Shane Croucher

By Shane Croucher

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


California may soon get to vote on the notion of independence for the state after CalExit campaigner Marcus Ruiz Evans secured permission from California Secretary of State Shirley Weber to start collecting signatures for a petition.

To have an independence vote included on California's 2028 election ballot, CalExit must gather 546,651 signatures—5 percent of the total votes cast for Governor Gavin Newsom in November 2022—and submit them to county elections officials by July 22, 2025.

The vote, if it happens, would not be legally binding, and there is one huge and perhaps insurmountable hurdle to Californian secession: No such mechanism for states to leave the union currently exists in the U.S. Constitution.

Read More on Politics

California is America's largest state by population (39.4 million) and annual GDP ($4 trillion). It is also a major global hub for tech, science, and entertainment industries. Though strongly Democratic in its political leanings, the Republican footprint is growing.

So, how real is the prospect of Californian independence, and what would its loss mean for the rest of the US? Newsweek put the question to a range of people for their views and insights. Here's what they said.

Elizabeth Bergman: The U.S. Wouldn't Let California Go

The prospect of a peaceful "Californian independence" is not currently real. The key reason being there's no provision for state secession in the U.S. Constitution, only for new state admission (Art. IV, Sec. 3).

However, in future the Constitution technically could be amended (Art. V) to provide for individual state secession, though the reason(s) the rest of the country would be willing to support such a thing seems dubious at best, and anyway ratification (Art. V) would be arduous, long, and unlikely to succeed.

Secession by non-peaceful means is always a possibility, but another Civil War seems out of the realm of the doable for 300 million-plus Americans. Would the other 49 states nuke California to prevent her from leaving the Union?

Which brings up the economic ramifications of California leaving the Union, a negative prospect for the rest of the nation to wit catastrophic and cataclysmic.

California being the 500-pound gorilla of states that she is (the largest population-wise at 39 million plus people) with the fifth largest economy in the world all by herself, and a donor state to the U.S. Federal Treasury (based on 2021 data, Californians pay $5.03 of Federal tax dollars per $1 dollar of support received; 40 states pay less and get more).

So why would the U.S. let California go? It wouldn't. And she can't legally leave anyway. And war is not a thing. So not happening.

Professor Elizabeth Bergman is the former chair of the Department of Political Science at
California State University, East Bay.

California Independence state USA

...

Marcus Ruiz Evans: The Energy Has Shifted in California Since 2016

The prospect for California is more likely today than in 2016.

CalExit exploded into popularity with the election of Donald Trump in 2016. However, at the same time that the CalExit movement was presented as an option to Californians, the Resist movement was also promoted by the media.

Only we at CalExit were telling people in 2016, that Donald Trump does represent America, and that he was voted in by the people of that land.

No one wanted to hear that message in California from 2016 to 2020.

The concept that the Federal system of justice can stop Trump or Trumpism is dead, and the concept that Trump doesn't represent an American that California is tied to, is now dead also, after Trump won the popular vote after committing an insurrection.

No one in California doubts what we said in 2016, now everyone in California is where only CalExit was in 2016.

In Feb 2017, Reuters Ipsos and Stanford University both did a poll of support for CalExit. It showed that a full 32 percent of Californians or roughly 15.5 million people supported immediate separation from America.

What was not reported by the media at that time was both surveys showed an additional 14.5 percent of Californians "didn't know" how they felt about secession.

I started the CalExit movement. I have been doing this for 10 years. In 2016 the energy was fear; people were scared of what Trump might do. In 2024, the energy is pure rage. It is a totally different energy now among the California people than in 2016.

When our movement grew very large after the first appearance of Trump in 2016, we constantly had to talk to members about how we were serious about breaking from America, and we meant it, even if it might be sad to have to end such a long relationship.

No one asks questions about "are we seriously considering a CalExit" at the CalExit meetings now. It is a stark difference eight years has made.

Marc Ruiz Evans is founder of the CalExit campaign.

Gavin Newsom Donald Trump and Melania

...

Matthew Klink: It's So Far-Fetched

Despite California's general disagreement and specific concerns with the second Trump administration from a personality and a policy perspective, there's no credibility to any claim of California seeking independence.

As the fifth largest economy in the world that boasts Silicon Valley, Hollywood, world-class beaches, and ski slopes, California exerts an over-sized impact on the entire nation from a cultural, societal, and economic perspective.

We're a deep blue state, but California has a significant part of the population that votes Republican—almost equal to the number of Texans who voted Republican.

In California, diversity is our strength—diversity in terms of geography, ethnicity, and a host of other factors. America benefits from this diversity. While it may be in vogue to criticize the Golden State, a large part of that criticism is envy.

Secession is so far-fetched for California that it's not even worth considering.

Matthew N. Klink is a partner at California Strategies.

Shaun Bowler: California Is Getting Short-Changed and it's Beginning to Rankle

I have 2 responses here.

1) It probably isn't very likely that California could actually secede. There are too many legal and practical ties. At least for now. At the very least, some more planning needs to be done by state leaders to explore that.

2) That said, it's not surprising there is more talk of independence. Maybe it is time to renegotiate some elements of the federal institutional arrangement because the current ones aren't really working well for the state.

One is the Senate. The disproportionality between us and many other states is extreme. We have a population nearing 40 million and have two Senators. The same number as North Dakota (population about 750,000).

We are a big and important state—but the institutions don't reflect that importance.

Second is that we can see that under-representation at work when it comes to federal government spending. California is a big net contributor to the federal budget. The degree of disproportion is striking.

California gets back about 85c on each dollar it sends to the federal government. On the other hand for a whole bunch of other states—AL, WV say—they get back $2 for every dollar they put in.

That kind of disproportional spending is enabled by the institutional inequality. And that is beginning to rankle. On average, each Californian pays in roughly $2,000 more in federal taxes than they get back.

And now it seems the money we do get back is subject to all kinds of opinions on how we can spend it. With the fires for example, we had the Senator from Alabama telling the state he wanted conditions on how we spend federal money.

The problem isn't just that the Senator himself is a retired college football coach from a state that doesn't have wildfires, it's that it's our money he is putting conditions on. He was talking about not spending our tax dollars on a massive disaster in our state.

There is a growing sense that people in other states are "biting the hand that feeds them"—taking billions of dollars each year in tax revenue from us and yet feeling free to criticize us.

Secession isn't likely to happen soon—but there will be pressure e.g on the Republican caucus from the state (because they are in control) to step up and defend the state's interests more forcefully than they have done so to date.

Shaun Bowler is a professor in the political science department at University of California Riverside.

Richard H. Pildes: No Connection to Reality

I don't comment on issues that have no connection to reality. You can quote me on that.

Richard H. Pildes is Sudler Family Professor of Constitutional Law at NYU School of Law.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines