0.cached.png

0.cached.png

Sarah Schafer

By Sarah Schafer

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Fu Chengyu says Americans won't fear his company, once they get to know it better. Fu is CEO of the China National Offshore Oil Co., which recently placed an unsolicited bid to buy Unocal of California for $18.5 billion. By far the largest Chinese bid for an American company, the move stirred fears in Washington that CNOOC is the spearhead of a Chinese campaign to secure world oil reserves, at U.S. expense. As legislators lobbied a reluctant White House last week to block the deal, Fu compared the backlash to America's misplaced fear of Japan in the 1980s. "Personally I think that the Chinese are being misunderstood all the time," he says. "They have one heart, two eyes. They are not monsters."

Fu insists his company is "quite different" from other Chinese state firms, with more independence from Beijing. One of the big three Chinese oil companies, CNOOC is far more nimble than the other two, both behemoths with tens of thousands of employees in factory campuses that include hospitals and schools. CNOOC is younger (established in 1982 at the beginning of China's market reforms), leaner (only 2,524 employees) and more worldly. Fu received a master's degree from the University of Southern California and speaks the lingo of global financial markets in fluent English. Yet one is left with the impression that he doth protest his independence too much.

Fu insists he is the main force behind the Unocal deal, acting not as a state agent, but purely to "add value for our shareholders." The state, however, owns 70 percent of CNOOC. As head of the corporation's Communist Party chapter, Fu reports to the government. And while he says his financing comes mainly from "commercial banks," CNOOC would borrow most of the $16 billion it needs to complete the deal from its state-run parent company and the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China. Jason Kindopp, an analyst for the Eurasia Group in New York, sees CNOOC at the forefront of Beijing's strategy to secure oil supplies by "building up national-champion oil firms that are capable of competing head to head with Western supermajors."

Read More on News

There is nothing necessarily wrong with that. China is already the second largest oil-consuming nation after the United States. With its economy growing at an average of 9 percent a year, Beijing's push to secure energy supplies makes perfect sense. To many industry officials, who actually owns oil companies is irrelevant. Oil is sold on an efficient and stable global market, in which supplies go to the highest bidder. Hypothetically, in a severe crisis state-owned giants could funnel oil to their domestic customers at low prices, but the gain would be offset by lost sales on the world market.

The response from skeptics is that China is already acting out what Kindopp calls an "aggressive economic nationalism," cutting deals with rogue oil states that others shun, particularly Sudan, and overpaying for oil. Exhibit A is the price CNOOC offered to pay for Unocal: the $18.5 billion bid trumped an earlier one from Chevron of Texas by $2 billion, and was viewed by most analysts as excessive.

Yet China is not the only nation playing hardball in the jittery oil markets. Lin Boqiang, energy economist at the Asian Development Bank, points out that almost half of the major players in the global oil market are at least partly owned by governments. CNOOC "is not even a big firm. It couldn't dominate anyway," Lin says. "The reason it becomes such a big issue is that it comes from China." As a relative newcomer to both the world oil markets and the game of international mergers and acquisitions, "it's just too early to tell what China's true intentions are," says Frank Verrastro, an energy analyst at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington.

For his part, Fu says it's "partly true" that the Unocal deal is about securing oil supplies, but insists China has no intention of hoarding resources. CNOOC's main aim, he says, is "to grow into an international company." Indeed, some analysts see this as simply the latest in a series of attempts by China to raise its global-market cachet by buying famous brands, like Haier's recent offer to buy appliance-maker Maytag.

In the short term, at least, Washington's fears do appear overblown. The basic concern is that CNOOC would divert a major source of oil supplies from the United States to China. But Unocal is only a medium-size oil company, too small to move markets. Only a small fraction of its oil goes to the U.S. market now, and CNOOC pre-emptively promised to maintain that flow, even before the backlash reached full boil. In fact, more than half of Unocal's reserves are in Asia, and are promised in long-term supply contracts, some of which don't expire for decades, mainly to Indonesia and Thailand.

China's foreign policy has focused on courting these neighbors as allies and trading partners. It's unlikely Beijing would risk its emerging status as a diplomatic leader in Asia by breaking the oil contracts. No matter what, U.S. oil supplies are not at risk. Nor is critical U.S. technology, as some in Washington fear. Kindopp points out that CNOOC is about to get equally advanced offshore-drilling technology in a deal with Brazil, rendering this threat moot.

Even if blocking the Unocal deal would serve no strategic purpose, there is no question that CNOOC has become a company to watch as one of the powerful new Chinese players in global markets. It has hired Public Strategies, a Texas company with close ties to the Bush White House, to handle PR in the United States. Fu says he is "comfortable" that a federal review of the deal now underway by an interagency committee on foreign investments in the U.S. will prove "satisfactory" for CNOOC, and that he understands the negative reaction in Washington. "I think that it's natural because they never knew about CNOOC, they never knew about Mr. Fu and they never knew how the Chinese run their businesses," he says. As China's thirst for oil continues to grow, one thing is clear. More and more Americans are going to find out about all three.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines