A woman shops for eggs at a Costco store on April 28, 2025 in Alhambra, California. (Photo by Frederic J. BrownAFP via Getty Images)

...

Khaleda Rahman

By Khaleda Rahman

National Correspondent

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A federal judge on Wednesday has rejected a lawsuit from the President Donald Trump’s administration that sought to block California’s animal welfare laws that it argues unconstitutionally sent egg prices soaring.

U.S. District Judge Mark Scarsi, a Trump appointee, ruled on Thursday that the administration did not have legal standing to bring the claim.

Newsweek has contacted the U.S. Department of Justice and California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office for comment via emails sent outside regular business hours. The White House and California governor Gavin Newsom’s office have also been contacted for comment via email.

Read More on News

A woman shops for eggs at a Costco store on April 28, 2025 in Alhambra, California. (Photo by Frederic J. BrownAFP via Getty Images)

...

Why It Matters

The judge’s order delivers a win to California in its ongoing legal sparring with the Trump administration on a wide range of issues, including immigration enforcement.

The Trump administration sued California last year, arguing that state laws and regulations create "unnecessary red tape" on the production of eggs across the country and that the regulation of eggs falls under the federal government’s domain. Two of the laws were approved by voters in 2018 and 2008 and require that all eggs sold in California come from cage-free hens.

Lowering the cost of eggs, which have spiked in recent years as an avian flu outbreak ravaged American flocks, was one of Trump’s key campaign promises in the lead-up to the 2024 election.

What To Know

In his ruling, Scarsi wrote that "unlike with the chickens and eggs at issue here, there is no question that an analysis of standing must come first."

He wrote that the federal government had failed to provide sufficient evidence to support the argument that it had a "personal stake" in the matter.

"Because the United States ‘is not the target of the challenged government action,’ as it does not allege it is a participant in the egg marketplace to which the subject California laws and regulations apply, the federal government’s ability to bring suit is ‘substantially more difficult to establish,’" Scarsi wrote.

He also wrote that siding with the administration could set a dangerous precedent.

"Suppose the executive or the decision-makers at the Department of Justice do not like a state law because it is in tension with their policies," he wrote.

"Without requiring the United States to show some redressable injury, the federal government might initiate a campaign of preemption sits under the aegis of its sovereignty to bring state laws in kine with its own political agenda. The potential for abuse of the federal courts for political purposes is manifest."

But Scarsi’s ruling does not prevent the administration repleading.

"Although Plaintiff put all its eggs in the sovereign-injury theory of standing, other standing theories may be articulable on repleading," he wrote.

What People Are Saying

Representative Jared Huffman, a California Democrat, wrote on X: "I'm not tired of winning! Just kicked Trump's butt in court again—a Trump-appointed judge rejected his latest challenge to the California law I wrote, AB 1437, setting public health and animal welfare standards for egg laying hens. More wins coming!"

After the lawsuit was filed in July, California Governor Gavin Newsom wrote on X: "Trump’s back to his favorite hobby: blaming California for literally everything."

Attorney General Pam Bondi said in a statement when the suit was filed: "Americans across the country have suffered the consequences of liberal policies causing massive inflation for everyday items like eggs. Under President Trump’s leadership, we will use the full extent of federal law to ensure that American families are free from oppressive regulatory burdens and restore American prosperity."

What Happens Next

Scarsi’s ruling gives the Department of Justice 14 days to file an amended complaint.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines