When Adoption Goes Wrong

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: monica83 @ 12/17/2007 2:45:40 PM

    I am a 24 year old multi-racial female, who was adopted in the United States, by two white parents. I found out to my surprise at the age of 18 that I had not only been misinformed by the adoption agency, however that they were lied to by my birthmother, who put on the birth certificate that my birthfather was black, not white. Throughout my childhood and adolescence, I was tortured emotionally and mentally by peers at school, constantly struggling to find out what my true identity was. At the age of 18 when I was making the transition to college, I was then forced to deal with the identity of being bi-racial.
    I think that this article sheds light on the stressors of adopting a child, however, I wish that there were more articles on mult-racial adoptions, rather than the adoptions that are peformed overseas. In my own case, I thought that it would be a great experience to meet my birthmother, however, to my dismay and frustration, I ended up having to put a restraining order against her, due to her inability to handle the reunification.
    I think that for future reference, possibly, shedding light on the different adoptions that occur in this U.S country, rather than outside countries might be more interesting, and also shedding light on those individuals who are willing to take multi-racial children, and raise them to be positive, and successful people, not the horror stories.

    • Posted By: TheRealDeal @ 12/17/2007 2:59:31 PM

      Have to agree, wholeheartedly. I would love it if positive news was more often reported. Yes, people need to know about the issues and difficulties others around the world face so that the problems can be worked on but it would also be nice if we heard the other side more often. It seems that balance is very difficult to achieve but it's necessary to know of both the struggles people have and the successes so we don't either wallow in depression or entertain unrealistic expectations.
      And I'm very sorry that things didn't work out with your birth mother. I'm sure you had high hopes for the meeting. I wish you the best! :)

  • Posted By: Stormwolf_28 @ 12/17/2007 2:52:59 PM

    You want my comment? Here's one for you! The international countries from over seas, should reconsider these senseless adoptions. For one those countries need to take more governmental responsibilities, in opening more parental programs and taking more concerns for their citizens. Those families should be more prepared more responsibly. I for one am 28 years age and my wife is South Korean and we have a child together and I have been dreaming about my son since I was 18 years old. we love him to death.. that's what they should do. together

  • Posted By: TheRealDeal @ 12/17/2007 1:53:53 PM

    Wow, you make a lot of judgemental comments, you know? For someone who professes to be lacking arrogance, ignorance and claims to be loving enough to integrate the two, you definitely seem to have some issues. No one here is making any personal attacks against you or your family. No one here is saying that what you have done is wrong. What this is called is an open discussion where EVERYONE gets to share their opinions. That is great that adoption worked for you but the reality is that for MANY people it does not, even when they do absolutely everything they can to make it work. You seem to live in happy dreamland instead of reality. One couple in particular that I will mention took in two sets of children. The first set, brother and sister, came from a home where they were left to starve by drug addict parents. When the kids were finally rescued the baby was near dead, it had been in the crib so long and was so week that the back of its head had flattened and the brain was pushing out and making a lump on the baby's forehead. Due to this the baby was SEVERELY brain damaged. This child will NEVER be a zooligist and can NEVER even aspire to such. Instead he has to be constantly watched so he doesn't abuse the other children. As I stated before, mixing the two, both biological and adopted, works for SOME kids but definitely not in all cases. Quit trying to tear people apart for stating the truth. And by the way, my friends have ALL made sure their adopted kids have gotten the help they needed. My POINT was, if you bothered to pay attention to what I said, was that their biological kids have suffered immensely, which also is truth. You talk so much about the "little people" and that they are smart. Well guess what, the little people didn't get asked if they wanted adopted kids as part of the family. According to YOUR logic they should have been asked, consulted and prepared. And if we face reality once more, what young child can possibly comprehend all that will be required for being the sibling of very abusive kids? We are talking abusive here, by the way, not just a child with difficulties.

    • Posted By: sgtpepper @ 12/17/2007 2:22:08 PM

      I'm sticking up for you! You're absolutely right.

      • Posted By: TheRealDeal @ 12/17/2007 2:42:41 PM

        Heh, thanks. I didn't mean to cause a flame war. In hopes that flame wars don't escalate, I refuse to verbally assault people, even if they've assaulted me but I will state my case better if needed and hope it calms the snap judgements. I don't understand why people so quickly judge others when they don't have all the facts.

  • Posted By: ConcernedParent @ 12/17/2007 2:38:06 PM

    It is unfortunate that people won'r read articles unless they are horrifying. I thought this article was fairly well done, but there were at least ten thousand successful foreign adoptions last year. We adopted our daughter from China in 2004, and her adjustment was challenging, but also wonderful. In order to create perspective you need to write an article about the deeply personal decision to adopt, and the miracle that it is. Grace is not my adoped Chinese daughter, She is just my daughter, with characterisictics that remind her of myself, and her father, She has a normal relationship with her siblings, they adore her and she also drives them crazy - as 4 years do. She is this remarkable, tenacious, extraordinary kid who amazes anyone who meets her. She asks questions, and talks about her own story nearly everyday. She knows who she is, where she come from and she loves her family. We are adopting again, our 5th child, from China in spring 2009. We believe the one who comes to us is meant for us. Most parents I talk to feel the same way. The circumstances that will bring that child to us may be difficult, we have no control over that, we just know that what we are doing is right, and what we want. I was really troubled by your surrogacy story as well - you just did your best to make it as ugly a thing as possible. It seemed a miraculous thing to me. There are people in the world who love children, understand the desire for a child, and whose sacrifice to bring a child to a couple is a noble and honorable thing. The night before we went to China to adopt our daughter, a vicous relative of ours told her sweet toddler son to say goodbye, that we were going to China to buy a baby. Everyone else just brought flowers and tears and love. Some people are allergic to happiness. I think the author of this article also has some race issues, and does not like children very much. The article will undoubtedly embarrass many good people, drive others away to be left childless, damage the relationship we have with countries who allow Americans to adopt. It is a destructive thing that ultimately will hurt children the most, and I just do not understand that, people who attack a child, verbally or physically.

  • Posted By: LOVINGMama @ 12/17/2007 11:47:46 AM

    I have had a US adoption go "bad". I have 2 boys and adopted a 5 year old girl. We were told that she was ADHD. That was ok, I have dealt with that and RAD in one of my sons. However when she came to our house her wonderful behavior disappeared. She did all of the things you can imagine, killing pets, and when she tried to kill my younger son, we gave her back. I can not even try to explain how stressful it was, and how it changed our behavior as parents. All of the training we had didnt work. We found out later that she had RAD, ADHD, fetal alcohol syndrome, and at that age they dont call it multi-personality disorder, but she had all the signs of it.No one wanted to tell us this, as she had been adopted and returned several times. None of this justifies killing the child, however I have walked that path, and I feel for the mother. Its sad that it ruined the family, and that the girl couldnt be saved. We lost a few friends that thought we gave up too soon or that we should have been "better" parents to her and it would have worked. All I can say is I hope that those who cast judgment dont ever have to eat their words, because its a horrible experience for a family to go through.

    • Posted By: TexasBorn @ 12/17/2007 2:34:08 PM

      We will make sure to have our own kids.

  • Posted By: Gracefox @ 12/17/2007 2:22:36 PM

    Katerswi - one more thing - what in my post led you to believe that I am passing judgement and on whom? I agree with your last line that if she got help from people who understood her child and how to help both of them, that both lives would have been saved. By the way, how could she have hidden something like this from her husband? (as the article states). What would you say is the best way to help these children? What have you seen that works?

  • Posted By: pinkgoo20 @ 12/17/2007 11:33:16 AM

    This is an excellent article; I only wish my parents had known about all of this before they adopted two 11-year-old boys from Russia. A few weeks after coming into our home, they sexually molested my 7-year-old sister. They both have RAD and are absolutely impossible to live with. They lie, steal, throw fits of anger constantly, and physically harm all of our family members. It has destroyed our family life, as my two sisters and my mother are now living away from home until we can get the two boys out of our home. We just wish that the orphanage, the agency, and everyone else had been honest with us about the mental health of these boys.

    • Posted By: Russia @ 12/17/2007 2:19:36 PM

      I am sorry for your family. It does not sound like the agency did their job. There are agencies out there who bring older children for an extended stay (perhaps for like the summer). That wasy both parties get to know each other. Then the children are sent back to Russia. If the family who they lived with for the extended stay is interested and the child is interested then the paperwork for an adoption will be put through. I think if your family was given that opportunity the result may have been different.

    • Posted By: kleu @ 12/17/2007 11:48:37 AM

      That's such a shame, because I'm sure your parents had nothing but good intentions for these children. I think these orphanages are so desperate to get rid of these problem kids they intentionally mislead prospective parents. I hope you can get those kids out of the home as soon as possible, I'll pray for your younger sister.

    • Posted By: DarthBob_2005 @ 12/17/2007 11:42:20 AM

      If its getting to the point where you're family has to live in separate places, you need to find someone who can re-adopt those boys. At that point the family is already separated anyway so finding another home with someone else who can help those boys could be doing whats best for you and them. As a former brother of a kid with RAD, I sympathize with you a lot. Good luck!

  • Posted By: nebfluan @ 12/17/2007 2:14:50 PM

    a child is a gift from god. u lucky to hav been able to adopt a child since there are so many parents that are still waiting to adopt one.u already adopted one n killed her. i believe that you should hav talked abt the problem tou someone, mayb ur husband...or you should hav asked for help wen the gurl was getting aggressive n not let the year and a half come to ur head. it really is a shame beating a child to death. i pray no child get such a mother coz a child needs care, love, hugs not beat.

  • Posted By: BJohnston @ 12/17/2007 1:47:52 PM

    Are you people listening to what is being said here?? How dare it even be suggested that the child was a factor in driving this woman to do what she did. Are you seriously kidding me?? First off, if you want a child so badly that you adopt you also need to anticipate behavior problems. Undoubtedly, a child going through this change in her life is going to have struggles possibly long term scarring. There is NO EXCUSE period. I am disgusted by the writer's tone of this story, how he basically blames the childs behavior to drive this, so- called mother to drink. Give me a break. Are you seriously telling me a child, a 2 year old child caused this woman to become a alcoholic, and a monster? Stop making excuses for her "... Hilt didn't have access to the resources " commentator. What is wrong with you people? Are you guys seriously kidding me?? I have a child that drives me to the end, and I have dealt with children from dysfunctional backrounds that have pushed me to the limits, and yes I know that it is not always possible to keep your cool. However, I could never even began to fathom dropkicking and punching my child or any child. I just love how all of you out there in your pathetic passive-aggressive tones, seem to want to help this child abuser share the blame for her acts. I pray that none of you have children of your own. God help them if you do. All I have to say is thank God he has a reason for everything and it was obviously clear why this woman was not able to have kids of her own.

    • Posted By: sulivel @ 12/17/2007 2:11:31 PM

      oh thank you, I think you are the only here who makes sense to me... this child is a victim... and there is much more to this story because if they were preparing to go on a trip and the woman got drunk, put the child to sleep, etc, etc. I don't know...

  • Posted By: SYSTEM OF A DOWN @ 12/17/2007 2:07:59 PM

    hilt you son of a *** why dont you try being a adopted child waiting everyday for someone to adopt you and then some women adopts you and kills you because there tiered of you you could have just put nina in adoption again but it wouldnt be very nice but its better than killing her.

  • Posted By: nebfluan @ 12/17/2007 2:07:21 PM

    A child is awonderful gift. you were lucky enough u hav been able to adopt one since there are so many people who wana adopt achild but can't. i believe you should hv talked about your problem and asked for help so that the year and a half oes not come to your head. beating 2 year old to deah is relly horribl. i pray no child get such a mother...maybe if she was ur own daughter u would have thought twice efore beating her like this and mayb u would have helped the child we she was being aggresive.

  • Posted By: sulivel @ 12/17/2007 2:03:59 PM

    why in the heck do people have more patience and can be more loving to a dog...

  • Posted By: Abdulmumin @ 12/17/2007 6:06:30 AM

    I am 26 years of age from Ghana not married but i think it is good to get married and have children of your own
    rather than going in for adoption.It is a high level of stupidity to adopt a child and is uncall for,and also mine you blood is ticker than water.This child will never and ever appreciate all the good things that you have been doing to them.If you really wants to have kids never mine Race or were ever the person is coming from or whatever he or she is madeup of.You can even make your way to Africa and get maaried and start giving your children and live in a happy life and stop adoption.
    Thank you.(adorimonaa1@yahoo.com)

    • Posted By: twatson1128 @ 12/17/2007 2:01:13 PM

      You are just an idealistic dumbass with no life experiences of your own when it comes to raising or having children healthy or not. Whoever came up with that saying had the same idealistic stupidity. But thats okay, life has a way of teaching one lessons needed to show empathy towards others! I just hope it isn't your own children who have to suffer the burden of teaching you!

  • Posted By: angelstar93 @ 12/17/2007 1:59:52 PM

    I really do pity this adopitive mother... she didn't bargain for what she got. I'm sure she expected a normal child, so she could have a happy family! And instead she got a problem child. Adoptions cost a lot, and for a child to come from so far away, she must have felt she couldn't send the child back! But that's what she should've done, if at all possible! I'm sorry for the death of the child...of course. But I can understand how the mother lost her mind. I can say that I would never beat a child like that,,, but we can always say we wouldn't do something when we're not in the position, and not dealing with the immediate stress! It's alwasy easy to stand by and crtiticize another person for being weak, but we don't know how we would react in a similar situation - or in a situation that over-taxes our emotions... It's a tragedy - plain and simple. The mother has also lost her life!

  • Posted By: sulivel @ 12/17/2007 1:52:28 PM

    just like that child was put for adoption for whatever reason, then she should have put it for adoption again if she could not deal with it, she had plenty of warnings if she felt like snapping before... she beat a child to death "hello"

  • Posted By: katerswi @ 12/17/2007 12:33:17 PM

    I completely disagree with "Gracefox". You have obviously never worked or have been around a child with reactive attachment disorder otherwise known as RAD. I suggest you educate yourself before passing judgement or assuming anything. I work with with children who have RAD on a daily basis. It is people like you who are continuing to allow these children to suffer because you are choosing to believe this is not happening. Yes, there are many adoptions that have gone smoothly. However, almost half of the children I work with at the residential treatment center have RAD. They are aggressive, untrusting and manipulative.
    Some say they are in constant "survival mode" and will do anything and everything to get what they want or need. In order to help these children live a healthy and meaningful life, people need to know what they have gone through, try to understand it and help them. I suggest you try to do the same. I am in no way sticking up for Hilt. She committed an unthinkable crime and should have to pay for it. However, I do think that if she was educated and knew that there were resources and people (such as myself) out there to help her, Nina would be alive today. PERIOD.

    • Posted By: Gracefox @ 12/17/2007 1:50:08 PM

      Katerswi - I'm only saying that situations like these are not limited to adopted children. I know RAD exists - I'm a teacher working in a secure residential facility and see it everyday. I'm focusing on the fact that the article makes it seem like it's solely and adoption issue. I'm interested in one thing you mentioned: you stated that "half of the children you work with have RAD" Have these children all been adopted?

  • Posted By: sulivel @ 12/17/2007 1:50:06 PM

    If she felt like snapping before then she should have renounced to the care of this child... no child should have gone through this kind of abuse and 19 years or a life sentence will never bring this child back... why did she only get 19 years?

  • Posted By: astaire10 @ 12/17/2007 1:33:53 PM

    To "THE REAL DEAL"::
    You make a hideous MISTAKE in so obviously putting up boundaries between an ADOPTED child and a BIOLOGICAL child! These are CHILDREN, NO MATTER WHAT their origins, there ARE parents who can sucessfully navigate the waters and BLEND the two into BROTHERS AND SISTERS! What in HELL is the matter with that??"BREAK YOUR OWN KIDS"?? The ONLY people responsible for dong that is THE PARENT! Kids are much smarter than we give them credit for, and you are obviously NOT "open" enough to give a child who needs a family a HOME, and NEITHER qare your friends! A CHILD's well-being is ALWAYS "worth the risk" ! I have an adopted son who is now 17 and wanting to be a zoologist or a policeman..It has been a Great success and also with the other children who DO consider him "BROTHER"..
    Id advise you to LISTEN to children FOR ONCE, and stop putting up such ridiculous barriers among little people, who , regardless of their histories, merely want to be LOVED ! Whether young or old, the world would a far better place if people like you would relax your ARROGANCE and SNOBBERY!

    • Posted By: sgtpepper @ 12/17/2007 1:48:05 PM

      To astaire10: Relax! Everyone is entitled to their own opinions. There's no need to get so offended when that clearly wasn't what the commenter was trying to do. People are allowed to write virutally whatever they want; there's no need to attack someone the way you did.

  • Posted By: alynne0185 @ 12/17/2007 1:47:25 PM

    The Hilts may have been victims of a corrupt system but they are at fault for not seeking legal advice and medical and pyschiatric help for their adopted child and their family to help them cope with adopting a disturbed child. There is no excuse for the crime Mrs. Hilt committed. This is not a problem specific to international children but for many children in the United States who have had traumatic childhoods and are victims of abuse and neglect. People should not be so naive as to think that adopting from overseas is easier than adopting an American child, in terms of the child's behavior. And people should also be very careful when dealing with a foreign institution so as to not be duped as the Hilts were.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse