10

Loading video...

Martha McHardy

By Martha McHardy

US News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Bovaer, a cow feed additive given a green light by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the U.S. for reducing methane emissions, is facing a battle for public acceptance as experts assure opponents it is safe.

Bovaer is a new feed additive that claims to significantly reduce the emission of methane, a greenhouse gas that is driving climate change, in dairy cows. DSM-Firmenich, the company behind Bovaer claims it could reduce cow methane emissions by between 30-45 percent. The Global Methane Pledge requires a 30 percent reduction in anthropogenic methane emissions by 2030 from 2020 levels.

But opponents are boycotting the product, with some citing a report by the U.K.'s Food Standards Agency last year, which found that one ingredient, "3-NOP "should be considered corrosive to the eyes, a skin irritant, and potentially harmful by inhalation" to humans handling it. But multiple experts say that there are no harmful chemicals passed through to consumers because they are filtered out by the cow's digestive system.

Read More on U.S.

The additive, which is for sale in 68 countries around the world, has been approved for use by U.K. regulators, with several major supermarkets set to stock milk produced by cattle eating feed with the additive. It has also secured a regulatory green light from the FDA in the U.S. for use in lactating dairy cattle, ruling that it meets safety and efficacy requirements.

The FDA ruled: "FDA has no questions at this time regarding whether Bovaer will achieve its intended effect and is expected to pose low risk to humans or animals under the conditions of its intended use."

A spokesperson for the FDA told Newsweek: "This extends to the safety of food (e.g., meat, milk) from animals treated with Bovaer."

Cows

...

Jeff Simmons, President and CEO of Elanco Animal Health, DSM-Firmenich's U.S. partner, said in response to the FDA ruling: "This monumental announcement has the ability to accelerate the opportunity for climate-neutral dairy farming while creating a new revenue stream for dairy farmers across the country.

"We appreciate FDA's commitment to maintaining high standards for science-based review, while balancing the need to quickly bring solutions to the market. Bovaer represents another example of Elanco being a partner of choice in animal health, where the capabilities of our talented R&D, regulatory and commercial teams are delivering significant value."

According to Katie Cook, VP of livestock sustainability at Elanco, 150 farms in the U.S. have now enrolled in the online tool, Uplook, which will be used to quantify greenhouse gas emission reductions when using Bovaer, following the ruling, meaning shoppers could see milk which includes the additive on shelves soon.

"We already have 150 farms enrolled on Uplook and we're growing that number every day," Cook told AFN. "So that's the first strong indicator of their willingness to participate. They're already submitting data without getting any credit for it because they want to make sure they have worked out all the kinks so that they can be ready to implement Bovaer once product is available."

DSM-Firmenich and Elanco likely face an uphill battle to convince consumers that Boaver is safe, as the additive has come under intense scrutiny on social media.

Bovaer is made using silicon dioxide, propylene glycol and organic compound 3-nitrooxypropanol (known as 3-NOP), which prompted the U.K. Food Standards Agency's warning last year.

What FDA Said About Bovaer in Milk

...

Experts have emphasized that no traces of Bovaer or the compounds contained within it would be found in dairy produce, as it is broken down by a cow's digestive system.

"There is no evidence to support the presence of 3NOP in milk since the compound is broken down in the stomach of the cow," Dr. Joseph W. McFadden, Associate Professor of Dairy Cattle Biology at Cornell University told Newsweek.

Other opponents have claimed that 3-NOP could cause cancer, but U.K. regulators have dismissed these concerns.

Some British shoppers have threatened to boycott supermarkets selling milk with the additive, and some critics have even filmed themselves pouring milk down the toilet in protest, with clips on TikTok attacking the product receiving up to 1.8 million views each.

Other opponents have made baseless claims that Microsoft founder Bill Gates is involved in the development of Bovaer, linking the additive to the conspiracy theory that Gates is part of an effort to depopulate the world.

Those claims emerged after an approval letter from the FDA found that the additive could lead to male infertility. But the letter was referring to precautions that must be taken when handling the product in its pure form, rather than when it is added to animal feed.

In a statement, DSM-Firmenich said it had "fully developed" Bovaer and emphasized that the company had "no other investors."

"Bill Gates is not involved in the development of Bovaer," the statement added.

Experts have also debunked conspiracy theories, telling Newsweek that Bovaer "poses a low risk to humans."

"The use of Bovaer in dairy cattle is effective at reducing enteric methane emissions and it poses a low risk to humans and animals under conditions of use," McFadden told Newsweek.

"The spread of misinformation regarding methane-reducing feed additives has the potential to prevent their use, and prevent our ability to achieve global methane reduction targets in a safe and effective manner," he added.

Ermias Kebreab, Associate Dean at the College of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences also told Newsweek: "Bovaer has been independently and extensively tested in several countries around the world and has been shown to be quite safe."

Season Solorio, a spokesperson for Elanco, told Newsweek that Bovaer is "safe" and "effective."

"Bovaer—a safe, effective cattle feed ingredient—represents a key science-based opportunity. Bovaer is the most extensively studied and scientifically proven methane-reducing feed ingredient, with more than 15 years of research and more than 85 peer-reviewed published articles. Regulatory authorities around the world, including the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the UK Food Standards Agency, as well as EFSA, have completed multi-year reviews confirming the safety and efficacy of Bovaer for use in lactating dairy cattle," Solorio said.

She added that "just one tablespoon" of Bovaer in the diet of a lactating dairy cow per day "can reduce enteric methane emissions by about 30 percent or about 1.2 metric tons annually."

"Feeding one million lactating dairy cows Bovaer could reduce emissions equivalent to removing 285,000 gasoline powered cars from the road annually," she said.

"Feeding Bovaer to cattle has proven to be safe for animals, producers and consumers."

DSM-Firmenich previously said that "mistruths and misinformation, external" have been spread about its product, and that it is "totally safe" for use, and has been tested over many years in many countries.

Update 12/05/24, 11:22 a.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from Season Solorio, a spokesperson for Elanco.

Update 12/07/24, 9:37 a.m. ET: This article was updated to clarify that the FDA's approval of Bovaer extends to the safety of food from animals treated with Bovaer.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines