10
Loading video...

By Khaleda Rahman
National Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Democrats' deepening divide over Israel is moving to the center of the fight over who will become the Senate majority leader.
Senator Chris Van Hollen challenges Chuck Schumer in a contest that could reshape the party's position on a contentious foreign policy issue.
Van Hollen has emerged as one of the Senate’s most-outspoken critics of the Israeli government. He has accused Israel of committing genocide in Gaza. Van Hollen has called for restrictions on U.S. military aid to Israel and worked to halt arms shipments to Israel. Israel has repeatedly denied accusations of genocide.
Read More on News
Meanwhile, Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, has a long history of support for Israel. He remains one of Washington’s most-prominent defenders of the U.S.-Israel relationship even as he has criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's handling of the war in Gaza.
Democrats routed their Republican rivals across the map in midterm elections earlier this month, securing at least 55 seats in the Senate. The sweeping wins were fueled by growing frustration over the United States’ relationship with Israel and U.S.-Israeli war with Iran.
Schumer and his allies have argued the wins are an endorsement of the current leadership. Van Hollen and his supporters say they are a call for change.

...
Van Hollen appeared on CNN’s State of the Union on Sunday. He accused Schumer of working with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) and cryptocurrency interests to defeat two candidates who ultimately won their races, Senators-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Troy Jackson of Maine.
But while neither Schumer nor Van Hollen have made Israel central to their campaigns, the divisions within the party have become a focus of the leadership fight. The next Senate majority leader will have considerable influence over the party's position on Israel, including deciding whether to push for votes on legislation to restrict aid to Israel.
Newsweek has contacted Schumer and Van Hollen for comment via email and is awaiting their responses.
Where Chris Van Hollen Stands on Israel
Van Hollen, a progressive, has called for conditions on U.S. military aid to the Israelis. He backed resolutions to block arms sales to Israel.
Van Hollen has consistently argued that supporting Israel's defense does not require giving its government what he described as a "blank check."
"My position is that American taxpayers should not be providing a blank check to the government of Israel or any government, regardless of their conduct," he said on Fox News. He has pointed specifically to violence involving Israeli settlers in the West Bank. Van Hollen has said that U.S. money should not support such conduct.
Earlier this month, he led a group of 12 senators in calling on congressional leaders to strip provisions from the Fiscal Year 2027 National Defense Authorization Act that would require expanded defense cooperation and intelligence sharing with Israel.
The lawmakers argued the measures would "further entrench concerning aspects of the U.S.-Israel defense and intelligence relationship at a time when the Israeli government’s actions are increasingly undermining U.S. interests and values."
Van Hollen was also among the Democratic senators most willing to pressure former Democratic President Joe Biden’s administration over Israel’s actions in Gaza.
In March 2024, Van Hollen, along with several other senators, urged Biden to enforce Section 620I of the Foreign Assistance Act. The group said that Israel should face consequences including the loss of U.S. military assistance, if it continued restricting deliveries of humanitarian assistance into Gaza.
In November 2024, Van Hollen backed resolutions seeking to block some offensive weapons sales while continuing to support Israel's right to defend itself and U.S. transfers of defensive systems, including Iron Dome.
And in November last year, Van Hollen, with Senator Jeff Merkley, authored a report that said Israel is implementing a "plan to ethnically cleanse Gaza of Palestinians." It added that "America is complicit."
Chuck Schumer Has Long Supported Israel
Schumer's support for Israel has been a defining feature of his decades in office.
The highest-ranking Jewish elected official in U.S history, Schumer has consistently pledged to preserve and expand U.S. military and security assistance to Israel.
Schumer drew criticism from progressive Democrats earlier this year after saying that one of his most-important jobs as Senate minority leader is to fight for aid for Israel.
"I have many jobs as leader…and one is to fight for aid to Israel, all the aid that Israel needs," he said at a gathering of Jewish leaders in February. This is according to a video posted on social media by The Forward reporter Jacob Kornbluh.
However, Schumer has criticized Netanyahu and his handling of the war in Gaza. In a speech in March 2024, Schumer named him as one of the major obstacles to peace and called on Israel to hold new elections.
In those remarks, he added that, as the first Jewish Senate majority leader, he felt a responsibility to act as "a guardian of the People of Israel."

...
Who Are Democratic Senators Backing?
Schumer remains the favorite and has said he has the votes to win.
"I welcome any discussion about the future of our caucus and the important work ahead," he wrote on X last week. "I’m proud of what we’ve accomplished together—55 seats and counting is an amazing result—and I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader."
A tally compiled by The 29th Vote, a nonpartisan vote-tracking group, said Schumer has the backing of at least 13 Democratic senators. These include Kirsten Gillibrand, Sheldon Whitehouse and John Fetterman. Fetterman suggested that Van Hollen's election could become a breaking point in his relationship with the Democratic Party.
Van Hollen has at least five votes, according to the tracker. However, five others have opposed Schumer but not revealed who they would support.
Van Hollen said on Sunday that the race is wide-open and that he has the support of "about 15 and growing."
His public supporters include Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders, Oregon Senator Jeff Merkley, Minnesota Senator-elect Peggy Flanagan and Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed. He is one of several Democrats critical of Israel’s war in Gaza who won their races in the midterms.
In a post on X, Sanders said the election is a "debate about the future of the Democratic Party."
"The election for Democratic Senate Leader will determine whether or not we continue to tinker around the edges and maintain status quo policies, or whether we finally have the courage to take on enormously powerful special interests and address the unprecedented crises that we face," Sanders wrote.
That includes the "need to fundamentally rethink our foreign policy including continued military funding to the extremist government in Israel."
When Will Democrats Choose Their Senate Majority Leader?
The vote for leader will be held behind closed doors and on a secret ballot on December 1.
A simple majority of the caucus is required to win.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Cannon and James Debens
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines