When Adoption Goes Wrong

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: indiaadoptionmama @ 12/17/2007 3:57:18 PM

    TenshiJaNai wrote: "If people wanted to adopt an American baby they could but it has become fashionable to adopt children from other countries. "

    Don't be fooled -- international adoption is GRUELING work. It's not a fashion statement, it's a way to build families for some who have no other options.

    You think that U.S. adoption is so readily available for anyone who wants it -- it's NOT. Adoption in the U.S. is more expensive and leads to more closed doors than international.

    • Posted By: Sincere1967 @ 12/17/2007 5:27:30 PM

      I hate to disagree with you but the USA is one of the top countries when it comes to exporting children via adoption. Did you know that Germany is the number one adopter of African-American and Bi-racial children in the world. Be honest and upfront. its only hard for white parents to adopt infant white babies. They would rather adopt a child from a culture they know nothing about just to avoid adopting a Black baby. Just because they adopt children of color from other countries doesn't mean they are not racist. I think this demonstrates just how much hatred white Americans can have for African Americans.

      • Posted By: TheRealDeal @ 12/17/2007 10:29:49 PM

        Your statement may be true for SOME white Americans but certainly not all and certainly not anyone I know unless they are 90 years old. Both sides of our family, my husband's and mine, are happy to have people from all different ethinicities, yes, including "black Americans", as you said. Matter of fact, we don't see race, we only see people we love. It's viewpoints such as this with such broad statements that are damaging. And by the way, many white parents do try to adopt African American kids within the US and are told it's wrong because they can't possibly give the child the type of environment they'd have with an African American family. There are many sides to every issue. Please don't use such terrible generalizations as if they apply to all of us.

  • Posted By: WallfloweRyan @ 12/17/2007 10:28:39 PM

    I have a younger brother who was adopted from Russia. Not everything was perfect when he first came to live with us, but just like any other child he simply needed love and patience. Children adopted from foreign countries not only have to adjust to a new family but to a completely different lifestyle, a different culture. Nothing is familiar. How can you blame a child from acting out when they are forced outside of their comfort zone, albeit for the better. Adoptive parents, and especially adoptive families need to do their part by learning about the culture that their child will be coming from. Families especially should attend some sort of family therapy.

  • Posted By: WallfloweRyan @ 12/17/2007 10:28:12 PM

    I have a younger brother who was adopted from Russia. Not everything was perfect when he first came to live with us, but just like any other child he simply needed love and patience. Children adopted from foreign countries not only have to adjust to a new family but to a completely different lifestyle, a different culture. Nothing is familiar. How can you blame a child from acting out when they are forced outside of their comfort zone, albeit for the better. Adoptive parents, and especially adoptive families need to do their part by learning about the culture that their child will be coming from. Families especially should attend some sort of family therapy.

  • Posted By: zarazame @ 12/17/2007 10:27:08 PM

    What difference does it make if the kids are foreign born or American born? Most kids adopted later in their lives DO have problems, American kids included. Tell me why an adoptive parent expects it to be picture perfect? Are they simply stupid? How else can anyone expect a perfect child coming out of the
    imperfect situation early in their lives? They need someone to stand by them NO MATTER WHAT! Shame on these so called parents!

  • Posted By: jalaia @ 12/17/2007 10:23:34 PM

    To Ariel_555: I am an adoptive parent, and I thank the Universe every day for my son. I never knew I could love so much, and I suspect your parents feel the same. I wonder why you have the perspective you do, and if anyone knows the depth of your bitterness. I got the impression the article was written to address foreign adoptions and the extent of the deceptions practiced by the agencies involved. Was your situation similar to these? It sounds like you believe you are the one deceived and betrayed by the adoption process.

  • Posted By: zarazame @ 12/17/2007 10:21:47 PM

    What difference does it make if the kids are foreign born or American born? It seems like the author is actually siding with American parents for killing foreign born kids (yeah her heart goes out for them, poor things, they just wanted everything to be picture perfect, guess what, you should not expect it to be, it is a human being not a THING to get rid of it when things go wrong.

  • Posted By: ESwann @ 12/17/2007 10:13:44 PM

    It's unfortunate that a story about a deeply troubled child is headlined as a story about adoption. This is NOT a story about adoption gone wrong. There is only one line in the story that makes sense as an adoption story -- the parents did not have realistic expectations of parenting. Bio or adopted, there are no guarantees that your child will be physically and emotionally strong and healthy. Check the daily news to see yet another child engaged in violent, sociopathic behavior. This is billed as an "adoption" story because it's sensationalist and it sells... it's a hook, to grab your attention... because, honestly, who would care about a loving mother who is driven to drink by her emotionally disturbed biological child and who eventually gets pushed over the edge and injures or kills her child. Check the local ER -- those stories are far more common than you would suspect.. There is no question that adoptive kids (and their parents) face distinctive challenges, but this story does little to shed light on that topic. Instead it spreads ignorance. it's irresponsible and simply bad journalism.

    • Posted By: DarthBob_2005 @ 12/17/2007 10:19:57 PM

      But this type of stuff does happen in adoption cases. Believe me I know from personal experience. The parents don't know what they're getting into when they adopt, and they end up bringing home a kid that urinates on them and wants to kill them and can't bond with the parent whatsoever. Even if the parent is non-abusive, that doesn't stop a kid with RAD from abusing a parent.

  • Posted By: Bookem @ 12/17/2007 10:19:32 PM

    Adoption is Cruel? Maybe you should appreciate the fact that you were loved by you adoptive parents. Would you rather be living on the street or going from foster family to foster family? Many children overseas die from sickness that is easily curable in the US. Or they may just starve to death. That sounds like a much better life that being adopted. Don't let your bad experience ruin things for other adoptive parents and their children. Also, a child that is adopted is your "real child". They are loved just as much.

  • Posted By: zarazame @ 12/17/2007 10:19:02 PM

    What difference does it make if the kids are foreign born or American born? It seems like the author is actually siding with American parents for killing foreign born kids (yeah her heart goes out for them, poor things, they just wanted everything to be picture perfect, guess what, you should not expect it to be, it is a human being not a THING to get rid of it when things go wrong.

  • Posted By: jalaia @ 12/17/2007 10:17:43 PM

    To Ariel_555: I am an adoptive parent, and I thank the Universe every day for my son. I never knew I could love so much, and I suspect your parents feel the same. I wonder why you have the perspective you do, and if anyone knows the depth of your bitterness. I got the impression the article was written to address foreign adoptions where the parents are deceived by the agencies involved. Did that happen to you or your parents? It sounds to me like you believe you are the one who has been deceived and betrayed by life itself.

  • Posted By: Bookem @ 12/17/2007 10:10:52 PM

    Adoption is cruel? Would you rather be living on the street? Would you rather have no food and die from a sickness that is easily curable at a young age? Don't let your bad experience ruin how great adoption is for other children.

  • Posted By: brIteStar54 @ 12/17/2007 12:02:40 PM

    My sister adopted 3 kids from Russia. The two older ones are half-siblings. Their mother was a prostitute who also was an alchoholic. It turns out that the older one, at least, had been raped on several occasions by the time she was 7. The other child has serious health issues. Their youngest has a problem with stealing money from other family membes.
    I have two American kids that we adopted as babies. They are teens now, and they have some problems relating to the adoption. They are getting though it, with our help, and talk therapy. Adoption is NOT like having bio-kids.
    You have to be prepared for some difficulties.

    • Posted By: Russia @ 12/17/2007 2:24:56 PM

      Enter Your Comment
      I could not disagree more about your comments that adoption is not like having a bio-kid. My 2 children may not have grown in my belly but they sure did grow in my heart. It is a shame that you don't have this connection with your children. I hope you will someday.

      • Posted By: brIteStar54 @ 12/17/2007 4:15:12 PM

        How do you figure that I don't have a connection to my own children. By saying that the adoption experience in not like birthing yiour kids?
        The difference is that as teenagers want to "find themselves" they first have t o figure out their own concept of themselves as adopted. children. Find the birthfamily or not? How do I relate to the adults who raised me? These questions are not ones that bio-kids even have to consider.

        • Posted By: Russia @ 12/17/2007 10:10:29 PM

          My point was that you have to be prepared for problem whether your kids are "bio-kids" or adopted. Every teenager is going to have issues with "finding themselves". Being adopted doesn't make it anymore or less difficult just different.

        • Posted By: Russia @ 12/17/2007 10:10:27 PM

          My point was that you have to be prepared for problem whether your kids are "bio-kids" or adopted. Every teenager is going to have issues with "finding themselves". Being adopted doesn't make it anymore or less difficult just different.

  • Posted By: freezfreakies @ 12/17/2007 9:07:44 PM

    to "shanesaylor".....you have no idea what this mother probably went through, you can not say she wasn't ready or mature enough. I'm not excusing what she did, but you have NO idea. My parents adopted three domestically that were foster children. Two of them have been an absolute nightmare that even Mother Teresa could not possibly know what to do with. So stop judging. My parents were completely misinformed and directly lied to by the welfare system. My parents have sacrificed everything and there is NO one who knows how to help these kids. There are issues here and you have been lucky not to have them. Count your blessings and stop being condescending.

    • Posted By: mumtaz5 @ 12/17/2007 9:25:10 PM

      wow...you are obviously very emotional about this because your family has been a part of adoption but I have to reply to you as an adopted child that went through what you might call a 'nightmare' and my adoptive parents are wonderful people. I believe the attitude of 'Not knowing who knows how to help these kids' is giving up. When you have children you NEVER give up! I don't care if you gave birth to them or if you adopted them. There are always issues with children. Having children is about the child and the care of the child. When parents focus on how hard it is for them I have very empathy. IT'S NOT ABOUT YOU! Focus on the child 24/7 and it may take a lifetime but that is what you signed on for when you decided to have a child...or adopt one.

      • Posted By: freezfreakies @ 12/17/2007 10:09:16 PM

        I am emotional about it because I see what it has done to my parents. They've not given up on the children and I commend them for that. But I am telling you, for children that are emotionally disturbed it is very hard to find professionals that know how to handle it. Especially when the children are very adroit at manipulation. Even manipulating the professionals. One of the kids is 18 now and has chosen not to take her meds (she's schizophrenic) and she can not be forced to take it and let me tell you, she needs it. I am convinced that either one of these two children (the other is 11) will physically kill my parents. They've threatened it. They've already killed them mentally, finacially and emotionally. I am scared for them. I do love my adopted siblings, but I am frightened. I am also angry at my parents for putting me in a position deal with these kids when my parents die. I have chosen not to have children.

  • Posted By: GustoMaybe @ 12/17/2007 9:57:05 PM

    /\_ \ /\_ \ /\ \
    \//\ \ ___\//\ \ \_\ \ ___ ___ __ ____
    \ \ \ / __`\\ \ \ /'_` \ / __`\ /' _ `\ /'_ `\ /',__\
    \_\ \_/\ \L\ \\_\ \_/\ \L\ \/\ \L\ \/\ \/\ \/\ \L\ \/\__, `\
    /\____\ \____//\____\ \___,_\ \____/\ \_\ \_\ \____ \/\____/
    \/____/\/___/ \/____/\/__,_ /\/___/ \/_/\/_/\/___L\ \/___/
    /\____/
    \_/__/

  • Posted By: SuzPReese @ 12/17/2007 9:54:34 PM

    Despite the need to get help, there is really not a lot of help out there for parents - adoptive parents are, for the most part, left to their own devices, Despite all well-intended efforts, agencies simply do not provide the follow-up care that is needed...heck, even naturally conceived babies and their families don't get the support they need!...and we wonder why PPD is on the rise? In either case, the family must be supported - the mother, especially. Group community classes that care designed to help parent get in touch with their children hold a treasure-chest of benefits at often affordable rates. Sadly, few know about these, decide "I don't have the time" or if they don't know enough about it, they don't go. Baby Massage or Infant massage, Baby Signing, Baby Yoga, Family Music classes - these are all designed to foster the simple yet complex aspects of healthy infant/child growth and development - and they are fun and they get families connected with one another. It may seem like a simple approach - and it is, there are no big secrets here. It's about investing our hearts into our children (as a supportive society) - it is only then their hearts can grow.

  • Posted By: GustoMaybe @ 12/17/2007 9:52:52 PM

    ??? ??????????????? here is a teddy bear for the poor young girl
    ?????? | ??? ??? ???
    ??????/????????? ?????? |
    ??? |?????? (_???_) ???
    ???????????????|???| ?????????
    /??????????????? /??>??? )
    (??????????????????/???(_???
    ???|???????????? /
    ???|??????????????????
    ???|???/?????? )??? )
    ??????????????? ?????? ???
    ?????????????????? ??????)

  • Posted By: shanesaylor @ 12/17/2007 9:24:58 PM

    comment to freesgreakies,
    Did your parents shake them to death, probably not because they were mature enough.
    regardless, adoption has nothing to do with problem children, and that was the main point of my comments.
    So spare us your semantic grandstanding and see it for what it is, adoption is irrelevant to the situation, and these articles and news stories do nothing but diswaid people whom may have no other choice from doing a very rewarding thing.

    • Posted By: freezfreakies @ 12/17/2007 9:46:31 PM

      If someone is so weak minded that reading this article would dissuade them from adopting, maybe they shouldn't adopt. It is just something of which to be cognizant. Not all adoptions are horrible, I would hope that most people are reasonable enough to get that. But bad adoptions do happen so I'm saying count your blessing. Everyone is not as lucky as you.

  • Posted By: nohorarivers @ 12/17/2007 9:41:38 PM

    Thank goodness this important magazine is writing about this important issue to help adopting parents- to- be to have a clear view before making any decision. We adopted two children from Colombia two years ago, brtoher, 9 and sister, 8 after five long years of a lot of paper work ( social studies, FBI check ups, medical examinations, CPR trainings, psycholgical evaluations, trips and interviews) here and over there. The Agency over there, Instituto Colombiano de Bienestar Familiar promised us the children were very healthy physycal and mentally, since we requested "healthy children" because our son is handicapped. All their evaluations, medical and psychological, were perfect. Nothing wrong with them. Lovely kids. When these kids arrived to our house was when the nightmare started. They had all the problems that you describe as signs ( violence, sexual abuse, physical abuse, etc., etc.) but no one told us anything about it. The overseas agency only wanted to find a home for these children and lie to us. When we faced the situation we tried to returned them back to Colombia but the Agency said, too late since the children became USA citizens as soon as they arrived to the airport. To make this long story short, finally, the Agency in USA that did our paper work , helped us looking for another home for them. The reality is that adopting parents do not have enough information, there is no post-placement support or mental health help in the community. I think the Goverment needs to do a better job supporting people that the only thing they want to do is help children. Agencies need to be honest in the assessments they do before placing children and give parents as much information as they can in order to make the adoption process successful and a great experience for both parents and children. Great article. Thanks.
    The Rivers

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse