Struggles Ahead for Brits Who Want Dual Nationality Post-Brexit

Dual nationality
A British passport is pictured in front of an European Union flag in this photo taken in Brussels, Belgium, June 20, 2016. Francois Lenoir/REUTERS

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

One of the major implications of leaving the European Union for British nationals is the loss of EU citizenship. British nationals will no longer be able to enjoy the right to free movement within the EU or the right to live in any member state. They will also lose the right to equal treatment in other EU member states on the same terms as nationals of those countries.

In principle, the U.K. government could reach an agreement with the EU that will allow British citizens living elsewhere in the EU to continue to enjoy their current rights and offer a reciprocal arrangement for EU nationals who live and work in the U.K.

One of the possibilities would be to provide British nationals who want to remain part of the European project with associate EU citizenship, an idea that has been proposed by a liberal MEP from Luxembourg, Charles Goerens. If accepted by the European Parliament, it could enable British nationals who opt for the new status to continue to travel and reside freely within the European Union.

Both the British prime minister Theresa May and the president of the EU Council, Donald Tusk, have stressed that clarifying the status of both EU citizens living in the U.K. and British citizens elsewhere in Europe will be top priority as Brexit negotiations begin. Until then, many face uncertainty—and are angered at being used as bargaining chips.

There’re 3mil EU citizens in the UK. Our home, families & friends are here. There’s no other home to ‘go back to’! #bargainingchip

— the3million (@the3million) March 28, 2017

So it is not surprising that some Britons have tried to take the matter into their own hands by looking for ways to get dual nationality with another member state. There has been some political support for this by the German Green party who called on the German government to fast-track the applications of Britons wishing to become German citizens ahead of Brexit.

Within a few months of the referendum vote in June 2016, there was a surge in applications by Britons for naturalization in other EU member states. In some straightforward cases, a connection with another member state gives the right to acquire its nationality. For example, British nationals of Irish descent—and anybody born in Northern Ireland—have the right to acquire Irish citizenship. British nationals who are descendants of Jewish World War II German refugees also have the right to acquire German nationality.

Trouble in Spain

Yet, there are different nationality laws across the EU. The U.K. recognizes dual nationality from anywhere in the world. Most other EU member states also accept dual nationality, but not all. Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Slovenia do not permit dual nationality. The Netherlands, requires applicants for naturalization to renounce their previous nationality unless the personal circumstances of the applicant meet a number of exceptions. The same applies to naturalization in Austria.

Spain recognizes dual nationality only with countries with which it has a specific connection: Ibero-American countries, Andorra, the Philippines, Equatorial Guinea and Portugal. Britons applying for Spanish nationality therefore need to renounce their U.K. nationality. Following naturalization in Spain, the continued use of U.K. nationality may lead to loss of Spanish nationality.

Spanish citizens who wish to obtain another nationality, such as those living in the U.K, do not face this dilemma. They can have dual nationality if they inform the Spanish authorities of their intention to maintain their Spanish citizenship within three years from the moment they acquire U.K. nationality. Because of this inequality, an agreement on the status of British nationals in Spain—the country that is home to the largest number of British citizens in the EU—is particularly important to address in the Brexit negotiations.

German dilemma

The national rules on loss of nationality upon acquiring a foreign citizenship are complex and vary from one member state to another. Another potentially complicated situation arises for Britons who want to apply for German nationality. Germany accepts dual nationality only with other member states of the EU. Therefore, while the U.K. remains an EU member state, U.K. nationals can apply for German nationality without the need to renounce U.K. nationality. After Brexit, new applicants will have to give up their U.K. nationality.

The national laws on dual nationality will also affect applications of nationals of other member states for naturalization in the U.K. Nationals of member states that do not recognize dual nationality could potentially lose their nationality of origin.

All this means that dual nationality is one of the solutions to losing EU citizenship, but it is by no means a substitute for a comprehensive political solution that would allow all affected British nationals to secure their rights in other member states following Brexit.

Oxana Golynker is Lecturer in Law at the University of Leicester