It is SO important to read this article with an inquiring mind. The so-called "investigator" makes many vague, generalized statements. It sounds to me like the "investigator" got no closer to Mr. Weaver's establishment than to observe 4 buildings and hear dogs barking. Yet the "investigator" feels at liberty to attempt to destroy this man's livlihood by labelling his operation as a puppy mill. A genuine puppy mill is a bad thing and there ARE laws enforced by local animal control people to protect helpless animals. It is important for the reader to realize that this "investigator" works for the HSUS which has an agenda. Notice the "investigator's" remark toward the end of this article about "we have created these animals....." Doesn't that sound odd? The HSUS holds that dogs and cats are unnnatural products of human run breeding programs that should never have happened to begin with. Ultimately, the HSUS wants to help the dear little puppies and kitties --- by making them extinct. (If you search a little, you can find published comments by the head of the HSUS to that effect.) Puppy mills need to be stopped, but the HSUS plans to stop ALL breeding of dogs and cats by the systematic persecution of ALL breeders, both good and bad.
There are many reasons for getting a dog from a shelter. Someone who is looking for a dog for a companion and has enough dog experience to be able to avoid bringing home a problem dog SHOULD go to a shelter. However, someone who is looking for a performance dog (a dog who will compete in agility, flyball, competition obedience, or some other dog sport) should go to a breeder. Like human athletes, a dog needs to be physically ABLE to compete in his sport. Someone who simply choses a cute dog from a shelter and teaches it to love a sport that is to demanding for the dog's physical structure, has done that dog no favors.
A purebred dog is a specialist. He was born able and desiring to do a certain job. It's a joy to him. A dog who is doing what he was bred and trained to do (like herding or hunting) is a glorious celebration of teamwork between a dog and an owner. Someone who is seeking a canine partner for such an activity needs to go to a reputable breeder who understands that breed of dog and that activity.
Yes, beware of puppy mills, but also be very wary of the HSUS and be kind to your local reputable breeders.









Discuss