What Will Israel Do?

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: mdvlstn3 @ 12/28/2007 9:03:28 PM

    why does Isreal....think it can treat palistinians like the nazis treated them....
    and think things are going to work out in their favor....(as long as the Us bails them out, militarily and financially)....they should have to sleep in the bed they have made....on their own

  • Posted By: Lindie @ 12/28/2007 1:45:09 PM

    Israel needs to stay put.

  • Posted By: pfreedma @ 12/28/2007 9:07:39 AM

    The fervent comments posted previously really don't address the article, which is not about the United States but Israel and which fundamentally confirms that Israel faces an "existential threat" from an Iranian nuclear program--i.e., that Israel could cease to exist culturally, politically, and biologically. Even if posters are positing some linear relation between American and Israeli governments and the posts are not misplaced the thrust of the article is that Israeli officials fear that lack of action against Iran will encourage the extermination of Israel. That raises the bar for external pressure on Israel to defer action.

  • Posted By: Depletion @ 12/27/2007 9:05:04 PM

    What is said here, is very disturbing, a way of change of information gathering and only comes within from the inside is not reliable, once it was started a lot of things will happen, if the course is started its hard to stop and waste effort and money invlove, eager to have nuclear power, its very sad, very qquestionable, people never get old in terms of thinking , state of the mind, only the flesh is getting old. Once the character is always a character it can only pause for a while but it will never give up in itself, once there is a chance it will take it and it will only observe the reaction from others and it will move slowly and until it will reach the goal, after all fossil fuels are on the process of depletion. one way or another the earth may destroy it self its beacause the structure of earth is continue alter in my point of view, once you disturb the natural process, and it cannot return to its self, something wrong will happen. thank you

  • Posted By: eddiewhere @ 12/27/2007 2:52:27 AM

    You do not control the Government the Government controls you, and this has to change. We are not talking race we are talking constitution. The Government is cleverly taking over our civil liberties, slowly, intelligently. Keeping us dumb. Romney is playing the same card Bush did. There stupid so do not play smart.

  • Posted By: hots @ 12/25/2007 7:37:48 PM

    washington ought to step back and take a very serious look at the Iranian NUCLEAR POWER affear.. And be very sure before it makes any more public statments :Am pretty sure that the Israel's Would feel diffrent and not so bad that the U.S.A. did not ran out on them in the thick of the heath.

  • Posted By: nawawimohamad @ 12/25/2007 12:34:02 AM

    Why is everyone talking about war? Why not talk and discuss about peace? Don't we have enough wars? Why is the "greatest nation on earth" so fearful of Iran? What does Iran have? Why is Isreal so afraid of Iran when it has "the greatest nation on earth" by its sides? For that matter why is "the greatest nation on earth" so afraid of Osama, who is just one sick person(maybe dead) running the Al Qaeda with no sophisticated set up and no technological advance? Why is the "greatest nation on earth" so afraid of the improvised explosives? It doesn't make sense at all! As for Mr. Hirsh, he can write whatever he desires but the readers must be critical. It is better to read an article written by somebody stupid or reading a stupid article rather than be a stupid reader.

  • Posted By: vpitt @ 12/22/2007 12:04:59 AM

    It is good that the Arabs are terrified of Israel, it may slow down their terroristic activities. Israel has fanatic terrorists that surround it. They have shown great restraint in spite of the repeated terroristic threats and actual murders carried out by these barbaric fanatics. Iran has shown that it is a terroristic government led by an insane fanatic. Israel has shown that it is a nation dedicated to peace and prosperity. Take your choice, who would you rather have in control of nuclear devices.

    VPitt

    • Posted By: RedAaron @ 12/24/2007 8:52:25 AM

      Small-scale violence by Arabs and Muslims against Israel and its U.S. bankroller is nothing compared to the large-scale, high-tech terrorism by Israel and the U.S. against anybody who gets in the way of their imperialist ambitions. Over 2 million Iraqis have died as a result of 13 years of virtual blocade (a.k.a. "sanctions") sandwiched between two wars led by the U.S., all with the strong encouragement of the powerful Zionist Lobby. If you add in the roughly 20 million people who die unnecessarily each year as a result of economic policies imposed by the U.S. and its allies on the neo-colonized countries, nothing that the people labelled "terrorists" by the U.S.-Israel Axis have done is worthy of more than a footnote in the terrorism account books.

  • Posted By: mkf1 @ 12/23/2007 3:37:55 PM

    This tone of jounalism suggesting that any state, has the right to arbitrarily bomb another state is not acceptable in a civlized world of laws. Hirsch you know better. What is the reason you set civilized laws aside when in comes to Israel? I believe you are a closet Israeli, and your "journalism" takes second place to you being a law abiding person. This atttude is why Israel is damned by so many, you jumped in with them.

  • Posted By: Turdchaser12003 @ 12/23/2007 1:27:48 PM

    Bush is an Idiot and he is cowering to Iran because he is making too much money in the war with Iraq, he dose not want to dilute his effort by taking care of this obvious problem. Insted he will continue to wage war on a nation that has never harmed one American.

  • Posted By: Turdchaser12003 @ 12/23/2007 1:26:51 PM

    Bush is an Idiot and he is cowering to Iran because he is making too much money in the war with Iraq, he dose not want to dilute his effort by taking care of this obvious problem. Insted he will continue to wage war on a nation that has never harmed one American.

  • Posted By: John the postmaster @ 12/22/2007 3:08:47 PM

    The US doesn't want nuclear weapons in Iran because of the chance of those weapons getting into the hands of terrorists. We've managed to avoid war with the other nuclear countries to this point because these countries were believed to be under stable leadership. Our past with Iran doesn't give us hope of that in this case.

    As to the comment about "some crazy American" using nuclear weapons first because "we've done it before", are you seriously saying that Harry Truman was crazy and we didn't have a good reason to use our nuclear weapon first? No to mention that no one else had nukes at that time.

  • Posted By: RFFNY1 @ 12/21/2007 3:06:27 AM

    I havew a question for Yuval Steintz who said "something like this should have been presented to the Israelis through professional channels"...... Was the observation by one of your agents and the information about the car filled with explosives that subsequently killed a lot of Americans presented to Ameria through professional channels. I remember reading **** the Americans, let them be made at the Arabs. I guess Steintz suffers from convenient amnesia or selective memory syndrome. RFFNY1

    • Posted By: Braes @ 12/22/2007 2:42:09 PM

      And Israel gave American secrets to the USSR, spied on us repeatedly, etc. It has been a one sided relationship. The minute you call them on it, you are called a Nazi or worse. Israel wins the propaganda war.

  • Posted By: SAQIB @ 12/22/2007 12:32:08 PM

    The war aginst terror was a pretext to invade afghanistan OSAMA WAS discovered and he was made to play the role of the USSR as the union had collapsed and there was no enemy to fight with for maintaining the velocity of progress.Then came the weapons of mass destruction who became the cause of attack on Iraq.Now it would be the nukes which ould become a pretext to wage a war against Iran.The world and especially the muslims think that the policies of Israel and THE WEST the same.Who comes forward and becomes an invader would be premeditated.If so happens it will push the whole world into a war,as already analyzed by the writer about Russia and company.It would add oil to the fuel and would be scareful for whole the humanity.

  • Posted By: kemet @ 12/21/2007 8:08:36 PM

    Those who thinks that Arabs are terrified of Nuclear Iran not of a country who has at least 300 Atomic bombs at its disposal are Idiots. Iran does not kill arabs every day in the west bank and Gaza. Iran did not invade its neighbor Lebanon last year.. It is only the Arab goverments who are terrified of saying No To USA

    • Posted By: Planet@Vertigo @ 12/21/2007 11:34:51 PM

      If that???s right, why then countries like Egypt, Jordan, the Saudi???s have recently, expressed their plans to develop their own nuclear programs (for ???energy??? of course???) why now??
      Is it because of Israel (that has a program since the 60???s ) or Iran?? this point alone proves that Israel is not a true threat to middle east but Iran is!!

      • Posted By: pinkpanther87413 @ 12/21/2007 11:56:57 PM

        what point?/All you have done is name all the countries that the terrorist came from to wipe out the WTC?

        • Posted By: Planet@Vertigo1 @ 12/22/2007 1:38:43 AM

          No??? I have named the countries that have expressed a desire to build a nuke program, because of Iran??? they are Sunni and they have a say in the middle -east???

          They are afraid of Iran not Israel

          Do you really want a region like the middle -east, known for its instability having nukes? And it???s all because of Iran! Imagine Osama having nukes!( this is what will happen if Iran is not stopped) ??? this is all because of Iran NOT Israel ???

  • Posted By: pinkpanther87413 @ 12/21/2007 11:59:16 PM

    Regardless of who you are or what holiday you celibrate!! I do not mis spell holidays or names as its rude! so i'll just say happy holidays to all in your own way, be well.

  • Posted By: kemet @ 12/21/2007 8:02:30 PM

    Those who thinks the Arabs are more terrified of Nuclear Iran than a 200 Nuclear Bombs Israel are idiots. The Arabs Governments are underr great pressure from USA to think that way . But Every Arab in the Middle East Think that the problem is Israel not Iran. By the Way Iran did not invade any country. Iran do not kill arabs In the west Bank and Gaza every day . Iran did not Invade Lebanon last year.

  • Posted By: fillip mars @ 12/21/2007 2:10:59 PM

    Posted by fillip mars @ 12/21/2007 - The USA has 18 nuclear submarines in the seas around the world at
    least 8 of which are said to have more firepower than all the weapons that were used by all sides in World
    War II. You can bet that at least one of these is withing striking distance of Iran, and, probably, the whole
    middle east, and we're concerned about Iran's POSSIBLE developing ONE BOMB? Gimme a break! Let 'em
    have their firecracker. D'you think they'd risk being turned to glass by attacking, or preparing to attack anyone
    with one, or even, a few "nucular" (sic) weapons? During the 1973 Yom Kippur war against Israel, existing
    satellite technology detected Israel, in desparation, loading their aircraft with the 13 atomic bombs they then
    had, because they were about to be overrun, according to a report by "Friends of Israel," A U.S. group. The
    result was a panic of diplomatic moves which included Henry Kissinger, the Russians (who were loading
    troops aboard planes in response), and others. Fortunately, the Israelis stopped the Arab advance by less
    drastic means. With the much more advanced technology we have today, nobody could prepare to launch
    a nuclear attack, except, perhaps, by shipping such a weapon under deep cover, and even that would likely
    be detected because it would require the activity by so many people that it would attract attention.
    We need to stop doing so much sabre-rattling toward other nations and treating them like inferiors, even
    if they act that way, sometimes. Iran was the only middle east nation that actually had demonstrations in
    sympathy with us after the WTC /pentagon attacks. At the same time the Iranian government offered to have
    talks with ours in an attempt to resolve our differences, which our government, in its wisdom declined, and
    so, here we are. Ain't it beautiful! Let's conduct our foreign affairs with courage instead of fear(mongering)!

    • Posted By: Westcoast @ 12/21/2007 6:13:10 PM

      The #1 reason why Israel, the U.S., and most of the nation in the Middle East don't want a nuclear armed Iran is because they are the primary supporters of Hezbollah in Lebanon, and the hamas party in palestine (which are the primary group that launches attacks against Israel from the gaza strip). Think about that, if Iran produces nuclear weapons and they currently support these terrorists groups with money, training and most significantly weapons, then what would stop from arming them with a dirty bomb or a compact atomic bomb that can destroy most of Israel and thereby fulfilling Irans' Ahamadinejad's goal of wiping Israel off the map. And then guess who would be next in Irans crosshairs, the U.S. Also on those proposed talks that the Iranian gov't offered were bologna. In March of 2000, former secretary of state Madeline Albright took part in talks with the Ayatollah Khamenei of Iran and despite a willingness of mutual agreement at first on many issues by Albright and the Ayatollah, the Ayatollah later dismissed the agreement as an apology by Satan.

  • Posted By: tonyforademocraticworld @ 12/21/2007 2:31:07 PM

    Israel strikes Iran, Iran retaliatesagainst Israel, forcing george bush to strike at Iran. Now george bush has is war with Iran, claiming national security and stays in Washington as a dictator.

    • Posted By: Westcoast @ 12/21/2007 5:51:34 PM

      You're more dramatic than a soap-opera tony. If Israel attacks Iran, Iran won't attack Israel in retaliation at first. Iran will attack U.S. armed force bases in Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and other U.S. bases in the region. Then the U.S. will have no choice but to launch strikes against Iran and for legitamate reasons. If this does happen, count on a republican candidate being ELECTED into the white house.

    • Posted By: Westcoast @ 12/21/2007 5:45:07 PM

      What a dramatic person you are tony. If Israel attacks Iran, Iran won't attack Israel in retaliation at first, Iran will attack U.S. armed force bases in Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and any other base the U.S. has in the region. Then that will leave the U.S. no choice but to attack Iran, and for legitamate reasons.

  • Posted By: theinformationist @ 12/21/2007 5:00:05 PM

    the US. problem with Iran is not nuclear its all about Iraq and the fax that based on whats happening on the ground is that the Iranian are not try to make things harder for the Americans.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse