
...

By Adrian Shanker and Sam Ames
Former Senior Biden Appointees at HHS
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Perhaps the most scientifically accurate thing Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has said all year is that nobody should take medical advice from him. Meanwhile, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)—an agency once widely trusted for their commitment to the scientific process, has become ground zero for medical myths masquerading as fact. Under his leadership, the CDC has been forced to replace decades of advances in science with conspiracy theories on vaccines, autism, HIV/AIDS, fluoride, Tylenol and even Wi-Fi. But most people know conspiracy theories are not evidence. An institution once known across the world for best-practice medicine is now mistrusted by nearly half of all Americans.
On the eve of Transgender Day of Remembrance, HHS published a methodologically-muddled “peer review” of their anti-trans health report. During its release Kennedy stated that gender-affirming care “is not medicine — it’s malpractice.”

...
Read More on Opinion
What he didn’t discuss, and what the report fails to adequately address, is the longstanding consensus of every major medical organization that gender-affirming care is linked to improvements in the health of transgender youth. Instead, its authors rely on misrepresentation of outdated studies to deflect from decades of research linking common-sense interventions to a 60 percent reduction in rates of depression and a 73 percent reduction in self-harm and suicidality.
The report stokes panic that wide swaths of America’s youth are rushing to make permanent changes too young, ignoring that the most comprehensive study to date found the number of trans patients who received gender-affirming surgery before 18 was 2.1 per 100,000, and the number who received it before 12 was zero. It substitutes salacious but anecdotal evidence for methodologically-sound data, which consistently shows the regret rate for gender-affirming care is less than 1 percent (compared to knee surgeries at 6 percent, bariatric surgeries at 7 percent and prostate surgeries at 16 percent). Finally, it reverse-engineers its conclusion that trans youth and their families should not be able to make health care decisions before 18, but also rejects the reality that allowing puberty to proceed is itself an irreversible change. Instead, it vilifies and greatly overstates the side effects of interventions like puberty blockers, which doctors have been safely using for decades to enable families to hold off on permanent decisions until they are ready.
This dangerous cocktail of transphobia and conspiracy theories is a poor substitute for scientific evidence. The original report was published just six weeks after a presidential directive to do so. HHS only had it peer-reviewed when the scientific community denounced its low-quality research, poor citations and false claims. Changes to this final version are minimal. The American Psychiatric Association responded that “the Report’s claims fall short of the standard of methodological rigor that should be considered a prerequisite for policy guidance in clinical care.” The American Medical Association and American Academy of Pediatrics issued a joint statement saying “These claims, rooted in politics and partisanship, misrepresent the consensus of medical science, undermine the professionalism of physicians, and risk harming vulnerable young people and their families.”
It is understandable for laypeople who value critical thinking to look at the debates unfolding at HHS and wonder what is true. What was formerly a generally-accepted medical consensus has been thrown into a flashy culture war whose proponents rely on bluster and noise to appear on equal footing with empirical evidence—and then somewhat audaciously claim the mantle of “biological fact” (an assertion that ignores the 1.7 percent of humans with intersex characteristics). But using a small minority of loud voices to create the appearance of a genuine scientific debate is hardly unique to this issue. The greatest danger of HHS under Kennedy’s leadership is that more Americans than ever now say that they don’t believe they can trust information from federal health agencies. We are in a moment when conspiracy theorists are waging a war on facts, including the existence of trans people—a moment that calls for courage and critical thinking.
So let’s be clear about what we know. Vaccines save lives, Tylenol doesn’t cause autism and Wi-Fi isn’t mind control. These are conclusions based on decades of study, guided by standards of care that politicians like Kennedy lack the medical expertise to unilaterally rewrite. It is a scientific and historical fact that transgender and intersex people have existed as long as human beings have. One report cannot change what health care is medically necessary for them, only what health care is safely accessible to them. If, by his own admission, Kennedy cannot give competent medical advice, it is time he put his energy toward making health care available to more Americans, not fewer.
Adrian Shanker is senior fellow at the Lehigh University College of Health. He served as deputy assistant secretary for health policy at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services in the Biden-Harris administration.
Sam Ames is a civil rights attorney and expert in suicide prevention. They served as senior advisor to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Agency at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services in the Biden-Harris administration.
The views expressed in this article are the writers’ own.
UPDATED 12/17/2025 at 4:55 p.m.: The HHS report did publish the names of the authors.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines