CIA officials have insisted that any techniques used were approved by the White House and the Justice Department. CIA director Michael Hayden disclosed to agency employees last week that the agency had destroyed the tapes in November 2005 because it feared the tapes would leak and therefore compromise the identities of the interrogators.

But the disclosure has caused an uproar, provoking charges from some in Congress that the agency had destroyed what amounts to key evidence of the interrogations without the approval of the congressional oversight committees charged with monitoring the CIA's interrogation and detention program. Rodriquez is considered the key figure in the dispute since, as chief of the agency's clandestine service, he ordered that the tapes be destroyed.
A former government official familiar with Rodriguez's views on the tapes controversy says that Rodriguez and his associates maintain that they repeatedly sought instructions from CIA management over a two-year period about what to do with the tapes, but never got clear instructions.

According to the former official, who requests anonymity discussing such a sensitive matter, Rodriguez and other Clandestine Service officials sought guidance from both then-CIA director George Tenet and Tenet's successor, Porter Goss, about what to do with the tapes. This source maintains that John Rizzo, a senior CIA lawyer, also discussed the issue with Justice Department and White House lawyers, including senior White House lawyer Harriet Miers.
Current and former intelligence officials have told Newsweek that before ordering the tapes to be destroyed, Rodriguez obtained a written opinion from a CIA lawyer assigned to the Clandestine Service that concluded there was no explicit legal reason why the tapes would have to be preserved. However, sources familiar with this document insist that it did not authorize or recommend that the tapes be destroyed, and that the author of the legal opinion believed that Clandestine Service officials would seek further advice from more senior officials before destroying any tapes. The tapes themselves were never brought into the United States, but rather were stored—and destroyed—at a secret location overseas, current and former officials said.

Bennett, who represented President Bill Clinton in the Paula Jones sexual harassment lawsuit, and, more recently, Paul Wolfowitz, the former World Bank president, declined to discuss any of the details of Rodriguez' case today. But he said his client had been "a dedicated and loyal public servant for 31 years and I'm convinced that he has done nothing wrong."

Terror Watch appears weekly on Newsweek.com

© 2007