While it is awful that your work was plagiarized I find it insulting that you belittle and generalize about the romance books and call them "trashy" and "bodice rippers". One author and one author's book hardly represents the entire industry.
While it is awful that your work was plagiarized I find it insulting that you belittle and generalize about the romance books and call them "trashy" and "bodice rippers". One author and one author's book hardly represents the entire industry.
This is my first visit to Newsweek online, and I can only guess that this admittedly intriguing article was distributed over six pages to discourage rural readers with dial-up connections from reading the magazine.
This is my first read of a Newsweek posting, and I can only guess that distributing this admittedly intriguing article across six separate pages is a ploy to discourage rural readers with dial-up from reading the magazine.
Why am I not suprised, in a world that thinks Wikipedia is a credible source (read their home page if you have any doubt). The biggest part of this, lightly touched on by the author, is that the practice of 'cut and paste' without credit is rampant in HS and College, and it is an excepted practice!
It's only wrong if you get caught...
As a writer of "trashy" romance novels I would love to make this up to you. You could appear on one of my covers. You are smoking HOTT!! Just saying.
Wow. That was a very classy, articulate, and entertaining response to a terrible situation. Kudos to Mr. Tolme for rising to the occasion with such grace.
I am a ferret enthusiast, learning about the black footed ferret as a sort of peripheral bonus when I became an owner of domesticated ferrets. These poor guys are struggling. It would be lovely if, perhaps as a fair settlement in response to this abuse, Edwards and her publishers donated proceeds from her book to the ferrets.
On a side note-- I am a writer by trade and recently began writing romance. I swear, Mr. Tolme, not all of us are that pathetic, and there are some out there you may actually enjoy. But I've always found Edwards' work nauseating and you get SUCH A HUGE HIGH FIVE for hunkering down to read it.
Many kudos and a big crate of Malox to you, sir!
Nora Roberts, a victim of plagarism herself, has set up a fund to raise money for the ferrets. See the web-blog mentioned in this article for more information and how to donate:
http://www.smartbitchestrashybooks.com/index.php/weblog/nora_roberts_matching_donation_program_for_defenders_of_wildlife/
Wow. That was a very classy, articulate, and entertaining response to a terrible situation. Kudos to Mr. Tolme for rising to the occasion with such grace.
I am a ferret enthusiast, learning about the black footed ferret as a sort of peripheral bonus when I became an owner of domesticated ferrets. These poor guys are struggling. It would be lovely if, perhaps as a fair settlement in response to this abuse, Edwards and her publishers donated proceeds from her book to the ferrets.
On a side note-- I am a writer by trade and recently began writing romance. I swear, Mr. Tolme, not all of us are that pathetic, and there are some out there you may actually enjoy. But I've always found Edwards' work nauseating and you get SUCH A HUGE HIGH FIVE for hunkering down to read it.
Many kudos and a big crate of Malox to you, sir!
Nora Roberts, the victim of plagarism herself, has set up a fund to raise money for the ferrets. For more information , see the webblog mentioned in the article:
http://www.smartbitchestrashybooks.com/index.php/weblog/nora_roberts_matching_donation_program_for_defenders_of_wildlife/
Hmmm, did I miss the ferret's bombing Israel or anywhere else or talking about Arab oil? This was a great and hysterical read on plagerism.
Hmm, I didn't see anywhere in the text about ferrrets bombing anything. Perhaps I missed that part. Anyhow, it was a hysterical read on plagerism, especially the comment..."Wow, that was hot!:
um, I thought this was about the ferrets.
umm,wasn't this about ferrets?
I'd like "esbee" to know that although I am sorry he/she has been the victim of piracy, to say 'the Chinese steal art' is the same as saying, 'the Americans are hypocrites'. Don't make sweeping statements. Discipline your language - refrain from tarring an entire ethnic group with your antagonistic brush.
the Chinese steal art from hard working American artists and copy it brush stroke for brush stroke or through the miracle of the internet and printing, just cut and paste it straight into their item to sell on ebay and other places...mine was lifted and is selling on many items...and other than stop that auction i cannot spend all my time looking for that image
there are no teeth in the laws, besides I got bigger things to worry about like the USDA program tht wants me to tell them everywhere i take my horse...see nonais.org for more info on that travesty....
I initally "pelt" sorry for Mr. Tolme until I realized that Shadow Bear spoke of the ferrets in 1850. Who plagiarized whom, Mr. Tolme?
Um...duh. Didn't you read Mr. Tolme's article? Edwards set her stupid story in 1850, and took Mr. Tolme's words and ideas and used them, practically verbatim, in her own work. If you are intimating that Mr. Tolme is in the wrong here, you need to reread his article. I don't think you got it the first time.
Lol...the guy was obviously kidding around...come on, his name is "tongue in cheek"...
Uh, did you not get that was a joke that "Tonguencheek" wrote? He jokes that Shadow Bear "said" all that in 1850?! (Sad when you have to explain a joke). Anyhow, as a former Publisher, I can tell you that it is legal to borrow and reprint up to 300 words from a work without obtaining the original authors' permission, HOWEVER, you still have to cite the original source!! Shame on Ms. Edwards' publishers as well!
Oops. Sorry for the double post.
found out a while ago that Ms. Edwards was in the hotbed for some of her novels when there was an article on how Nora Roberts basically says, "stealing someone else's work is a big fat NO NO." Yet to see it even clearer in this instance really makes me wonder about the rest of her novels as well. She's a prolific and YES best selling romance writer. She's been writing for YEARS. Although I have never read her- and now I most certainly will not. I like cheesy romances, I like fantasy, I like good thrillers. I will read anything that looks good. The link for the Nora Roberts statement and story was through MSN in their Entertainment, Books and Arts sections, but I don't recall it offhand, so I can't accredit it like a NORMAL, EDUCATED, MORAL person should.
As a student, I learned you give credit where credit is due in all your papers. How could she not know that? How could she consider herself a writer and not have learned that? Any style manual like the Little, Brown Handbook or the MLA Style Manual will say the same thing and tell you how it should properly be done. She must not have taken any ENGLISH COMPOSITION classes in JUNIOR HIGH OR HIGH SCHOOL OR COLLEGE FOR THE MATTER AT ALL. So she can say, "Oh I didn't know." But that is one lousy excuse to say.
In this age of instant information through search engines off all kinds, plagiarism is sure to abound. That's why teachers have the technology to look for such things in students' papers. Maybe editors and publishers should have that as well.
Just my thoughts.
An incredible story!!
If your anger has abated, you've hit upon something--using the medium of romance novels to advocate for environmental issues! Edwards' publisher should re-issue the paperback with an epilogue informing the reader, IN YOUR WRITING, of the challenge faced by ferret in competition with cattle.
Wow...its pretty darn bad when you have to plagarize to write a trashy romance novel. Makes the rest of us who work for a living suffer heaving bosoms of jeaousy.
So Very glad you could ferret out the truth. Cassie has been writing for a long, long time and I am sure knows better. She just happened to get caught with her big girl panties down. Your sense of humor aside - she messed up big time. Beware - there are a gazillion women and men reading those trashy romance
novels. The hate mail will pour in. Cassie needs to say sorry and donate money to a ferret rescue group or you. Have to go now........my boobs are heaving, I am gasping for breath, mindless, wanton and just your plain ole hussy.......
maybe you can take the plagerist to court for royalties and then use the that money for some sort of Ferrat aid. Heck you may not need to even involve the court, she may want to do it simply not to lose anymore face.
Enter comments if any for reporting abuse
Discuss