Quora Question: Would a Zika Virus Be Free?

06_17_ZikaOlympics_02
A physiotherapist exercises a 5-month-old with microcephaly at a hospital in Santos, Brazil on April 20. Nacho Doce/Reuters

Quora Questions are part of a partnership between Newsweek and Quora, through which we'll be posting relevant and interesting answers from Quora contributors throughout the week. Read more about the partnership here.

Answer from Tirumalai Kamala, immunologist, Ph.D. mycobacteriology:

Primarily because it's intended target is the healthy population, the economics of vaccines are unlike those for other medicines.

  • Most governments already factor in this difference and have specific policy guidelines and even laws to help fund mass immunization campaigns.
  • An international two-tier pricing structure ensures that vaccine costs in poorer countries are far lower than those in their wealthier counterparts.
  • Vaccine cost also is fundamentally different between countries with a publicly funded national health care system, e.g., Canada (lower), versus countries that don't, e.g., USA (higher).
  • The difference between childhood and adult vaccination programs is another element that influences vaccine cost. While the former are the intense focus of governments and therefore have robust public-private partnerships to defray costs, adult vaccinations can be fee for service, i.e., a health care provider purchasing vaccines upfront and then getting reimbursed after administering them.

Whether a future Zika vaccine will be available for free thus depends on whether Zika presents an epidemic or pandemic threat (circumstance #1) or not (circumstance #2), if and when such a vaccine becomes available.

Circumstance #1. When a vaccine becomes finally available, if Zika presented an epidemic or pandemic threat, affected governments would likely support mass immunizations campaigns, meaning vaccine cost would be heavily subsidized or even free. Though the particulars of how vaccines are funded differ in different countries, by and large most governments heavily subsidize costs of vaccination. For e.g., in the U.S., vaccine costs were brought under a common umbrella through the 1962 Vaccination Assistance Act (Section 317 of the Public Health Service Act). Section 317 has been continuously reauthorized since 1962. Thus, it's now a mainstay of immunization support in the U.S.

The U.S. Vaccine Assistance Act ended up doing several things:

  • Two, it provided financial assistance "in lieu of cash" to state and local health departments to in turn support mass immunization programs. Specifically Section 317 allows the US federal government to provide vaccines and personnel such as CDC Public Health Advisors and epidemiologists to assist local and state health departments in managing these programs.
  • Three, through Section 317, the US federal government is able to negotiate down vaccine prices with manufacturers. Factors relevant to cost reduction include sales volume, limited distribution points, no-return policy, to name a few.
  • Four, in addition, the US 1993 Vaccines for Children (VFC) Act ensures free vaccines to uninsured children, those on Medicaid or American Indian or Alaska natives (7).

Thus, in the US, most recommended vaccines are covered by either private health insurance plans or government subsidies.

Circumstance #2. If, on the other hand, Zika threat in a particular country is so low that it would not be cost-effective for its government to subsidize it, then an individual may have to pay for it out of pocket, similar to the way they do now for travel-related vaccines, i.e., not covered by health insurance. Intended to protect against a mosquito-borne viral disease like Zika, the Yellow fever vaccine is a helpful guide for the cost of a travel-related vaccine in the US (see figure below from 8).

If a vaccine for Zika is developed, will it be freely available to everybody? originally appeared on Quora—the knowledge-sharing network where compelling questions are answered by people with unique insights. You can follow Quora on Twitter, Facebook, and Google+. More questions: