
...

By Micah McCartney
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The political turmoil following President Yoon Suk Yeol's declaration of martial law Tuesday night, though short-lived, has raised questions about stability in South Korea and its impact on China's aims in the region.
Yoon, now midway through his five-year term, has faced plummeting approval ratings and intense resistance to his agenda from the opposition-controlled National Assembly. In justifying his surprise decision, Yoon accused opposition lawmakers of sympathizing with North Korea andengaging in "anti-state activities" aimed to paralyze the government, claims his opponents dismissed as baseless and authoritarian.
A majority of the legislature quickly voted to overturn the declaration, the first of its kind since 1980, and Yoon announced an end to the measure early on Wednesday. Lawmakers from six opposition parties initiated impeachment proceedings against Yoon, condemning what they called his "attempt at an armed coup."
Read More on World
The upheaval feeds into Beijing's narrative that U.S.-style democracies are inherently chaotic and ineffective. Officials frequently tout their system of centralized governance as stable and efficient, drawing a contrast between Chinese Communist Party rule and Beijing's geopolitical rival.

...
Jenny Town, director of the Stimson Center think tank's Korea Program and North Korea-focused analysis group 38 North, said Yoon's use of martial law for political gain was "an egregious overreach and abuse of power" that damaged South Korea's reputation as a staunch supporter of liberal democratic values.
She also criticized Washington's failure to strongly condemn his actions.
"While calling it a propaganda 'victory' for countries like China and North Korea may be overstated, it certainly can be used. For instance, I can imagine a scenario where Beijing or Pyongyang pose the question of who is really the 'axis of upheaval' in the region," she told Newsweek, employing a term used by foreign policy analysts to describe anti-Western collaboration among China, Russia, North Korea and Iran.
Yoon's foreign policy is a departure from predecessor Moon Jae-in's focus on dialogue and engagement, particularly with North Korea.
Critics have accused him of isolating the country diplomatically and increasing the risk of conflict.
"Under the guise of so-called 'value-based diplomacy,' the administration has antagonized North Korea, China, and Russia while favoring a Japan-centric foreign policy," opposition lawmakers said Wednesday in a statement detailing their reasons for pursuing Yoon's impeachment.They also criticized Yoon's appointments of individuals with pro-Japan views to key government positions.
Yoon's security-driven approach has aligned South Korea more closely with the U.S. on defense matters as well as Japan, whose ties with Seoul have long been testy because of the legacy of Japanese colonial rule and other issues.
His participation in last year's trilateral summit at Camp David with U.S. President Joe Biden and former Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida marked the beginning of a fragile rapprochement. The two neighbors have since taken part in unprecedented joint exercises with the U.S., with an eye toward nuclear-armed North Korea, which has cited the cooperation as a "nuclear alliance" and threat.
Seoul's growing alignment with Washington, which stations nearly 30,000 troops in South Korea, is also a concern for Beijing. China has frequently warned against the formation of regional "blocs" and "cliques" that it views as efforts to contain its rise.
South Korea's engagement with U.S-led coalitions like the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue and its increasing defense cooperation with Japan—both of which Beijing perceives as part of a strategy to contain it—add to these tensions.
The potential unraveling of this framework would strengthen China's hand by enabling it to deal with its neighbors individually.
"Watch for the possibility of South Korea swinging back to a conciliatory approach to Pyongyang and Beijing if Seoul's Democratic Party retakes the presidency," Michael Sobolik, a senior fellow in Indo-Pacific Studies at the American Foreign Policy Council, told Newsweek. "Recent trilateral progress among the U.S., South Korea and Japan could backslide as well."
Newsweek reached out to the Chinese Foreign Ministry and the South Korean Embassy in the U.S. with written requests for comment.
In an editorial released Tuesday, Chinese state-run media outlet the Global Times said the political turbulence would "have little impact on China-South Korea relations" but cited Yoon's pursuit of closer Washington and Tokyo ties as a major source of friction.
"After Yoon Suk Yeol came to power, he was tough on the North, fawning toward Japan, and even following the United States, so the relationship between China and South Korea, which used to be quite good, once hit rock bottom," the author wrote.
Town predicted a snap election in the near future and said Yoon's actions were unlikely to result in democratic backsliding in South Korea, noting that his Cabinet and senior aides have offered to resign and that his People Power Party has strongly condemned the declaration.
However, she said the incident had served as an unwelcome reminder of the country's authoritarian past.
"The temporary martial law stirred up a lot of trauma for many South Koreans who lived through the authoritarian leaders of the past and fought hard against them during the democratization movement."
Update 12/4/24, 11:30 a.m. ET: This article has been updated with a comment from Jenny Town and additional information.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines