
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
I tried to imagine what it would be like to be processing into St. Peter's Basilica in Cardinal Bernard Law's shoes yesterday. And concluded that Law's friends here in Rome really should have joined the protesters in urging him to stay at home.
How uncomfortable he looked, staring up and then down rather than into the crowd, much aged in these last few years and shockingly bloated. Not even his flowing crimson robes were forgiving. He moved down the aisle so slowly--in acute back pain, a friend said. And unlike any other cardinal at any other mass, he was surrounded by security guards.
Law, of course, is the former archbishop of Boston, the epicenter of the 2002 clerical sex-abuse crisis in the United States. He resigned under pressure in December of that year after court records revealed that he had knowingly shuffled predatory priests from one parish to another, postponing the scandal but compounding the toll.
Read More on News
The archdiocese, which has paid out some $85 million in settlements to victims, has Law off its payroll now. He lives in Rome, mostly out of the spotlight as archpriest of Santa Maria Maggiore, one of the four basilicas under the Vatican's direct supervision.
After Pope John Paul II's death, however, Law was the only American invited to say one of the nine memorial masses held at St. Peter's after a pontiff has died. Vatican officials brushed aside American sex-abuse victims offended that Law had been given such a prominent role. This was a completely pro forma invitation traditionally extended to the archpriest of Law's Roman church, they explained, and was certainly nothing personal.
In fact, as The Washington Post reported today, Law's predecessor at Santa Maria Maggiore was not similarly included in the mourning rites after Pope John Paul I died in 1978. But Law's celebration of the mass at St. Peter's yesterday was also not the salve that his defenders had perhaps intended.
First, Italian police felt the need to protect Law from two peaceful American protesters by escorting them off St. Peter's Square in a downpour before they even had a chance to start handing out fliers. One was Barbara Blaine, the founder of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, who had flown here from Chicago to make a point. She called Law "the poster child of complicit bishops.''
Inside the basilica, the ornate surroundings did not exactly work to Law's advantage, either. High above the center aisle, a sculpture I'd never noticed before shows St. John Bosco-protector of children and young people-whispering a warning to two urchins hiding behind his skirts, and pointing accusingly towards the altar where Law said mass yesterday.
But his appearance was inarguably a distraction from the whole point of the mourning mass. "Our faith has been reinforced,'' by John Paul, Law said in his homily. Not, alas, by him, however. And the whole spectacle of the disgraced cardinal slinging incense here and now was almost too baroque to bear.
The message of the week in Vatican City, as cardinals prepare to choose the next pope, is that they are silently, prayerfully contemplating the challenges facing the church, especially the importance of re-evangelizing Europe and of promoting global healing.
Yet Law's appearance at St. Peter's yesterday undercut all that. (The Bush White House message team, I kept thinking, would at a minimum have removed St. John Bosco "for cleaning.'')
Even at the Vatican-which is a sprawling bureaucracy , after all, rather than some monolith--there was some feeling that Law should have known better than to accept the invitation. Only one of his fellow cardinals from the United States, Justin Rigali of Philadelphia, attended the mass, and there were rows of empty chairs at the front as well as the back of the basilica.
Whatever the intention of the decision to shine the spotlight on Law, it showed no compassion for the abuse victims, no understanding of the challenges facing the church and in the end, no particular kindness to Law himself.
And when he joins his fellow cardinal electors in the seclusion of Domus Sanctae Marthae, the Vatican hotel residence where they will be sequestered while choosing a new pope next week, it may be something of a relief for all concerned.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines