A resident mows the lawn in front of his home along McKinley Street near the home where Republican vice presidential candidate Ohio Senator JD Vance was raised on July 23, 2024, in Middletown, Ohio.  (Scott Olson/Getty Images)

...

Giulia Carbonaro

By Giulia Carbonaro

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


As Ohio lawmakers weigh out options to offer relief to homeowners in the state who are struggling with higher property tax bills, experts are warning that eliminating the rates entirely would harm local governments in a way that would not be easy to fix.

“Replacing Ohio’s property taxes would require implausibly high sales or income taxes, and there’s no way to replace the revenue without creating a host of new problems,” Jared Walczak, vice president of state projects at the nonpartisan think tank Tax Foundation, told Newsweek.

Why Are Ohio Lawmakers Looking at Offering Property Tax Relief?

Ohioans have seen their property tax bills creep up for years now, as home values soared during the pandemic home-buying frenzy, when everyone wanted to buy a property but there was just not enough supply.

Read More on News

According to Redfin, the median sale price of a home in the state was $261,500 last month, up from $190,600 five years earlier, in September 2020. The state’s average effective property tax rate is currently 1.43 percent, according to SmartAsset’s data, higher than the national average of 0.90 percent.

The Tax Foundation calculated that Ohio has the eighth-heaviest property tax burden in the nation, ahead of traditionally expensive housing markets like New York and California. Rising property duties have been weighing heavily on the Buckeye State’s homeowners, especially as wages have not kept up with these increases. Ohio ranks 40th in median household income in the country, according to the Tax Foundation.

What Kind of Reform Is Ohio Considering?

Lawmakers in the state agree that there is an urgent need to offer relief to homeowners, but they have not yet decided on what type of reform is needed.

A working group tasked with finding solutions to the problem by Governor Mike DeWine issued 20 different options earlier this month to ease the burden on homeowners—including completely eliminating property taxes in the state.

Two of these options, contained in House Bills 129 and 309, passed the Ohio House last week.

A resident mows the lawn in front of his home on July 23, 2024, in Middletown, Ohio. (Scott Olson/Getty Images)

...

HB 129 would include emergency and substitute levies in some school districts, effectively limiting major revenue increases like the ones reported by Ohio districts over the past five years. HB 309 would allow the County Budget Commission to modify levies and reduce a taxing unit’s millage if these are deemed “unnecessary or excessive.”

The bills would need to pass the Ohio Senate and be signed by the governor to come into force. Meanwhile, abolishing property taxes in the state is still on the table.

Why Are Experts Warning Against Eliminating Property Taxes?

While many Ohioans would be happy to bid farewell to property taxes, doing so could create havoc in public services in the very near future, experts warn.

Should property taxes be eliminated in the state, they would likely be replaced by a new local taxing authority, Walczak said—a move that would make it “almost impossible” for jurisdictions to replace the lost revenues with additional municipal sales or income taxes.

“Bedroom communities without a retail concentration, for instance, may not be able to collect enough sales tax to offset lost property tax revenue at almost any rate,” he said.

Alternatively, they could be replaced with higher state income or sales tax rates, with revenues disbursed to localities.

“Then, even beyond dealing with uncompetitively high state tax rates, lawmakers will have the unenviable task of deciding how to allocate the funds,” Walczak said.

“If they backfill revenue in proportion to current collections, they’ll reward higher-tax jurisdictions in perpetuity. Where you currently have homeowners paying higher rates for better local services, you’ll now have the rest of the state subsidizing these mostly higher-income jurisdictions,” he added.

If they backfill according to population or some other formula, “some jurisdictions will be big winners, but others will find their budgets slashed,” Walczak said, “with no mechanism for making up the lost revenue.”

There is just no good way of replacing property taxes, according to Walczak. “Under any approach, there’s a risk that revenue replacement won’t track with changing demographics, and population growth might stretch revenue thin, thereby encouraging localities to shrink rather than grow,” he said.

“Many homeowners understandably dislike the property tax. They’d probably hate the alternatives.”

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines