Cold Plunge

...

Lucy Notarantonio

By Lucy Notarantonio

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


After getting hot and sweaty during a workout, many now opt to take a cold plunge—typically between 50–60 degrees Fahrenheit (10–15 Celsius)—in hopes of speeding up muscle recovery and easing post-exercise soreness.

However, a new study has cast doubt on whether either of these methods actually help women recover faster following intense physical activity.

In a randomized clinical trial published in the journal PLOS ONE, researchers at the University of Applied Sciences and Arts of Southern Switzerland found that neither cold- nor hot-water immersion significantly improved recovery from muscle damage in 30 female participants.

Read More on Wellness & Fitness

The study, led by exercise scientist Vanessa Wellauer, examined how women's muscles recover after intense physical exertion and whether water therapy makes any meaningful difference.

Cold Plunge

...

Participants were asked to complete five sets of 20 drop-jumps from a 0.6-meter box—a strenuous workout designed to induce muscle damage.

Following the exercise, each woman was randomly assigned to either cold-water immersion, hot-water immersion or no immersion at all.

Those in the immersion groups submerged themselves up to the breastbone for 10 minutes, first immediately post-exercise and then again two hours later.

Pros and Cons of Cold Plunges

Dr. Farah Ahmad, a general practitioner, spoke to Newsweek about the potential benefits and risks of cold plunges—a wellness trend that has swept through the fitness industry and has driven the global cold plunge tub market to an estimated value of $318.63 million in 2023, according to Grand View Research.

She said that immersing yourself into freezing water for a short while may enhance your mood and improve mental clarity, along with improving your metabolic health.

Ahmad said: "Frequent cold exposure might activate brown adipose tissue, which plays a role in thermogenesis and energy expenditure. This activation could potentially improve insulin sensitivity and aid in weight management."

Ahmad, who works at The London General Practice, emphasized the potential risks too.

"Sudden immersion in cold water can cause rapid heart rate increases and elevated blood pressure," she said. "For individuals with heart conditions, this stress may lead to abnormal heart rhythms or even cardiac arrest."

"Prolonged exposure to cold water can significantly lower core body temperature, leading to hypothermia," she said, adding the risk of respiratory complications.

"The initial shock of cold water can induce hyperventilation, which may be dangerous for individuals with respiratory conditions like asthma."

Additionally, Ahmad warned of potential physical harm to the skin and nerves.

"Prolonged exposure to cold can result in frostbite or nerve damage, particularly in extremities. It's crucial to monitor exposure time and ensure proper protection."

But the researchers' findings suggest that the perceived benefits might not hold up—at least not for women.

"While we observed some physiological differences between the groups, such as body temperature changes and muscle oxygen levels, these didn't translate into better muscle recovery," the researchers wrote.

Measuring the Aftermath

The team tracked several markers of recovery over 72 hours following the workout, including muscle soreness ratings, knee muscle swelling, levels of creatine kinase (a marker of muscle damage), and muscle strength via isometric contraction tests.

None of these metrics showed significant differences between the groups. In other words, whether participants plunged into freezing water, soaked in warmth or did neither, their muscles recovered at roughly the same rate.

This trial is notable for being among the few to directly compare hot and cold immersion strategies in female participants—a demographic often underrepresented in sports science research.

Given the complex physiological factors at play, the authors suggest more targeted studies are needed to determine if and how recovery methods might need to be tailored to women's unique responses to exercise.

What's Next?

The findings raise highlight complex links between physiological responses and muscle recovery outcomes for women.

While the chill of an ice bath may feel refreshing, or a soak in hot water might offer psychological comfort, this study suggests the physical benefits for muscle recovery could be minimal.

Future research could explore real-world training conditions, different athletic populations, or longer immersion durations to help clarify the role, if any, of these therapies.

5 Recovery Tips for Women

For now, GP Dr. Ravina Bhanot—who specializes in women's health and is the founder of London-based Zonas Fertility—has the following tips for women who may want to try something other than cold plunges to aid exercise recovery:

Do you have a tip on a science story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have a question about ice baths? Let us know via science@newsweek.com.

Reference

Wellauer, V., Clijsen, R., Bianchi, G., Riggi, E., & Hohenauer, E. (2025). No acceleration of recovery from exercise-induced muscle damage after cold or hot water immersion in women: A randomised controlled trial. PLOS ONE, 20(5). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0322416

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines