Clare Crawley is The Oldest 'Bachelorette' Ever and Fans Are Here For It

ABC announced Clare Crawley will return to the Bachelor franchise as The Bachelorette on Monday, and most fans are filled with glee. Crawley, who is 38, marks the end of the influencer era on the reality TV series, according to some. Twitter was flooded with comments praising Crawley's age and expertise on the series.

Bachelor Nation has participated in an ongoing joke about younger women on the series, who graduate from the show with instant brand partnerships and internet fame. The Bachelor and its spinoffs have undeniably become a platform for self-marketing—see Jed Wyatt winning Hannah Brown's season of The Bachelorette after admitting he'd only signed up to further his music career. Crawley's leadership could seemingly end, or at least curve, the constant pull toward influencer-driven casting.

Clare as The Bachelorette coming in to absolute OBLITERATE these 22 year old Instagram influencers. What a legendary move. #TheBachelorette

— Sarah Wainschel 💫 (@Swainsch) March 2, 2020

Crawley appeared on Juan Pablo Galavais' season of The Bachelor in 2014. She also attended Seasons 1 and 2 of Bachelor In Paradise, and was even engaged on Bachelor Winter Games in 2018. The relationship with Benoit Beausejour-Savard ended two months after their post-show engagement, though.

Clare Crawley
Reality TV Personality Clare Crawley attends ABC's "The Bachelor" season 19 premiere at Line 204 East Stages on January 5, 2015, in Hollywood, California. Photo by Paul Archuleta/FilmMagic/Getty

Twitter conversations praised Crawley's age above all else. Even before the official announcement on Good Morning America Monday morning, Bachelor fans were intrigued by the idea of Crawley in charge.

Honestly Clare as bachelorette would be refreshing in the age of 23 year old influencers.

— Why-it (@WStrazz) February 27, 2020

Guessing not happening, but If these @Clare_Crawley for bachelorette rumors have any truth. I’m here for it.

— Nick Viall (@viallnicholas28) February 27, 2020

I am HERE for a 39 year old Bachelorette! Knew the pick was going to be unconventional since she is getting the early “Rachel release” but mostly just excited for @Clare_Crawley!!!!

— Ashley Spivey (@AshleySpivey) February 29, 2020

A 38 YEAR OLD WOMAN is allegedly cast as the next #Bachelorette (Clare Crawley from Juan Pablo's season). This is a show I will ACTUALLY be invested in. Kudos to Bachelor producers if this is true. What do you guys think???

— JOSLYN DAVIS (@JoslynDavis) February 29, 2020

Special thanks to the petty trash women of Peter’s season for being so awful that they had to go looking to previous seasons for someone worthy of being the Bachelorette. Finally Clare gets what she deserved years ago! 👑🎉🎉🍾 #thebachelorette #BachelorNation #thebachelor

— EvaMarie Lola (@evamarielola) February 29, 2020

The conversations also surrounded contestants on Peter Weber's season who were passed over for the opportunity. Fans remarked that the maturity level in Weber's season was lacking. This was even stated by some of the women inside the series, like Kelley Flanagan who told Weber his relationships don't need to be so difficult.

Many of the women on Weber's season were models, influencers and former pageant queens. Crawley isn't exactly the opposite, though. The Sacramento hairdresser is only mildly active on Instagram but has posted sponsored content in the past for things like personalized vitamins and dog treats.

Still, it appears Crawley's intentions may be pure compared to the handful of contestants in Bachelor history who have clearly, immediately profited from their appearances on the show.

Crawley's casting was generally approved of, but of course some didn't agree. A few pointed to Crawley's past on the show, which showed a risque intimate moment between her and Galavais. Others seemed to want someone from Weber's season to take over, or to see a person of color in the role. The only black lead has been Rachel Lindsay, who was Bachelorette in 2017.

Since when does being in your 20s mean you’re not ready for love? I truly get angry at people saying that young bachelorette contestants “aren’t ready for marriage”
Clare being 38 doesn’t make her anymore ready than Hannah Ann at 23. Love can happen at any time. #TheBachelorette

— Gabby Sotola (@gabbysotola) March 2, 2020

This is a problem. Out of 15 seasons of the Bachelorette, and 22 seasons of the Bachelor, there’s only been 1 person of color that had the main lead role. This is a misrepresentation of our country. I’m just so disappointed in ABC. #BachelorNation #bachelorette

— Cristian Sanchez (@perspectivebycs) March 2, 2020

literally who asked for clare from 6 years ago to be the bachelorette when you had tayshia from coltons season??

— anita🧃 (@ancsi_baba) March 2, 2020