10
Loading video...

By Jesus Mesa
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Byron Donalds enters Tuesday’s Republican primary for Florida governor as the overwhelming favorite, with every major poll and prediction market pointing to a victory for the Trump-backed congressman, who has led the race since entering it.
Prediction markets gave Donalds a 97 to 99 percent chance of winning heading into Election Day.
On Kalshi, contracts trading Monday morning put his odds at 98.4 percent, with Lieutenant Governor Jay Collins and businessman James Fishback taking most of the remaining share. Polymarket put Donalds at 99 percent, while Fishback, Florida Agriculture Commissioner Wilton Simpson and Casey DeSantis, the wife of term-limited Governor Ron DeSantis, were each below 1 percent.
Read More on Politics
The final wave of public and partisan polling tells the same story, though the size of Donalds' lead varies by pollster.
A Quantus Insights survey of 635 likely Republican voters, conducted July 27 to 29 for the partisan client America First Insight, found Donalds at 50 percent, 34 points ahead of Collins at 16 percent. Fishback trailed at 12 percent and former Florida House Speaker Paul Renner at 4 percent.
A Targoz Market Research poll of 532 likely voters, conducted July 20 to 26 for the James Madison Institute, put Donalds at 49 percent to Collins' 18 percent, a 31-point margin. Renner drew 8 percent and Fishback 4 percent in that survey.

...
A poll from The Political Matrix and The Listener Group, conducted July 21 to 22 among 1,020 likely voters, showed a tighter race, with Donalds at 32 percent, Renner at 19 percent and Fishback at 13 percent, though 32 percent of respondents were undecided.
The widest margin came from Fabrizio, Lee & Associates, polling for the Donalds campaign itself. That survey of 400 likely voters, conducted July 14 to 16, had Donalds at 53 percent to Collins' 10 percent, a 43-point spread. A second Fabrizio Lee poll released August 10 showed Donalds climbing to 54 percent.
Earlier surveys from Emerson College and the University of North Florida, both conducted in the spring and again in July, consistently placed Donalds in the mid-40s, with Collins and Fishback clustered in single digits and a meaningful undecided share that has narrowed as the primary approached.
Why the Field Never Closed the Gap
The governor’s primary could set the direction of the Florida GOP, with the longstanding rivalry between DeSantis and President Donald Trump broadly shaping the Republican contest.
Donalds has out-raised his rivals by a wide margin, reporting roughly $10 million in contributions in the most recent quarter, compared with well under $1 million for each of his remaining Republican opponents, according to state campaign finance filings. He has also won endorsements from Trump, Senator Rick Scott, Agriculture Commissioner Wilton Simpson and the full Florida Cabinet.

...
Collins, whom DeSantis appointed lieutenant governor in 2025, has cast himself as the race’s underdog. At a recent meet-and-greet, he argued that endorsements and money “don’t matter” to Florida voters who “think for themselves,” according to Fox 13 Tampa Bay.
Fishback, an investment executive making his first bid for office, has survived a residency challenge in court and recently accused Donalds, without evidence, of being under federal investigation. The Department of Justice denied the claim. Fishback has also argued that turnout at his events undercuts the polling, telling WCTV that 274 people attended one of his gatherings, compared with 62 at a Donalds event held the same night.
Newsweek reached out to Donalds, Collins and Fishback for comment on Monday.
How the Republicans Compare Against Democrats
The Republican primary may be largely decided, but the general election is a different question. Recent polling suggests Donalds would start with an advantage over Democratic frontrunner David Jolly, who left the Republican Party in 2018, while also showing that another Republican could perform better against him.
A Change Research poll in May showed Jolly leading Donalds 46 percent to 42 percent among likely voters. By July, two polls had Donalds ahead. A University of North Florida survey of 848 likely voters conducted July 8 to 17 put Donalds ahead 46 percent to 41 percent. A Targoz Market Research poll of 1,026 likely voters conducted July 20 to 26 found Donalds leading 45 percent to 38 percent, with 17 percent undecided or supporting another candidate.
But the same Targoz survey found Lieutenant Governor Jay Collins performing better against Jolly. In a hypothetical matchup conducted among 1,027 likely voters, Collins led Jolly 44 percent to 39 percent. That gives Republicans a potentially stronger general-election number in Collins, even though he trails Donalds by a wide margin in the primary.
Donalds' support also comes with a potential weakness among independent voters. The Targoz poll found him trailing Jolly by 17 points among independents despite leading overall. Pollsmax's average of 17 surveys had Donalds ahead of Jolly by 4.1 points, 43.5 percent to 39.4 percent, as of mid-August.
The numbers do not necessarily mean Collins would be the stronger November candidate. Donalds has consistently led the Republican primary and has a much larger campaign operation, while polling matchups this far from Election Day can shift significantly. But they give Democrats an opening to argue that the Republican primary front-runner is not necessarily the Republican best positioned for the general election.
Related Story

James Fishback’s Byron Donalds Allegation Is ‘Absolutely False’—DOJ
How Are Florida Democrats Doing? Jolly's Lead Over Jerry Demings
While Republicans have been consumed by a five-way primary, the Democratic side has been comparatively sleepy. Jolly faces Orange County Mayor Jerry Demings in Tuesday's primary and has led every public poll of that race by a wide margin.
A Change Research poll in mid-May had Jolly at 42 percent to Demings' 27 percent among Democratic primary voters. An Emerson College poll in late March showed an even wider gap, with Jolly at 21 percent and Demings at 10 percent, though 53 percent of Democratic voters were undecided at that point, reflecting how much less national and campaign money has flowed into the Democratic primary compared with the Republican one.
Jolly has campaigned for months as if the general election had already begun, naming former U.S. Representative Gwen Graham as his running mate in the spring and building out a statewide operation well ahead of a primary he is not seriously contesting.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Jason Lemon and Sam Wilson.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines