10

Loading video...

Hugh Cameron

By Hugh Cameron

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Supreme Court's new term opened Monday with a potentially landmark case pitting states and local governments against some of the world’s largest oil firms.

The case asks whether states can hold oil giants liable under state law for climate change-related effects like rising seas and storms, and for the billions of dollars in resulting damage to property and infrastructure.

During oral arguments on Monday, Justice Amy Coney Barrett raised a “quibble” about how much authority state law has over federal regulations on interstate pollution.

Read More on U.S.

Advocate Kannon Shanmugam, representing the fossil fuel firms, argued that Congress authorized state law “to apply in a very specific context,” and that precedent points to interstate pollution as a fundamentally federal domain without congressional authorization.

Barrett interjected that precedents like American Electric Power Co. v. Connecticut (2011) did not show Congress intervening to provide authorization, but that the law “preserved some state authority” that already existed.

“it's not that it said Congress authorized states in any way. It just left alone some of that preexisting authority, maybe some of which might be affected by the Clean Air Act.”

What Is the Case?

In 2018, the city of Boulder, Colorado, sued oil giants Suncor and ExxonMobil over their alleged role in contributing to climate change and for misleading the public about it. The Supreme Court is now weighing whether this case can proceed under state law.

The defendant oil firms have asked the U.S. Supreme Court to toss the case, arguing that federal law preempts state law in these matters, and that the Clean Air Act specifically prohibits such lawsuits against energy companies.

Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett testifies during a Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Financial Services hearing on July 14, 2026.

...

Allowing the case to move forward would be groundbreaking, as the oil companies have themselves acknowledged, paving the way for further suits against firms over their alleged role in climate change and any associated destruction.

“Giving even a single jury the power to impose ruinous liability on selected members of the energy industry is a recipe for chaos. Unleashing juries nationwide is a recipe for disaster,” the defendant companies wrote in a brief submitted to the court.

“State tort law is not the solution to global climate change,” they continued.

Justice Samuel Alito recused himself from the case last week. The letter disclosing this decision did not state a reason, though this followed questions over his holdings in oil companies; Alito has in the past recused himself from cases involving companies in which he had a “financial interest.”

Given this and the potential for a 4-4 deadlock, attention will be on the court’s more central conservatives, Chief Justice John Roberts and Barrett, who will be watched closely for indications of how the case may unfold.

Related Story

Supreme Court Refuses to Hear ‘Let’s Go Brandon’ Apparel School Ban Case

Supreme Court Refuses to Hear ‘Let’s Go Brandon’ Apparel School Ban Case

What Do These Justices Think?

In analogous cases, Roberts has expressed concerns about the potential impact of burdensome regulations and reinterpretations of climate-related statutes on businesses.

Internal memos uncovered by The New York Times earlier this year alleged that Roberts “acted as a bulldozer” to stop former President Barack Obama’s Clean Power Plan from taking effect on these grounds. In one memo, Roberts cited an estimated cost of $480 billion for the plan, higher than the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's official estimates.

And such concerns were apparent during Monday’s arguments.

Court artist drawing depicting attorney Kannon Shanmugam addressing the Supreme Court on October 5, 2026.

...

Addressing the team representing Boulder, Roberts said allowing the case to proceed would “presumably” mean that “the next day a municipality in every single state will file a lawsuit.”

Barrett, meanwhile, appeared skeptical of some of the other side's arguments. In response to Shanmugam saying the side’s position on state courts addressing interstate air pollution “apply with full force, regardless of what EPA says,” Barrett called this aspect of the fossil fuel companies’ legal arguments “a little slippery.”

An analysis by the UCLA law professor Alejandro Camacho had Barrett “leaning toward” the oil companies, albeit “by a narrower route.” He described Roberts as “skeptical of both sides, and harder on Boulder by the end.”

The justices are due to rule by late June 2027.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Cannon and Sam Wilson.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines