Top Seven Health Myths

« Return to Article

Discuss

Member Comments

  • Posted By: puppylove @ 12/28/2007 11:48:58 AM

    Wow! FIrstly I would like to point out that most myths have at least a modicum of fact as basis, and have just grown into whoppers along the way. As for the water issue, our bodies do need to stay hydrated, and water is the obvious choice. Yes, we receive liquid nourishment from other sources, and yes, 8 glasses is excessive and vague at the same time. But - bottom line, we need water to stay healthy. It is a healthier way to get the liquid nourisment we need. Period.
    On the Halloween candy myth - it is not unheard of that someone might put a sharp object in a child's candy. When you look at the horrible people that do horrible things to children every day, it is not inconceivable. Do I personally know of a child that has had a sharp object in their Halloween candy? NO. Did I check my kids, neices and nephew every year? Yes. I also monitor whose house they go in, etc. Being aware is a good thing.
    We all know about cell phone interference and most have experienced it in some manner. It isn't a stretch to think that they might interfer with the odd piece of equipment. While it might not happen everyday, it is bettter to err on the side of caution than to be responsible for someone's ventilator randomly shutting off!!
    People are always debunking urban myths, and for every debunking there is someone else who can prove it fact. Is there a boogie man? We say no, but tell that to the little girl who saw him crawl in her bed every night for two years. Point is, these myths are based on someone's knowledge, experience, etc. To say that straining your eyesight will make you go blind may be an exaggeration, but straining your eyes is bad for your eyes and will produce headaches, and in the long run, poorer vision. I agree with several posters regarding the author and Newsweek for printing an article that -while true as written - causes more misconceptions than it clears up. Perhaps this "fluff" piece should have been advertised as such, and not in such a reputable news magazine. And - for those that think that something beind debunked or disproved in SNOPES makes it fact. Try belching (or Passing gas) in front of a lit lighter and see what happens. Silly girl at work did it last week because "IT IS JUST A MYTH" and ended up with no eyebrows ( and a verbal reprimand from supervisor for playing with lighter at work).

  • Posted By: lnj36 @ 12/28/2007 11:39:22 AM

    Thank God this list is out there for all to see, I'm so sick of people arguing with me about things that seem so ridiculous, but they believe it because their elders swear by it, come on people lets start having some common sense. Look, I love my granny too but when she says things like, "you can't go in the pool for a half hour, cause you just ate, I'm like Grandma Please! SLASH!!! Laura Las Vegas, NV

    • Posted By: HowAbout... @ 12/28/2007 11:48:33 AM

      Not a total myth, Dear. Do some research and thank you Granny.

  • Posted By: Skulldugger7 @ 12/28/2007 10:09:33 AM

    Boy, aren't doctors idiots for believing these myths? It just goes to show you that you can waste ten years of your life in school and still not know a thing. What a waste of your life! Morons.

    • Posted By: DogLoverInVirginia @ 12/28/2007 11:21:40 AM

      I think Skulldugger7 is being sarcastic, and jorge did not understand. Doctors are human, and I have had disappointments in my Kaiser doctors in not diagnosing quickly, e.g., taking two years to diagnose broken cartildge in my sinus area, longer to diagnose gall bladder stones, but their training lead to good treatment eventually. To me, the bottom line is that if you own a body, you need to learn about your body, and not leave it totally up to doctors, who try to do their best but are only human.

      • Posted By: Skulldugger7 @ 12/28/2007 11:48:12 AM

        That's MR Skulldugger7 to you, DogLover . . .

    • Posted By: DogLoverInVirginia @ 12/28/2007 11:14:45 AM

      I think Skulldugger is being sarcastic.

    • Posted By: jorge_mt @ 12/28/2007 10:20:09 AM

      No, they are human. Opinions like yours make me wonder about your capacity to absorb knowledge

  • Posted By: BPlummer @ 12/28/2007 11:45:22 AM

    I have lived in Las Vegas since my childhood. I also remember the Halloween tainted candy as really happening here also. It goes to show that even this article has myths. Thats why I never became a writer because I would of never gotten a single article written for fear of not writing the truth.

  • Posted By: snarkle01 @ 12/28/2007 11:37:33 AM

    My aunt had cancer and lost all of her hair after chemotheraphy . When her hair started growing back it was a different texture. It was soft, silky and smooth, unlike before.
    Can you explain this?

    • Posted By: Brody @ 12/28/2007 11:44:42 AM

      snarkle,

      I know someone who had chemotherapy and lost his gray hair, which grew back as brown.

  • Posted By: suem @ 12/28/2007 11:44:34 AM

    I can remember trick-or-treating BEFORE it was dangerous, we had to stop when some einsteins started inserting razor blades, needles and glass shards into apples. And yes, there were photos and documented news reports.

  • Posted By: tifstr2 @ 12/28/2007 9:55:30 AM

    People need to lighten up! Lately several news outlets have had articles about the same medical myths. Do all of you with scathing remarks seek out every article and rip the author. This article was meant to make you think before simply believing something you're told. I for one have been reading by dim light for years and as I approach 40, I still don't need glasses. My children have never needed to have their candy x-rayed, nor did I as a child. I get by on the fluids I drinks, be that 1, 2, or 8 glasses depending on the day ad how busy I am. And most of the Doctor's offices and Hospitals I go into now are lifting their bans on cell phones. So, calm down and use your brain that you just found out you are fully using!!

    • Posted By: mmp55555 @ 12/28/2007 11:44:30 AM

      What hospitals are lifting their bands on cell phones? I would like to report them to joint commission so they can be shut down. Even if they are willing to put 1.2% of patients it is still a HIPPA/privacy violation...not to mention rude.

    • Posted By: Habsolute @ 12/28/2007 10:27:07 AM

      "...calm down and use your brain that you just found out you are fully using..."

      Now THAT'S humor!!! HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!!!!

  • Posted By: DesertRat123 @ 12/28/2007 11:43:32 AM

    I'm sorry, but this article is ridiculous...as a physician, I know of no credible doctors who believe these statement...maybe you should do a survey of actual physicians before making much a dumb blanket statement.

  • Posted By: BPlummer @ 12/28/2007 11:41:55 AM

    I have lived in Las Vegas since my childhood. I also remember the Halloween tainted candy as really happening here also. It goes to show that even this article has myths. Thats why I never became a writer because I would of never gotten a single article written for fear of not writing the truth.

  • Posted By: ckincaid @ 12/28/2007 11:39:10 AM

    Some of this is not true, I don't care what they say. I've researched the water intoxication theory through several medical reports, and it would take an astronomical amount of water to cause such a condition. Furthermore, you really do need to drink at least 8 glasses of water per day. Think about it...the water you get in other forms is not pure water. Your body needs the pure water in order to keep it flushed and free of contaminants. Every doctor, fitness trainer and medical person I have ever talked to or read comments from has pointed out that pure water is the only way to keep the body flushed of harmful elements. To suggest that getting water from caffeinated drinks, such as coffee, is as good for us as pure water is absurd.

  • Posted By: h3nurse @ 12/28/2007 10:08:25 AM

    Regarding the myth of the cell phones in hospitals. In started in the old days when cell phones were big enough to be carried in satchels and our equipment was less protected. The EMP was fairly significant and would cause problems. Today in our ICU we only have one piece of equipment, a specialized ventilator that CAN (and has) been shut down by cell phone use. Other hospitals in outlying areas may still use this outdated equipment. Generally, we have kept this myth alive for another purpose. As cell phones have increasingly become equipped with cameras, the risk of HIPPA/privacy violations has skyrocketed. Cell phone use is prohibited more for that reason than any other. If we have to withhold that privilege from one person, then we have to block all. That and holding a conversation over the bed of a critically ill individual is crass. Go home and talk to your friends.

    • Posted By: mmp55555 @ 12/28/2007 11:38:56 AM

      First of all a PBT 840 isn't a "specialized ventilator"...what are you, a nursing home nurse? I use the PBT 840 on all types and ages of patients. The one reason why you see it in most hospitals today is due to its versitility. Heck, I have even used it on 23 week gestation babies. Second don't forget about telemetry monitoring. Two days ago I was on the telemetry floor and a cell phone kept making the patient look like they where in V-fib and we have the most updated system for cardiac monitoring.

  • Posted By: Been there @ 12/28/2007 11:36:46 AM

    They started inspecting Holloween candy because broken glass and razor blades were supposedly found in fruit handed out several years ago. They then started offering x-ray at hospitals just to be safe. So people trying to keep their children safe would throw out everything but wrapped candy no more pop corn balls and fun things like that because it may not be safe.

  • Posted By: Janellee @ 12/28/2007 11:35:35 AM

    Many items listed in the "myths" are not "myths" but are true... It's nonsense to think in the entire USA no one has ever poisoned by a stranger on Halloween. Also, all Doctors recommend 8 glasses of water a day bcause we should be drinking water and NOT soda, juice, etc. Yes, some people get the fluids other ways, but that is not the way it should be. Doctor's are not saying take 8 glasses of water and 3 bottles of soda and 2 beers/wine every day. Of course, that would be too much fluid.

  • Posted By: Brody @ 12/28/2007 11:35:17 AM

    It's interesting that there have been comments about every item except the one about how the hair grows back. Oops, now there has been one.

  • Posted By: lyssalanai @ 12/28/2007 11:34:13 AM

    I wish some notice would be given to the idea that babies can catch strep throat: another medical myth strongly believed by doctors: my first daughter caught strep throat at only 7 months, and they only tested her because I pushed. They simply didn't believe anything was wrong with her, and were astonished when the test came back positive. With my second daughter, she was four months when she caught strep throat, from my older daughter, who once again had it at 23 months. Again, I had to push to get her tested, and again, they were absolutely astonished to see a positive result on a test they thought was a waste of time.

    A thoguth on the water myth: overconsumption of water needs to be addressed, particularly within military channels. When I was in boot camp in the Navy, we had no less than three instances of people sent to medcal, only to find out they had consumed so much water they were sick. The military pushes hard on water, says you can never consume too much, and will even force you to down two or three full canteens (about 16oz a piece) in one sitting. We were expected to drink 8 to 12 canteens of water a day, or more on the "rigorous" days. For those who say it's necessary because boot camp is an "intensely physical environment" think again: in days past it was, now they run three or four times a week, and go to classes and training the rest. Does that really warrant that type of water consumption?

  • Posted By: h3nurse @ 12/28/2007 10:40:26 AM

    The Halloween candy is mostly urban legend. As a trauma nurse I have researced this topic. Until Nov 1st of this year I had never seen documented caes of razors or poisoning of Halleween candy, (with the exception of relatives in nasty divorce cases and aone or two insurance as noted by jscohn2002. ) The one and only case that I have seen, (and may have been an attention stunt by a 15 yo.) occurred in Mineola Fla. twoo onths ago. With all the media attention, it was bound to be copy-catted eventually. The boy was David Mahon. Still a frightening possibility, but lss robably than being hit by lightening. And no one has ever been injured. Skulldugger7 states he was given a popcorn ball with Alum. Anybody who has eaten alum knows it is a VERY sour taste. It is non toxic, and is used in pickling frequently. Are you telling me you didn't notice? We did have a case in Texas here of three boys placing marijuana laced brownies in a teachers lounge as a prank. They were arrested and charged. Any other cases I would love a link to a REPUTABLE sourse. I've never found any others.

    Timothy O'Bryan of Houston, Texas actually did die in 1974 after eating a Pixie Stick laced with cyanide on Halloween night. Which is true, but the kicker is that investigators determined that the candy was poisoned by O'Bryan's own father, who, unbelievable as it seems, hoped to collect on a life insurance policy he had taken out on his son.

    The

    • Posted By: ittakesbrains @ 12/28/2007 11:33:49 AM

      I agree the idea is very unlikely, but one incident in the late seventies was well documented. It did start out that a family member was to blame. The father wanted to collect on a life insurance policy and poisoned his son's halloween candy, problem was he poisoned the other candy and gave it out so he could claim tainted candy. No other children were killed but reports have several ill. This mad was executed in 1984-5. But hey, what a way for terrorists to start!!! I suggest that parents still use caution and check their children's candy...I mean what can it hurt? google the "Pixie-stick killer" to read about Ronald O'brians horrific crime!

    • Posted By: Skulldugger7 @ 12/28/2007 11:04:50 AM

      The popcorn was heavily salted with cheddar cheese flavoring. To this day, I can't eat cheddar cheese.
      X p

  • Posted By: antonio440 @ 12/28/2007 11:31:37 AM

    well I will say that, when my uncle was exhumed, because a mistake at the cemetery, my relatives could not resist to open the casket, his hair was long and his fingernails too.
    now i remember when he was buried , his hair was clean cut and nice

    myth or no myth I saw it....

  • Posted By: TammyP @ 12/28/2007 11:25:05 AM

    I have a newspaper article with a picture of my policeman father from the Goshen News (Indiana) back in the 70's, holding an apple with razor blades stuck inside. It's been going on for a long time.

  • Posted By: scashman@carrierservice.com @ 12/28/2007 11:24:59 AM

    What I would like to know is what is a nutritionalist.

  • Posted By: docpearce @ 12/28/2007 10:35:32 AM

    Water intoxication. Are you serious? Do you have any idea how much water you'd have to consume to reach water intoxication? And although you do not need 8 glasses of water per day to stay hydrated (unless you workout intensely, which most of you do not. Who needs to? There's always a pill or a surgery to fix what you neglect), the water does help to flush the body of toxins, which would come in handy if soda and coffee are your sources of hydration. Now you wouldn't want to tell people to drink 8 glasses of water over 8 cans of pop would you. It's better that they are lethargic, obese, and most likely diabetic (oh diabetes runs in my family. It's not the 200 pounds of sugar I consume per year). If you need help writing an article that might actually be helpful, let me know. Dr. Pearce

    • Posted By: msnsucks @ 12/28/2007 11:24:31 AM

      Doc Pearce: I wanted to send my thanks and support in regards to the statement made about people with diabetes and their denial as to where the diabetes really came from. I loved the 200 pounds of sugar comment, your sarcasm was spot on. Keep it up.

Reply

Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse