10
Loading video...

By Amanda Castro
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The number of deceased claims filed with the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund has surpassed 10,000, marking a grim new milestone more than 25 years after the terrorist attacks.
The increase underlines an enduring health toll as cancers and other illnesses continue to affect responders, workers, residents and others exposed in the aftermath of the World Trade Center attack.
Survivors and relatives of those who have died told Newsweek that misconceptions about who was exposed and who qualifies for federal assistance can delay monitoring and treatment, while some families face lengthy administrative hurdles when seeking compensation.
Read More on News
The VCF recorded 10,029 deceased claims through October, compared with 610 at the end of 2015, according to its latest monthly figures. The total is more than three times the 2,977 people killed in the September 11, 2001, attacks.
A deceased claim is not synonymous with a federally confirmed death caused by 9/11 exposure. The VCF evaluates claims from personal representatives or eligible relatives of deceased victims, and eligibility and compensation depend on factors including presence in the exposure zone and a qualifying physical condition. The 10,029 figure therefore represents claims filed with the fund rather than a new official 9/11 death toll.
Cancer nevertheless accounts for most approved VCF death awards. Data cited by attorney Michael Barasch, managing partner of Barasch & McGarry and a two-time cancer survivor, showed that 5,997 of 6,397 approved death awards involved cancer, or nearly 94 percent.
"Twenty-five years after the September 11 terrorist attacks, we are still counting those we lost," Barasch told Newsweek. "9/11 did not end on 9/11."

...
9/11 Cancer Cases Continue to Rise
The World Trade Center Health Program, which monitors and treats eligible responders and survivors, recognizes dozens of cancers among its covered conditions. Program data supplied to Newsweek showed 59,279 cancer certifications as of September 30, up from 3,204 recorded in December 2014.
The figures do not mean every cancer was individually proven to have been caused by exposure on or after September 11. Certification means a member's condition met the federal program's requirements for a covered WTC-related health condition.
Barasch said the passage of time does not diminish the potential consequences of exposure, particularly because cancers can emerge years after contact with carcinogens. He pointed to the range of substances present in dust and debris after the towers collapsed and argued that continued medical monitoring is essential as the exposed population ages.
Federal policy did not immediately reflect the long-term risk. Cancer was added to the list of conditions covered by the World Trade Center Health Program in 2012, more than a decade after the attacks. The program now monitors both responders and "survivors," a category that includes eligible people who lived, worked or attended school in the New York City disaster area.
9/11 Survivor Says Early Cancer Detection Saved Her Life
Christine Sakoutis, 63, was a Manhattan Family Court clerk and New York state peace officer on September 11, 2001. She told Newsweek that she was driving across the Brooklyn Bridge when the first tower was struck and continued to the courthouse at 60 Lafayette Street.
After the courthouse was evacuated, people made their own decisions about where to go. Sakoutis headed toward the World Trade Center.
"I went to Ground Zero because I was a New York State Officer (Senior Court Clerk - Peace Officer) who took an oath to protect and serve," she said. "I was wearing a summer dress and white pumps, but I went anyway."
She eventually took up a position near Broadway and Fulton Street, about a block from the North Tower, and was there when it collapsed.
Nearly 16 years later, in April 2017, Sakoutis developed a severe cough while working at Richmond County Civil Court on Staten Island. At a doctor's office, her blood oxygen level registered in the 80s and she was taken by ambulance to an emergency room, where an X-ray revealed a suspicious spot on her lung.
The cancer was ultimately diagnosed as stage 2B. Sakoutis underwent surgery to remove half of her left lung, followed by chemotherapy with Taxotere and cisplatin.
Sakoutis said her doctors considered her 9/11 exposure a highly likely cause. She believes catching the disease when doctors did was decisive.
"It was everything," Sakoutis told Newsweek of early detection. She said she initially faced roughly even odds of survival, but her prognosis improved with treatment and each cancer-free year. She now describes herself as cured and free of disease.
For others who believe they were exposed but remain healthy, her message is forceful: take monitoring seriously.
"The ONLY way to increase your odds—the ONLY action you can take proactively—is to get scanned, scanned, scanned," Sakoutis said.

...
Who Qualifies for 9/11 Health Care and Compensation?
Doug Mandelkow knows the consequences of incorrectly assuming that 9/11 programs are only for people who worked directly on the pile.
His father, James Mandelkow, spent 30 years with the FDNY as a fire inspector. After the towers fell, his son said, he worked at a telephone bank in Lower Manhattan, contacting families of FDNY members during the recovery operation.
"He did not spend his days digging on the pile, so he never viewed himself as one of the heroes climbing through the rubble," Mandelkow told Newsweek. "He believed he was simply doing his duty for the department and for families desperately waiting for answers."
James Mandelkow was diagnosed with esophageal cancer in 2013 and died six months later at 54. His son said his father initially did not connect his illness to his post-9/11 work because he had not been on the debris pile.
That belief also affected his willingness to pursue federal assistance, according to Mandelkow.
"He dismissed his eligibility and felt guilty for asking for help, somehow believing that he was taking away from someone else," he said.
Eligibility for the federal programs is broader than for responders who worked at the World Trade Center pile, although it is subject to specific geographic, timing and medical criteria. The World Trade Center Health Program covers qualifying responders and survivors, while VCF compensation generally requires an eligible physical condition and proof that the individual was present in the New York City Exposure Zone or another covered site during the required period.
The VCF's permanent authorization means claims may continue to be filed through October 1, 2090. People who believe they were exposed can separately determine whether they qualify for monitoring through the World Trade Center Health Program even if they have not been diagnosed with a covered illness.
Mandelkow said he wishes his father had understood the scope of those programs earlier.
"Do not disqualify yourself because you believe someone else had it worse," he said.

...
Rare Cancers Draw New Attention in 9/11 Community
Alongside the overall growth in cancer certifications, advocates are drawing attention to less common cancers appearing among World Trade Center Health Program members.
Program figures supplied to Newsweek include 611 neuroendocrine cancer certifications among 147,137 members as of September 30. Neuroendocrine tumors arise in specialized cells that share characteristics of nerve and hormone-producing cells and can occur in different organs, including the lungs, pancreas and gastrointestinal system.
Those raw certification figures should not, on their own, be interpreted as proof that 9/11 exposure increases the incidence of neuroendocrine cancer by a particular multiple. Comparisons circulated by Barasch & McGarry juxtapose the program's certification totals with population-wide cancer incidence rates, but the populations and measures are not necessarily directly comparable.
Barasch also pointed to skin, prostate, breast, lung and thyroid cancers among diagnoses seen in the 9/11 community. His broader concern, he said, is that illnesses emerging decades later can be particularly dangerous if someone does not realize that a past exposure may be medically relevant.
For Sakoutis, that risk is personal. Her cancer was detected only after a cough prompted the medical visit that led to imaging. She said people who were in the exposure area should tell their doctors about that history rather than assuming the passage of time means they are no longer at risk.
Families Face Delays in 9/11 Death Claims
The health toll is only one part of the story. Some families seeking compensation after a relative dies face an additional legal process because a deceased victim's claim must be handled by an authorized personal representative.
Barasch told Newsweek his firm currently has 1,858 death cases at various stages before filing or within the VCF process. Of those, he said 399 cannot yet be fully submitted, including 244 in which relatives are waiting for a Surrogate's Court appointment and another 155 where documentation is still being assembled.
Records can be particularly difficult to reconstruct decades after the exposure, with families potentially needing medical, employment and other evidence. VCF rules also require appropriate legal authority to act on behalf of a deceased victim, which can send relatives through estate proceedings before they can complete a claim.
Barasch is calling for New York to create an expedited process that allows relatives to obtain the limited authority needed for VCF cases. He also wants Congress to change how certain collateral payments, including life insurance, are treated when calculating awards.
Current VCF policy requires deducting certain payments from other sources when calculating compensation. Barasch argues that the treatment of privately purchased life insurance unfairly reduces wrongful-death compensation for families whose loved ones bought coverage.
His proposals go further, including indexing non-economic loss limits to inflation and increasing staffing for the federal health and compensation programs. Those are recommendations from Barasch, rather than announced federal or state policy changes.

...
The Long-Term Toll of September 11
The milestone has sharpened a distinction that families and advocates have emphasized for years: September 11's immediate death toll and the number of people who later became ill are separate measures of the attacks' human consequences.
For Doug Mandelkow, each new deceased claim represents a story resembling his own.
"The fact that the number has topped 10,000 and keeps climbing every year is horrifying and heartbreaking," he told Newsweek. "Behind every claim is a family like mine that lost a father, mother, spouse or child years after 2001."
His father never reached old age. James Mandelkow died at 54.
Sakoutis survived her cancer, but she said the growing number of deaths carries its own emotional burden. Asked how she felt about deceased claims crossing 10,000, she said she still experiences guilt when she learns that someone exposed after the attacks has died.
"My brain acknowledges I was just a 30-something-year-old gal in a summer dress and white pumps, but I still feel guilty," she told Newsweek. "I went to therapy for it and have just learned to accept the guilt."
For those still living with uncertainty, Barasch said the central lesson from his own two cancer diagnoses is to take potential exposure seriously and seek appropriate monitoring.
"Early detection is the reason I am alive today," he said.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines