When Adoption Goes Wrong

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: Adopt-at-home! @ 12/17/2007 4:44:11 PM

    I see US adoptions daily. In the state I live in when the parents sign to "relinquish" their rights to their child the language is that it is "irrevocable" meaning the parent can NEVER change their mind and LEGALLY get the child back. The risk of the birth parent having contact with the adoptive parent and the child is up to the adoptive parent. The type of contact is up to the adoptive parent. The more specific a family is about the type of child they want (ie: mentally and physically healthy blonde haired, blue eyed baby girl vs. any child, any gender, any medical condition, any race, any mental conditon, any congative condition, any behavioral condition) the longer they will wait for a child. The children that NEED adoption in the states are the abused and neglected, most are minorities, most are over the age of 8 and most have some "baggage". I know for a fact in my state that there are more children in foster care than there are homes to put them in. Many of them have been in foster care for years and will continue to be in foster care until adult hood. So this "poor families who can't adopt" whining that I'm seeing on this blog is CRAP! Start feeling sorry for all of the children who don't have familes because they don't fit in the little box that the family expects for them to fit into! And if it takes X# of years for someone to adopt, I say FINE. That gives them more time to prepare for the child who will change their lives.... for the better or (heaven forbid) for the worse.
    Adopting from over seas does not stop the parent from comming back either..... look at Madona's child.
    Adoption is cool! It's giving a child a home who wouldn't otherwise have one, but there are plenty here at home to adopt.... even for Angelina, Brad and Madona!

  • Posted By: woodstock @ 12/17/2007 4:35:17 PM

    i think this person who hurt this innocent girl is a disgusting filthy worthless pig. how could you ever even think about doing that? what this retarded "mother" doesnt get is the fact that this girl isnt EVEN FIVE YET and you beat her up?? wow you must be so tough, hurting a baby like that. you deserve nothing more than the worst and idc what happens to you. God bless this little baby and i know shes in a safe place now and will never have to deal with this sick human being she thought was her mother EVER again.

  • Posted By: Adopt-at-home! @ 12/17/2007 4:24:18 PM

    Working with adopted children I see this happen all too often (the return of children not the fatal abuse) and it is ashame. I also have close friends who are wanting to adopt or who have adopted. I too hope to adopt in the future. My friends want to adopt abused/neglected children from the US.... we have PLENTY of children right here in our country who need adoption, if people could get away from wanting a blonde haired, blue eyed baby girl..... but they too have their issues. They too are being placed back in foster care to languish there for the rest of their childhood. There need to be more resources available to adoptive parents to help these children that do not involve spend their intire savings and retirement to care for them. All children of abuse/neglect no matter their place of birth are at risk of mental health issues because of the factors that lead to their abuse/neglect. Although the parents who place their children in orphanages in other countries do it with the best intention and hope for their child, the workers in those places are just that, workers. The contact they have with the children is their job, they are not parents. So it is not surprising to read that these children have attachment disorders. Add to that a child who was born to a woman with a substance abuse problem and the cognative and developmental challenges that child faces. Then add to that abuse. You have a risk of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Add to any of that a birth parent with a mental illness. There are not systems in place here in the States or any where on the planet that I am aware of that can help these children. Then to hand them to well meaning people who want to have an impact on a child's life and they don't realize the impact the child will have on their life.... especially when that impact is negitive.
    Unfortunately we cannot stop child abuse/neglect and we can't stop people from having children they cannot care for, but the children being adopted and the place from where they are being adopted must be as carefully scrutinized as the parents adopting them. I too encourage people to consider children here in our own back yard. Some of the struggle for forgin born children and the frustration besides the abuse and negelct is the culture shock. Having to learn to speak another language and bond with another family is alot to ask anyone...... If someone came to you and told you to move to another country and live with a strange family...... WOULD YOU DO IT?
    As for the comment from "TexasBorn" I think alot of this has been spurred on by celebrity.... like Angelina and Brad....., but those wanting to adopt need to remember these are children NOT TROPHIES!

  • Posted By: newsjunky @ 12/17/2007 3:49:53 PM

    Are you kidding me? This article is deeply disturbing. A woman beats her child to death and she is the victim? That is totally ridiculous!
    Imagine if we all got "fed up" with our children, spouses, co-workers and friends and just beat them to death. We all get really uspet at children at times but we don't punch and kick them. "When adoption goes wrong?" How about, "when unfit parents kill innocent children" that seems like more of a fitting title. This lady has no excuse for what she has done no matter if the child may have been a spawn from hell!

    • Posted By: kombucha @ 12/17/2007 4:20:51 PM

      I agree 100%. My sister and I were both difficult children, and my mother was the spanking type but she would never do any of those things that woman did! The article title was very misleading. And to all the people who are commenting it's hard to walk in those shoes - it is, of course it is! - that NEVER justifies hurting a child to the point of sending them to the hospital, or worse.

  • Posted By: ninamc65 @ 12/17/2007 2:16:15 PM

    I agree with "are-you-my-daddy", as harsh as the words sound. I am a 42 year old woman with no children, and I concur that being a parent is not meant for everyone. My husband has never had any children either, and this is a 2nd marriage for both of us. I was told early on (in my 20's) that because of a medical condition, it would be difficult if not impossible for me to get pregnant...I pretty much accepted that. While I think it's very noble to want to give a child a home, sometimes it's done for the wrong reasons... everyone else has them, the marriage is suffering and a couple thinks it will "save the marriage", etc. I agree that if you are unable to have children, go out and adopt a beautiful kitten or puppy from a shelter and give it a home, or find something else to fill your time and heart with, like charity work. My husband and I have a great marriage, even with no kids around and we don't really feel deprived. People should be more realistic about the responsibility of parenthood.

    • Posted By: are-you-my-daddy? @ 12/17/2007 4:16:08 PM

      Thank you for understanding where I am coming from, I really appreciate it.

    • Posted By: arcticblonde @ 12/17/2007 3:56:59 PM

      I'm really glad the wonderful woman who adopted me didn't feel the same way as you do!! She managed to be the best mom I could ever have hoped for and spent over 20 years of her life in a classroom helping special needs children. I agree that parenthood is not for everyone, take a look at all the children that are abused and neglected by their BIOLOGICAL parents as proof of that!

      I respect your decision not to adopt when you couldn't have kids but there's not a day of my life that I won't be grateful the woman who raised me made a completely different choice! Please realize that your choice, although best for you, was your choice and not the right choice for everyone else. Glad I didn't end up with teenage parents and/or a life of foster homes and orphanages because the woman who adopted me instead went out and got herself a kitten.

  • Posted By: childprotectionreform @ 12/17/2007 3:14:47 PM

    People forget that what children really want and need are their bio families. To tear children away from their bio parents is a traumatic life altering experience. To thrust them into an environment with strangers, foster homes, institutions, adoptive families is terrifying and dangerous. How many so-called orphans are genuinely abandoned with no bio family to care for them and how many have been snatched away by social services because the bio parents were poor or troubled? This article clearly demonstrates the need for social services to start assisting families and children and stop tearing them apart. Protecting children has become a profitable industry in which there are cash incentives to take children into protective custody, confine them to a foster home or institution, or adopt them out and it is literally destroying these kids lives. We don't even know the difference between a real orphan (the kind with no family) and the modern day orphan as defined by social services (the kind with family) anymore. We have a corrupted sense of compassion that includes taking kids from struggling families in the name of child protection, a for-profit industry that erroneously refers to itself as non-profit and subjecting them to the horrors and abuse so rampant in foster care and institutions, then adopting them out to strangers who may or may not be able to love and care for them. It would obviously be so much better for the child if we could use our funding and resources to assist bio-families. Only when we have gotten back on the right track of genuinely trying to help children and families will we bring an end to these horror stories. Think of the many ways to help these kids and their mothers, fathers and grandparents. Stop giving the funding to strangers and start helping the families who really need it. It's clear that strangers aren't always qualifed to be good parents either. It would better in the long run for the kids, their families and society as a whole to give the help and funding to children and families in need and work to help them through whatever obstacles they are encountering in life, keeping the family in tact. With our love, understanding, patience and guidance these children could stay home which is where they want and need to be!

    • Posted By: tigger05 @ 12/17/2007 4:13:30 PM

      I agree those who are trying should be helped, but I know of a woman who would not clean her home to keep her children. All she had to do was clean her home and maintain a safe living environment for her children. The difficult question here would be if the parents just want the money or do they really love their children?

  • Posted By: kombucha @ 12/17/2007 8:11:38 AM

    About that lady who went crazy and killed her daughter, I don't see what that really has to do with the main focus of the story - it seems clear to me that the combination of alcohol, repressed anger, and poor communication were the main motivating factors. My parents have reprimanded me before but you can't blame killing your daughter on Russia, that's just ridiculous.

    • Posted By: kimp @ 12/17/2007 9:33:28 AM

      you obviously do not have a russian child with issues. I have a daughter 7 years old from russia, I have raised 3 boys all grown now and have never dealt with the issues i have to on a daily basis with my daughter. My husband and i are professionals that understand children, however you cannot understand unless you are the shoes. DONT JUDGE.

      • Posted By: kombucha @ 12/17/2007 4:12:32 PM

        My younger sister behaved in the same way as the girl in the story when she was younger. She had to take a lot of different medications, most of which didn't help. She would physically beat my mother and has put me in the hospital, throwing at us scissors, knives, pretty much anything she could get her hands on. She would also get into tantrums and kick, scream, spit, and hiss at us, as well as calling us the worst most derogatory names she could think of. Whenever we tried reprimanding her, she would break windows, doors, and put holes in the walls of our family home. My mother had to work two jobs to support us kids so I was usually at the forefront of her agressions. She is my blood sister. The point of my comment was that ANYONE can have a child with these problems, which is why I said blaming it all on Russia (Eastern Europe) as this article did is not valid. Before you are so quick to tell me in caps, "DON'T JUDGE", I have to ask you to look in the mirror and ask yourself the same thing.

    • Posted By: kimp @ 12/17/2007 9:38:06 AM

      i have raised 3 boys all grown, then we adopted a 7 year old girl from russia. You CANNOT understand what you go through....... DONT JUDGE. I love my daughter with all my heart but the things these children have gone through you could never understand.

      • Posted By: kombucha @ 12/17/2007 4:01:07 PM

        WHAT? This comment makes no sense at all. There's always a chance that any child from any country, including your own children, will have problems. Also I must say that to insinuate that I have no idea what they're going through is sheer ignorance on your part, and also none of your business. As a self-professed "expert" such as yourself, surely you can understand my main focus here.

  • Posted By: are-you-my-daddy? @ 12/17/2007 4:07:14 PM

    I apologize to the people I have personally offended, that was never my intention in posting. I only wanted to share my personal experience and opinion to show people what one person passionately feels about something they have dealt wth their whole life. I hope people can see my post for what it is, an adopted person speaking about an issue that is near and dear to their heart.
    marissaanne -"You would rather that all the women who are in severe mental pain because they can't have children, stay in that pain because you haven't dealt with your childhood trauma. "
    REPLY to marissanne-I would rather that all the women who are in severe mental pain for any reason DO NOT even think about attempting to adopt a child. Please read the comment by "ninamc65" in response to my post I feel it is a very rational sounding interpretation of the message I tried to get across.
    newsjunqie-" That same reasoning also means that people who have children are most capable of raising a child, even the ones who abuse, torture and kill their children."
    REPLY to newsjunqie- That is a very absurd interpretation of my reasoning. I never said or implied anything like that.

  • Posted By: adoptionworker @ 12/17/2007 3:53:08 PM

    When prospective adoptive parents are having their home study completed, preparation and training needs to be intensive - all too often, it is not, as the Agency licensing the family is only interested in the monetary aspect of facilitating adoption, not making sure the family is prepared to parent a child. Every adoptive parent needs to be prepared for the fact that any child they adopt, whether they are newborn or 15, foreign or domestically born, will have special needs. Those special needs may be mild and close to non-existent, but it is only fair to disclose just how significantly traumatized these children may be, regardless of what you are told initially, because just moving from one home or orphanage to another can cause significant damage. One should NEVER assume "this child just needs love and they will be OK". It is vital for people to understand that you are adopting to meet a CHILD'S needs, and not your own desire to have a perfect family with a child who will provide you unconditional love. Working in the public child welfare adoption system, I have seen many adoptions occur, and while they can be the beautiful creation of a family, it takes WORK. And I have seen the ugly side, where families drop their children at the doorstep, saying they can't handle an adoptive child's behaviors one more day, whether they adopted them 10 weeks or 10 years ago. People interested in adoption need to do a LOT of homework to prepare for parenting an adopted child. I recommend such books such as Twenty Things Adopted Kids Wish Their Adoptive Parents Knew by S. Eldridge or Raising Adopted Children, Revised Edition: Practical Reassuring Advice for Every Adoptive Parent

    • Posted By: TheRealDeal @ 12/17/2007 4:05:40 PM

      Thanks so much for the comment. Hopefully the prospective parent that posted earlier will see your comment and look for the books you mentioned as a good place to start their education. No, love isn't the only thing these kids need but it's a big part. Love plus well prepared adoptive parents would definitely be the ideal. Thanks for the work you do in helping kids, you're continuing it here. :)
      It is really sad though that people feel they can just return a child like they might a defective product they bought at a store. :\

  • Posted By: dereksmommie @ 12/17/2007 4:01:13 PM

    How can this "mom" be made the victim? What about this little girl that was killed at the hands of someone who was suppose to love her unconditionally. Parenting does not come with a handbook and if this mom was having trouble, then she should have turned to someone for help, not jumping into an alcohol bottle.
    It takes a real coward not to seek help when your temper is getting the better of you.

  • Posted By: newsjunky @ 12/17/2007 3:57:40 PM

    a child is beaten to death and the murderer is the victim? Is it just me or is this deeply disturbing to anyone else? Whether or not a child gets on your last nerves, you do not kick them while they are on the ground and punch them. This article should have been named, "when unfit parents adopt a child" instead.

  • Posted By: grovebaby69 @ 12/17/2007 3:53:12 PM

    With all the anger in this world, a child is the light at the end of the tunnel. It's not easy to be a mom or dad for that matter but with lots of interacting with the child they have a tendency to grow on you there are many obstacials to over come but surely no child needs to be beaten to a bloodly pulp to satisfy our own aggression. There is no excuse for beating a child who was calling for the love unconditionally that put them in the place they find themselves. love can conquer ALL

  • Posted By: TenshiJaNai @ 12/17/2007 3:41:55 PM

    You say that we shouldn't take the kids away but my mom is a social worker and i see the horrors of what these children face with their biological family. Baby Alice who was born a drug addict and was beaten while in her infancy. My mom recieved her when she was 3 months covered in bruises. These kids would be dead but you want us to leave them there anyway?!?

    • Posted By: TheRealDeal @ 12/17/2007 3:51:14 PM

      I don't think anyone said that. Obviously there are cases where the children have to be taken, for their own safety. But there are other cases where the family is simply financially distressed and helping with this means the kids get to stay. I would hope that if I was a parent in a situation where I was struggling to feed and clothe my kids that someone would help me do so before they stepped in and just took my kids away.

  • Posted By: goldieb01 @ 12/17/2007 3:46:01 PM

    This woman is crazy. And needs to be beat herself. Honestly if this would have been a woman of ethnic decent it would have been plasted on every news wall through out the country. I understand life being to hard. You know what fix it. She is Blond and White and so we should understand even though this is horrific. I am glad it is being somewhat publisized. But there is a crazy gene in these people that is not being recognized. And this is wrong just DEAD wrong. And it doesn't just happen with adopted kids. I hear of these stories all the time. But they do not get the media that a Michael Vic gets for Dog fights. Yes that was sad a wrong too, but kids vs dogs. Give me a break. We know why one gets A beam of light and why the other gets a candle flicker. Lets begin to be real POPLE if you want world peace lets start with national equality. LOL.

  • Posted By: TenshiJaNai @ 12/17/2007 3:45:48 PM

    the thing is that there are already a lot of children that can be adopted here. There are far to many children in the system without adding more. Outlawing abortion would not solve anything. It would only add more problems. If people wanted to adopt an American baby they could but it has become fashionable to adopt children from other countries. Don't confuse this issue with the controversy of abortion. they are two different things.

  • Posted By: cubilady @ 12/17/2007 3:42:35 PM

    I am in the process of adopting a 5 year old boy from the united states. My story is different. I knew the childs family for many years. He was in the care of his paternal grandparents when they passed away. I have had non-relative custody for the past 3 years. It has been very, very, very difficult. I think the first year was so difficult because he was spoiled rotten. He did as he pleased. Woke up when he wanted, slept when he liked, hit, kicked, didn't like to bathe, spit you name it. Both of his parents are mentally ill. He has no simptoms but these signs usually come out during puberty. I am praying that this does not happen when the time comes. fast forward.... Now he is a happy, well behaved, wonderful child. It was long getting here and I did express my concerns to everyone including my worker. I am an open book and voiced my concerns to everyone. Nothing could have prepared me for this. Had I known it would have been like this I would probably have not done it. But he is here, I love him and he is part of my family. I plan to tell him the whole truth when he gets older. He does not remember fully that he was somewhere else before my home. I pray for the best. I can have children and have 2 older children of my own. They helped alot. There are no stories to help someone in making this HUGE decision. All they say is that it is wonderful. It is only if you are blessed to get a wonderful situation......

  • Posted By: im4life @ 12/17/2007 3:37:17 PM

    In most cases, children adopted over seas are getting a much better home life then they would have staying in an orphanage. It is mentioned that's it's getting harder to adopt overseas and there aren't as many children to adopt in the U.S. But, has anyone considered that if this country weren't killing thousands of innocent unborn babies everyday that there could be plenty of children up for adoption in our own country. We could create less of a problem with pulling overseas children out of their natural habitat, if you will, and giving the less fortunate children of this country a better chance instead, when their "bio family" isn't an option. But since it is still legal to kill our unborn children for whatever reason, families wanting children will have to spend much more time and money to try, and maybe succeed, to adopt wherever they can. Or, maybe adoption in our country should be advertised more to pregnant women of all ages. It would be a healthier, safer choice for all involved.

  • Posted By: momoften @ 12/17/2007 3:37:02 PM

    Having been through the adoption process of a Russian child, I can sympathize with this mother. We were given a total sob story about our daughter and were lied to repeatedly, told she was healthy, normal, and loving. Instead, we later found that our 10 year old daughter spoke Russian like a 5 year old would. This was the beginning of a trip down "severely learning disabled lane" that has gone on for over 8 years. She will NEVER live a 'normal" life and much of it could've beeen helped had they told us the TRUTH so we could have gotten her help in the beiginning. It's the lies that upset me so much. It was the most stressful experience of my life.

  • Posted By: childprotectionreform @ 12/17/2007 3:15:02 PM

    People forget that what children really want and need are their bio families. To tear children away from their bio parents is a traumatic life altering experience. To thrust them into an environment with strangers, foster homes, institutions, adoptive families is terrifying and dangerous. How many so-called orphans are genuinely abandoned with no bio family to care for them and how many have been snatched away by social services because the bio parents were poor or troubled? This article clearly demonstrates the need for social services to start assisting families and children and stop tearing them apart. Protecting children has become a profitable industry in which there are cash incentives to take children into protective custody, confine them to a foster home or institution, or adopt them out and it is literally destroying these kids lives. We don't even know the difference between a real orphan (the kind with no family) and the modern day orphan as defined by social services (the kind with family) anymore. We have a corrupted sense of compassion that includes taking kids from struggling families in the name of child protection, a for-profit industry that erroneously refers to itself as non-profit and subjecting them to the horrors and abuse so rampant in foster care and institutions, then adopting them out to strangers who may or may not be able to love and care for them. It would obviously be so much better for the child if we could use our funding and resources to assist bio-families. Only when we have gotten back on the right track of genuinely trying to help children and families will we bring an end to these horror stories. Think of the many ways to help these kids and their mothers, fathers and grandparents. Stop giving the funding to strangers and start helping the families who really need it. It's clear that strangers aren't always qualifed to be good parents either. It would better in the long run for the kids, their families and society as a whole to give the help and funding to children and families in need and work to help them through whatever obstacles they are encountering in life, keeping the family in tact. With our love, understanding, patience and guidance these children could stay home which is where they want and need to be!

    • Posted By: TheRealDeal @ 12/17/2007 3:27:52 PM

      Seconded! I worked with a gal who is a product of the foster care system in the US. She was in foster care from the time she was six years old and she shared with me the 'dirt' of the system from her own personal experiences, which were horrific and eye opening. One thing to note, there has been a shift in view in some agencies and policies are beginning to change as well since it has been realized that snatching kids away from families isn't always the best way. Many agencies are now trying to find a way to keep families together first. It's a difficult struggle since in many of the cases there is substance abuse and physical and verbal abuse involved but in some cases it's also working. I for one am glad they're beginning to try and help the families first before they take the kids away. I hope things continue that direction.

  • Posted By: Stormwolf_28 @ 12/17/2007 2:59:43 PM

    Oh yeah one more thing, they need to pass their learning torch down through their generations.So that way they can put a stop to this.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse