
...

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Experts and trade groups have warned that Argentina may be unable to source enough beef to meet domestic demand while also hiking its shipments to the U.S., potentially derailing President Donald Trump’s plan to purchase the country’s supplies to address rocketing U.S. prices.
“We are the world’s top consumers of beef. There’s not much room to export more,” Javier Preciado Patiño, Argentina’s former undersecretary of Agricultural Markets, told United Press International on Wednesday. He added that without a significant increase in productivity, the country would be unable to meaningfully address the U.S.’s shortfall.
Newsweek has contacted the White House and Argentina’s agricultural ministry for comment via email.
Read More on Politics
Why It Matters
Trump’s proposal to buy “some” Argentinian beef to reduce American costs has already faced sharp criticism from American cattle farmers who believe the move will undercut their domestic competitiveness without significantly affecting prices. Experts similarly note that Argentina’s production capacity would minimize any meaningful price impacts for U.S. consumers.
U.S. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins has also cautioned that disease-related issues may prevent or limit the scope of any deal, though Argentine officials have disputed this as a concern.
What To Know
The United States imported 1.64 million tons of beef in 2024, according to Trade Data Monitor, primarily from Australia, Canada, Mexico, Brazil and New Zealand.
Argentina accounted for just over 2 percent of total U.S. beef and veal imports last year, and imports are restricted by an annual tariff-free quota of 20,000 tons—intended to protect U.S. producers while ensuring quality standards.
The country is noted for its beef-eating culture, and domestic demand has been soaring in recent years. According to an April report from the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Foreign Agricultural Service, the country is also grappling with its own supply issues—with production forecast to drop about 3 percent compared to 2024 because of lower calving rates and adverse weather conditions.

...
David P. Anderson, a professor and livestock economist at Texas A&M University, told Newsweek that the effects on Argentina’s own beef supply and prices should receive attention in debates over Trump’s proposal.
“I had the chance to tour Argentina’s beef industry back in about 2007. That was about the time they banned all beef exports to bring down consumer beef prices,” he said. “They eat a lot of beef and it’s an important cultural item. Exporting more to other countries means higher prices for their consumers.”
José Rizzo, the president of the Chamber of Meat Suppliers of Mendoza—a regional trade association—told the Argentine outlet Diario NDI that while exact details of Trump’s proposal remained unclear, expanding quotas for exports to the U.S. would likely tighten domestic supplies.
“Argentina today does not have enough meat of the type they ask for,” he said. “If exports rise, domestic values could rise. Everything is still very preliminary.”
In a video posted on X, Preciado Patiño called the plan “technically and commercially impossible,” adding that “neither in terms of quality nor volume is Argentina going to make American consumers pay less for beef.”
In an interview on Radio Mitre this week, Nicolás Pino, the president of the Sociedad Rural Argentina—which represents agricultural producers—said Trump’s interest in Argentine beef was “very good news” for the export sector. However, he added that this would require raising production levels and increasing the cattle herd.
What People Are Saying
Agricultural economist Derrell Peel previously told Newsweek: “Domestic beef consumption in Argentina uses 70-75 percent of total beef production in the country. If, for example, the U.S. doubled imports over 2024 levels, it would likely mostly be at the expense of other markets for Argentine beef. China has been the largest market in recent years, and the E.U. is a significant market. Such an increase in imports from Argentina would have a negligible impact on the total supply of beef in the U.S. market. In fact, if the U.S. took all of the projected 2025 Argentine beef exports, if would represent less than 2.5 percent of total U.S. beef supply.”
U.S. President Donald Trump said during a meeting with NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte on Wednesday: “The beef ranchers, let’s say—who have done a great job—have lost their shirts for many, many years. They’ve really been decimated. And I help them a lot. I put tariffs on things coming into the country, including beef, and that gave them a chance to finally have a decent industry. We are going to be talking to them, and they’re great people, but they’ve been hurt for 25, 30 years. They’ve been losing because other countries have taken advantage of them, and by putting tariffs on, they’ve been able to make a few dollars. They’ve been able to have an industry, but I also want to keep the beef prices low. So I’ll be talking with the ranchers, and I’ll be speaking with a lot of different people.”
What Happens Next
Politico, citing sources familiar with the plans, reported that the administration sought to import 80,000 metric tons, quadrupling the current import quota, but that discussions were ongoing.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines