10

Loading video...

Micah McCartney

By Micah McCartney

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Philippines has released footage showing a Chinese coast guard vessel moving to block a Philippine patrol ship in the disputed South China Sea.

Manila accused the larger Chinese vessel of "dangerous" maneuvers, while Beijing said it was the Philippine ship that risked a collision and accused Manila of hyping up the encounter to malign its neighbor.

Why It Matters

China claims more than 90 percent of the South China Sea, asserting historical rights. These territorial claims overlap with competing ones by the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei and Taiwan.

Read More on World

An international arbitral court issued a 2016 ruling largely dismissing China's claims, citing the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, to which China is a signatory. Beijing dismissed this decision as invalid.

Newsweek reached out to the Chinese Foreign Ministry and Philippine coast guard via email for comment.

Chinese and Philippine Coast Guards Face Off

...

What To Know

Monday morning, Chinese coast guard vessel 21612, the Zhongan, "increased its speed and maneuvered past the port side of the [Philippines'] BRP Cabra, dangerously blocking its navigation route," Philippine coast guard spokesperson Jay Tarrieal wrote on X (formerly Twitter).

The incident occurred southwest of the Philippines' Luzon island and about 40 miles south of Scarborough Shoal, a rich fishing ground over which China seized effective control following a 2012 standoff.

The shoal, hundreds of miles from China's southernmost province of Hainan, has been the site of multiple clashes. Some have seen the Chinese coast guard's forceful behavior, such as ramming and water cannon blasts.

In the video, the Cabra's crew can be heard issuing a radio challenge, informing their Chinese counterparts that they have no jurisdiction to patrol within the Philippine exclusive economic zone. A Chinese coast guard member is heard asserting Beijing's claim over South China Sea islands.

The footage then appears to show the Zhongnan angling toward the bow of the Cabra, though a collision was avoided.

"While coast guards are typically recognized as enforcers of maritime safety and humanitarian organizations, the actions of the People's Republic of China diverge from these norms," Tarriela wrote. "Their illegal patrols jeopardize the lives of fishermen and legitimate law enforcement agencies alike."

China's coast guard issued its account of the incident on Tuesday, alleging that the Cabra "harassed" its ship, which reportedly crossed near the Zhongnan on four occasions.

The Philippines published the "staged photos" to smear China, state media outlet Xinhua quoted the Chinese coast guard as saying Tuesday. The agency added that the Cabra was eventually expelled from the area.

It wasn't the Philippine ship's first encounter with the Zhongnan this month.

The Zhongnan was one of two larger Chinese vessels Manila accused of attempting to ram the 144-foot Cabra in waters west of the Philippines' main island of Luzon last weekend.

Chinese ships have maintained a steady presence in the area since early this year in what analysts describe as a show of force.

Manila said that Philippine National Security Chief Eduardo Año held a phone call with U.S. National Security Advisor Mike Waltz on Friday. The two discussed "recent development in the Philippines-United States alliance," according to an NSA readout.

The two countries share a decades-hold Mutual Defense Treaty, which the Trump and Biden administrations have described as "ironclad."

What People Are Saying

The Philippines' National Security Council said in a statement: "[Añ​o and Waltz] exchanged views on the regional security situation, particularly in the South China Sea, and future bilateral activities to further accelerate the progress in the alliance.

They also underscored the importance of engaging with other like-minded partners to ensure a free, open, and prosperous Indo-Pacific."

What Happens Next

China is unlikely to halt its activities within the Philippine EEZ. According to a January poll, the Marcos administration's pushback enjoys the support of some 84 percent of Filipinos, and it has shown no signs of backing down.

The Philippines and the United States will kick off their largest annual joint military exercise, Balikatan, on April 21. This year, some 14,000 troops will participate. The Philippine armed forces said Tuesday that around 200 Australian forces and observers from the Japan Self-Defense Force are also expected to take part.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines