
...

By Jenna Sundel
News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A family member of Doug Benefield and a prosecutor in the case dubbed "The Black Swan" murder trial slammed Ashley Benefield's dramatic testimony.
Ashley Benefield, a 33-year-old former ballerina, was charged with second-degree murder in the 2020 fatal shooting of her husband, 58-year-old Doug Benefield. She was convicted on the lesser offense of manslaughter.
Tommie Benefield, Doug Benefield's cousin, claimed that Ashley Benefield did not actually cry during her testimony.
Read More on U.S.
"She's like 10, 15 minutes into pretending to cry, and she's putting on a good show, but there's no tears," Tommie Benefield said in a recent podcast interview. "And the judge says to her at some point, 'Hey, there's a box of Kleenex if you need it,' because he can't see she's not crying. But everyone in the courtroom and the jury can see she's not crying."
Ashley Benefield took the stand in her trial on July 26. She became emotional multiple times during her testimony, visibly shaking and sobbing at some points. She recounted how her relationship with Doug Benefield began, several incidents of alleged abuse and the day she shot him.

...
"Black Swan Murder," a podcast by Law & Crime, focused on her testimony on its sixth episode. The six-part podcast can be accessed by Wondery+ subscribers on the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Castbox, Pocket Casts and Overcast.
Prosecutor Suzanne O'Donnell also questioned Ashley Benefield's emotional outbursts.
"There was one point where we had to stop, because she was crying so hysterically, and take the jury out and take a break," O'Donnell said. "And she did not look like she was crying. She looked exactly the way she did before, so that was not lost on the jury."
O'Donnell said one juror looked directly at Ashley Benefield as the jury left the room.
"I thought, 'She's seeing exactly what I'm seeing. There's no tears,'" O'Donnell said.
The testimony gave Ashley Benefield the opportunity to tell her side of the story.
"When we found out that she was definitely going to testify that day, I was excited, because let's hear her speak for herself after four years," Tommie Benefield said.
Ashley Benefield's account of the events leading up to the shooting failed to convince O'Donnell.
"I didn't feel most of it was genuine," O'Donnell said. "I felt most of it was overdone."
O'Donnell led the cross-examination, calling Ashley Benefield's fear and the level of threat she perceived into question.
Jurors weighed testimony from Ashley Benefield and others as they deliberated for six hours before delivering the manslaughter conviction. Tommie Benefield said the conviction on the lesser offense was not surprising.
"We knew it was confusing enough that they would struggle to get a second-degree murder conviction," Tommie Benefield said.
Defense attorney Neil Taylor said he and the rest of his team were "crushed" by the verdict.
"We really can't get over it because we all thought we'd won," Taylor said.
What's Next for Ashley Benefield
Ashley Benefield's legal team has filed a motion for a new trial alleging juror misconduct.
Taylor said he noticed something when he went back to the office after the verdict was announced.
"There's a network that publishes a verdict watch, and we notice there is a chat portion where some individual who identifies himself as 'That Hoodie Guy' has a number of entries predicting precisely what the jury has done, but before they did it, and he's got it in real time," Taylor said.
He alleged that a juror snuck a phone into the jury room.
"Of course, we realize chat rooms, you can say anything you want, but we can't figure out the uncanny accuracy of these posts," Taylor said.
The defense then conducts background checks on the six jurors.
"At this point our head explodes," Taylor said.
He discovered that one of the jurors had been a victim of domestic violence and had filed for a domestic violence restraining order. The juror had also been named as a defendant in two domestic violence cases.
During jury selection, jurors were asked if they had ever been involved in domestic violence courts. The juror did not disclose her experience during the selection process. She also did not disclose that her ex-husband once sought sole custody of their child when asked if she had ever been involved in a custody battle.
"Now we know, oh my God, this juror lied," Taylor said.
Ashley Benefield's sentencing is scheduled for December 3.
Do you have a story Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines