10
Loading video...

By Sam Stevenson
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed has urged President Donald Trump to embrace Medicare for All, saying it is "really popular," but two recent polls offer sharply different pictures of public support.
El-Sayed, who defeated Republican Mike Rogers in Michigan's Senate race, has offered an unusual sales pitch to a Republican president: let Trump put his name on universal health care.
Two national polls conducted in September show differing levels of support for Medicare for All, with KFF finding majority support while an Axios/Ipsos survey found a plurality in favor when the proposal was described as largely replacing private insurance.
Read More on Politics
El-Sayed, who recently called Trump an “unserious fool,” took a different tack in a November 17 video posted on his X account, addressing the president as “habibi,” an Arabic term of affection, before pitching a rebranded version of Medicare for All.
“Trumpcare for All. It’s really popular. People really want healthcare,” he said. “You can put your name all over it.”
"The Radical Democrats’ socialist proposal for a government takeover of healthcare should really be called ‘Medicare for None’ as it destroys access to the life-saving care Americans rely on daily," White House spokeswoman Allison Schuster told Fox News Digital on Tuesday evening in response.
Newsweek emailed El-Sayed’s senatorial campaign and the White House for further comment on Wednesday morning.
Why It Matters
El-Sayed's tongue-in-cheek pitch comes after Democrats' midterm gains and puts a long-running progressive goal back into the debate as Americans worry about health care costs.
Medicare for All would fundamentally change how Americans obtain and pay for health coverage, potentially replacing much of the private insurance system.
Key Points From the Polls
- Two September polls found meaningful support for Medicare for All, but produced notably different results depending on how the policy was described.
- KFF found majority backing in its initial question, although support shifted sharply when respondents were presented with arguments for and against the proposal.
- Axios/Ipsos recorded a smaller plurality in favor after explicitly describing Medicare for All as government-run insurance that would largely replace private coverage.

...
KFF Finds Majority Support
KFF’s pre-election Health Tracking Poll, conducted September 16 to 21 among 1,328 U.S. adults, with a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 3 percentage points for the full sample, found 66 percent favored "a national health plan, sometimes called Medicare-for-all, in which all Americans would get their insurance from a single government plan."
That level of support was substantially higher than the 53 percent KFF recorded when it last asked the question in 2020.
Partisanship produced a stark divide. Eighty-four percent of Democrats and 72 percent of independents favored the proposal, while 66 percent of Republicans opposed it.
What Happens When Voters Hear The Trade-Offs
After hearing that Medicare for All could lead to delays in some medical tests and treatments, 76 percent opposed it.
Sixty-five percent were against the proposal when told most Americans would be required to pay more in taxes, while 62 percent opposed it after hearing that it could threaten the existing Medicare program.
Positive arguments moved opinion in the opposite direction.
Seventy-six percent supported the plan when told it would guarantee health insurance as a right for all Americans, while 75 percent backed it after hearing that it would eliminate premiums and reduce out-of-pocket health care costs for most people.
That volatility matters when judging whether Medicare for All is "really popular": Americans can react quite differently to the same underlying policy depending on the consequences placed before them.

...
Axios/Ipsos Finds A Smaller Plurality In Favor
A separate Axios/Ipsos American Health Index illustrates that point particularly clearly.
Conducted September 25 to 28 among 1,122 U.S. adults, the survey had a sampling error margin of plus or minus 3 percentage points.
Unlike KFF's initial question, respondents were explicitly told that Medicare for All would provide government-run insurance and "largely" replace private health insurance.
Under that description, 43 percent supported it, 24 percent opposed it and 32 percent were unsure.
Among Democrats, backing reached 62 percent; 47 percent of independents approved, while 52 percent of Republicans were opposed.
The same poll nevertheless found considerable appetite for government action on affordability.
Sixty-six percent agreed that Washington should be willing to spend more tax dollars to reduce Americans' health care costs, compared with 11 percent who said it should not spend additional money even if household costs increased.
For opponents of single payer, the biggest concern was the treatment they might receive: 38 percent feared care would be worse than under private insurance, ahead of taxpayer cost at 22 percent and opposition to government involvement in health care at 21 percent.
What The White House Says
The White House has pointed to Trump's efforts to reduce prescription drug prices and said the president would continue pursuing policies aimed at lowering costs.
The administration also cited a Council of Economic Advisers analysis estimating that Medicare for All would increase the federal budget deficit by about $47.4 trillion between 2027 and 2036 without additional taxes or revenue.
For El-Sayed, however, the political gamble is that voters' frustration with the existing system leaves an opening for something much bigger when he enters the Senate on January 3.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Sam Stevenson, Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines