10
Loading video...

By Andrea Mohamed and John D. Skrentny
Co-Founder of QuantumBloom; Professor of Sociology at the University of California-San Diego
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
In America's high-stakes competition with China, policymakers are placing significant bets on semiconductors and science. This month marks the two-year anniversary of Congress' rare display of bipartisan cooperation, when the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022 ushered in a new era of federal investment in domestic infrastructure, innovation, and science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) talent. But there's a blind spot—the persistent failure of STEM employers to attract and retain women.
Since the $280 billion law was passed, CHIPS has mobilized $52.7 billion in grants, incentives, and loans, with new agreements being signed regularly. Most of this is directed toward major corporations—including Intel, Micron, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, Samsung, and BAE Systems—to build or expand U.S.-based facilities and capabilities. Additional funds are directed toward R&D projects, public-private partnerships, and STEM education initiatives.
To create quality jobs and a robust and diverse workforce, the Department of Commerce, which oversees CHIPS, issued nearly a hundred pages of workforce guidance to companies seeking federal support. Applicants must submit plans that "demonstrate appropriate investments and commitments to recruit, train, hire, retain, and upskill a skilled and diverse workforce" while adhering to "good jobs principles." This includes removing workplace barriers women experience. But will early-stage plans and corporate promises be enough?
Read More
Our Republic at the Breaking Point | Opinion9 min read

Hollywood Creators Should Embrace AI | Opinion6 min read

Hamas Is Responsible for Rape in Israel—and in Gaza | Opinion3 min read

The industry's track record does not inspire confidence. Despite decades of investments in STEM education and workforce development, women remain badly underrepresented in the fields the CHIPS Act prioritizes. In the semiconductors industry, women hold only 10-15 percent of technical roles.
The Semiconductor Industry Association—and the predominant narrative across STEM—puts accountability on schools and American students for not doing enough to alleviate perceived STEM worker shortages.
Analysis from the Pew Research Center, however, tells a different story—76 percent of women with engineering degrees do not work in engineering; 62 percent of women with computer degrees don't work in computer jobs.
These numbers show that the dearth of women in STEM isn't just an education pipeline problem. Many women are earning STEM degrees, but employers are not attracting them or retaining those who do get hired. By age 30, only 32 percent of women with STEM degrees are in STEM jobs, with 20 percent pivoting out in the very first year.
Across STEM fields, we must address workplace cultures and practices that drive STEM-educated women away. It is utterly inefficient to lure young people into STEM education programs only to have them abandon STEM careers shortly thereafter.
A technology executive recently recounted her daughter's story to us. By seventh grade, Jessica (not her real name) knew she wanted to be an engineer. She went to a STEM-focused high school and participated in summer space camps. In college, she worked on a NASA grant and led the student rocket program. By all accounts, Jessica is a success story of STEM education.

...
Yet, at age 23, Jessica contemplates leaving STEM due to bias, harassment, and a chilly work environment. Male colleagues often take credit for her work. Leaders ignore her in meetings, addressing male colleagues about projects she is overseeing. Once, a new male engineer's changes to Jessica's project got approved by a male leader despite her objections, leading to failure and belated recognition of her expertise. Jessica's education did not prepare her for these workplace realities.
Jessica's story is all too common. Some workplace cultures and recruitment events resemble frat houses more than professional environments. Interview and leadership teams are often devoid of women. Women search in vain for mentors, sponsors, and family-friendly policies. Anxious leaders deny, diminish, or otherwise tolerate harassment and bias.
These factors conspire to make STEM workplaces feel unobtainable or undesirable for many women.
When Jessica and other women leave, not only do they lose out on a potentially stimulating and rewarding career, but employers—and the U.S. as a whole—lose out, too. Excluding a whole category of highly skilled workers means quality, profits, and innovation suffer—and the U.S. loses ground to China in the R&D race.
If policymakers aim to rebuild America's advantage in the global innovation race, it's vital for STEM employers to create working conditions that attract, retain, and advance women. CHIPS workforce guidelines need to be enforced, and employers must respond with evidence-based retention strategies. That includes assigning formal mentors or coaches to women workers, involving company leaders in diversity task forces, instituting pro-family policies such as flexible schedules and equal pay, and monitoring progress in outcomes.
The stakes could not be higher. We cannot keep placing one-sided bets. Investing in STEM education is necessary but not enough to win the game.
Corporations receiving CHIPS taxpayer dollars are being dealt a promising hand and a unique opportunity to lead the way in attracting, retaining, and advancing women. It's time we leverage all available STEM talent to build a more competitive and inclusive future for the semiconductor industry and beyond.
Andrea Mohamed is co-founder of QuantumBloom, which helps employers retain early-career women in STEM.
John D. Skrentny is professor of sociology at the University of California-San Diego and author of Wasted Education: How We Fail Graduates in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (University of Chicago Press).
The views expressed in this article are the writers' own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines