone is big does NOT mean they are unfit or unhealthy. I weight between 220 and 235 lbs, and I commute by bike (a REAL bike not electronic)...3 1/2 miles each way to my job. I also do middle eastern dance and work with weights. No, I'm not losing weight but I'm not gaining it either...and you know what men still give me admiring looks and that's good enough for me! So weight haters can stick it as far as I'm concerned. Bottom line? no matter how much or little you weigh, there will always be someone out there to try to make you feel bad about yourself. It's up to YOU to stand up to the judgmental twerps!

  • Posted By: 1126 @ 12/05/2007 8:38:19 PM

    THERE IS A SOLUTION!!!! PLEASE CONTACT F.A. -FOOD ADDICTS IN RECOVERY ANONYMOUS- A 12 STEP PROGRAM OF RECOVERY FOR FOOD ADDICTION- YOU ARE NOT ALONE !!YOUR STORY IS LIKE MINE OR MANY OTHERS WHO BECAME ADDICTED TO FOOD. YOU DON'T HAVE TO HAT YOURSELF OR YOUR WEIGHT. FOOD ADDICTION IS EVERYWHERE , PLEASE REACH OUT FOR HELP . GOD HAS A GOOD PLAN FOR YOUR LIFE AND YOU DON'T HAVE TO KILL YOURSELF WITH FOOD OR ALCOHOL, OR DRUGS. ROCIO.

  • Posted By: NO EXCUSES @ 12/05/2007 8:07:53 PM

    I hate that people single out men and women like this. Both men and women have eating problems. If they are going to *** about there weight and say that they are unhappy. GUESS WHAT??? DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT!!!! Dont just sit down and have another donut! So many people are just so lazy! If you want to look good and have good things come to you, for women and men, then get up and do what you have to do. It's that easy!!!

  • Posted By: amazinggrace @ 12/05/2007 3:16:36 PM

    chris - your "love each other" approach is fine, but what about when those obese people start having children? I think it's a slow form of child abuse to fatten your child up on fast food and watch as the medical and psychological problems start to emerge. I don't care how you lead your life, but I think it's disgusting to watch people too irresponsible to care for themselves destroy their children.

    • Posted By: RNandMommax3 @ 12/05/2007 5:40:41 PM

      Fat parents don't automatically have fat children. To lump child abuse and obesity together is a steriotypical stretch. It doesn't work that way. I've gained some weight as I've gotten older, but my kids are on premier soccer teams and involved in boxing. I take them to sporting workouts 5 days a week. They are not fat. I cook at home. Not all heavy people eat fast food. I don't abuse my children. We are not having happy meals for dinner.

      • Posted By: amazinggrace @ 12/05/2007 6:35:05 PM

        I didn't say that you did. I assume from your username that you are also in the medical field. I have no problem with people who are obese, as long as it doesn't affect their children. But too often it does. In my career, I have treated 15 year old boys with higher cholesterol than my 67 year old, overweight, father, then watched as their mothers snuck them in happy meals because they didn't want them eating the disgusting hospital food. I have assisted in removing arterial blockages from an 18 year old girl and watched her parents convince themselves that it was stress-related, when the girl was almost 150 pounds overweight.

        So that is child abuse. When a parent causes their child to be hospitalized through intentional actions, whether in the form of physical violence, neglect, or dietary practices, I consider that abuse.

        • Posted By: RNandMommax3 @ 12/05/2007 7:06:12 PM

          True, but you missed my point. The subject was about obesity, not parenting skills. My point was that you can't assume that all fat people feed their children improperly. Children in America do not eat healthy, whether they have fat or thin parents. The schools serve junk food. They put energy drinks in the vending machines. Parents are busy working 2 jobs to "keep up with the Jones's" and kids are doing the latchkey routine, parking it infront of the television or video games instead of playing outside. We (medical staff) have the advantage in that we see the end results of the choices that people make in life. When you see the pain that people experiece in their latter years as a result poor health choices. It makes you think twice about what you are eating. It is downright depressing at times. So I do share your concern. I just don't tag obese people as abusive to their children. That is an individually earned label, not a blanket occurance.

          • Posted By: amazinggrace @ 12/05/2007 7:59:44 PM

            My comment was in response to Chris' comment, which said that we all need to just love each other and let people do as they please. At no point did I say that "all fat people feed their children improperly," but in my experience, which, as a third year medical student, is admittedly limited, more often than not, obese parents are the ones who turn a blind eye to their children's problems. They openly embrace chris' gag-reflex-inducing philosophy to make themselves feel better while the doctors I study under plead with them to stop killing their children.

            The fact that you don't see it as abuse only emphasizes my point. If a parent malnurishes their child in any other way, they have a front and center spot on Nancy Grace. If you don't feed your child, it IS considered abuse, yet, if you overfeed your child, and your child subsequently has a heart attack, nobody pays attention.

            This is not a blanket occurence, I never said it was. My point is that SOME parents do this to their children, which makes Chris' cumbayah approach both ignorant and nauseating.

  • Posted By: nautaclue @ 12/05/2007 7:52:18 PM

    ok. I'm 1 inch shy of 5 feet. I weigh 150 pounds and I hate my weight. I had 4 children and never weighed this much brfore or after birth. Stopped smoking 7/21/07 and packed on amost 27 pounds immediatly. along with the gas from the chantex, My life is just horrible right now. If I started smoking again I would probably lose it fast. I would love to be a size 4 again or even an 8 would make me extremely happy.How do you lose it and still stay sane? My husband is always making snide comments about my weight. What to do???

  • Posted By: nautaclue @ 12/05/2007 7:47:21 PM

    I quit smoking on July 21,2007. I immediately packed on about 18 pounds. I took chantex and with it came the ungodly gas and weight gain. My husband was thrilled that I had quit so easily but has not touched me since I quit. Because of the weight gain or the gas. I don't know which one is worse. But I hate being FAT. Much less fat and gassy...Help me to understand what is going on with my body.Oh I weigh 150 and 1 inch shy of 5 foot tall

  • Posted By: california girl @ 12/05/2007 5:47:58 PM

    I agree with the part about the underweight feeling the pressure to stay there. I was a size 2 for a long time. In order to stay there I exercised obessivley and restricted my eating to very little. I am now a size 6. I still watch what I eat and get some exercise but the reaction has been terrible. Everyone, even family members, are constantly asking about my weight and what I am doing to loose it. Keep in mind these people are all between a 6 and 10 themselves. I think people get used to seeing people in a certain way and have a hard time adjusting. With reactions like this it does make me self concious about what I eat around them and I have caught myself slipping back to the old ways to be accepted. I have become more reclusive and worried about how I am seen. I think this is why the underweight have such a hard time. Why can't we be normal too?

    • Posted By: qtee64 @ 12/05/2007 7:07:21 PM

      Cali girl-I don't even need to say this, a size 6 is great. I don't know how tall you are. What you said about being a size 2 before, I think has alot to do with your family's comments. I bet you look wonderful and healthy, I would put the "kabosh" on thier comments and let them know that "this is you" and to stop with the heckling. Would they be happy if you slipped into an eating disorder and had to be taken to the hosiptal? Some people just don't stop and think-hang in there girl, you even know it-YOU'RE FINE!

  • Posted By: DontEatMeat @ 12/05/2007 2:03:02 PM

    LETS FACE IT...FAT PEOPLE MAKE EXCUSES!!!!

    • Posted By: BubblesBrideToBe @ 12/05/2007 6:41:19 PM

      I think you have some HUGE issues you need to deal with you really need to shut your mouth meds can make you gain weight... Not everyones excuse is fake... why don't you stop being a Can't Understand Normal Thinking. Your a crule person... Karma... what goes around comes around.

  • Posted By: MsTHigh @ 12/05/2007 1:59:40 PM

    To Momma2Four Well to the woman who had children and lost weight. Child bearing weight is very different from lifetime weight. Ask you physician. It is much easier to lose because your body has not completely adjusted to holding that fat. For someone who has been overweight for an extended period the body is maladjusted to the fat content and is used to consuming a certain amount of fat. Thus it will retain more fat. Also to suggest that a certain thing that worked for you or "skinny" people should work for larger people is ignorant. I mean that in the sense of your knowledge on this matter is incorrect not that your personality or sense on a whole is ignorant. Everyone is different our bodies respond differently to everything. You could possible respond overzealously to stress whereas someone else may not. You may have dermatitis reaction to sweat when working out someone else may not. You may think you work hard for your "nice" body but actually it???s a possibility that you may not. There are many things that come into play when it comes to losing weight. Genetics, diet, access to exercises, proper health care, proper food. I personally have come into better finances and am now able to eat better along with adequate transportation for work and school which has given me more time to exercise and resources to get what I need to be healthier. It is a determination and goal but don't make it seem as if you are working so hard and "fat people" are not. The goal is healthy not thin. Maybe you should refocus your mental capacity on compassion and helping others get healthy rather than pointing out their errors. If you let it happen you're a part of the issue.

    • Posted By: momma2four @ 12/05/2007 2:06:40 PM

      To MSTHigh......If you think I have always been thin, you are WRONG. I was always a lil overweight till I had my last child 2 yrs ago, and I took control MYSELF! That is why I have no sympathy for overweight people. They need to toughen up and if you want it bad enough, than you will MAKE it happen. Period. If you think it was easy to lose weight after having 4 kids in 5 yrs you are WRONG, and weight is weight. Don't give me bull *** that baby weight is easier to lose. It isn't. Have a great day!

      • Posted By: BubblesBrideToBe @ 12/05/2007 6:35:44 PM

        Acctually it is especially if your breast feeding.

      • Posted By: MsTHigh @ 12/05/2007 2:27:22 PM

        There's no need to curse - causes more issues. I am not trying to degrade your efforts. Congratulations, pat yourself on the back, GREAT JOB! (No sarcasm intended). I am just trying to further educate you about some of the obstacles that get in an obese persons way. Yes you are correct it is something you make happen but resources are needed. How do you eat healthy food if there is no grocery money? How does one exercise if you have class each day after work and homework on the weekends? What about children if you do not have sitters and no family? I know people with these issues. Some people just aren't educated and don't know what???s going on with their bodies. Do the research - healthy food is not for the poor. When is the last time you've seen a Whole Foods in the center of the city? In my city Detroit there are NO major retail grocery stores. Only Chaldean/Arab run stores with high prices and low grade produce. I???ve never seen the FDA here to lay regulations on them. You have to have money and transportation to travel to the suburban grocery stores. The city lacks public transit (to get to healthy food stores) because of the automotive industry's hold on the market here. That is just the brink of the scope that poverty can hurt. If you are poor then I'll take heed but being obese isn't just about diet and exercise - if it was that easy France would be fat and America would be skinny. France has longer lunches (eat slower and well prepared meals), they have better public transit, their jobs are close in commute to walk, they have social health care, they promote preventative health care, they have longer vacations and I'm sure their unemployment rate is much lower, I'm just guessing maybe not but they have something right. The article clearly reported that people need to feel good in order to feel motivated to do good things for their bodies.

        Why don???t you start a support group and help those get the motivation you had to lose? You would most likely be a great motivator since you don???t quit. Write to congress about health-exercise systems and food aid/education for those impoverished. Or start a class at a local city community center on healthy eating. What did you say? ???Its something you make happen???? MAKE IT HAPPEN! You???ve motivated me to. Stop pointing fingers. No one needs/wants you to feel sorry for them. People want empathy and respect and that???s something lacking.

  • Posted By: croationgal @ 12/05/2007 4:00:24 PM

    I can't believe that fat/obese people are happy with themselves. Have you looked at the children of these people?.. They are fat......and also sloppy.....what is happening? Do the parents not see what their children look like and feel like? How sad....if they cannot help themselves .....then please help the children.

    • Posted By: noah4me2003 @ 12/05/2007 4:17:01 PM

      I am considered overweight and I have two little boys. Because I have struggled with weight issues most of my life, I am very causious about what and when my boys eat. I think what you said is steroetyping everyone in this catagory and that is wrong. My older son 4 years old and weighs almost 32lbs. I was told to feed him more to bring his weight up, but I am not going to because I weighed 25lbs when I started Kindergarten so it is in his genes to be underweight. My second son is a little more because he is a more active baby then my first son. He has been walking the furniture since he was 7 months old and he has a lot of muscle already. If you can't say something that will be helpful to people in this situation, you shouldn't say anything at all. Not every situation is what you stated in your comment, and unless you yourself have been overweight or obese, you will never understand how this comment could hurt someone!

      • Posted By: RNandMommax3 @ 12/05/2007 6:22:37 PM

        Comment: Fat parents don't automatically have fat children. To lump child abuse and obesity together is a steriotypical stretch. It doesn't work that way. I've gained some weight as I've gotten older, but my kids are on premier soccer teams and involved in boxing. I take them to sporting workouts 5 days a week. They are not fat. I cook at home. Not all heavy people eat fast food. I don't abuse my children. We are not having happy meals for dinner either. What kindof person looks at children in such a judgemental manner? I'm willing to bet my children are more functional and better looking than you.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse