Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


On Wednesday morning in Minneapolis, an ICE agent shot and killed 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good, a U.S. citizen and who was behind the wheel of her Honda Pilot. Numerous videos are circulating online, reportedly showing the incident from multiple angles, but nevertheless the episode has become a familiar Rorschach test for a highly polarized America: President Donald Trump is calling it "self-defense"; New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and other Democrats are calling it "murder." The shooting occurred just blocks from where George Floyd was filmed dying in 2020.

Kristi Noem ⬇

During her first press conference in Texas soon after the shooting, the Homeland Security Secretary claimed the incident was "an act of domestic terrorism" after ICE officers "got stuck in the snow," adding, "They were attempting to push out their vehicle, and a woman attacked them, and those surrounding them, and attempted to run them over." Videos widely circulated on social media immediately contradicted both claims, making her initial story look as fake as the camouflage and sandbag props decorating the lectern she was delivering it from.

Read More on Opinion

Gregory Bovino ⬆

By the time Noem got to Minneapolis for her second press conference, this time vowing federal prosecutions for using vehicles as weapons, the Border Patrol commander was standing alongside her. After a federal judge found he lied about using tear gas in his Chicago operation, he finally got to take a break from being the craziest, most ruthless face of Trump’s immigration crackdown.

Representative James Comer ⬇

While the shooting took place on Wednesday morning, the House Oversight Chairman was holding hearings on Republicans' best hit during the immigration debate: allegations of billions of welfare fraud by Somalis in Minnesota. By afternoon, the only thing anyone in Minnesota was talking about was the ICE shooting. Nothing kills a carefully choreographed scandal like an actual shooting.

Governor Tim Walz ⬆

Comer and other Republicans had drawn political blood with the scandal, calling the Minnesota governor "asleep at the wheel," humiliating Kamala Harris’s former running mate into dropping his bid for re-election. The scandal is now pushed off the front page, and he’s vowing "a full, fair, and expeditious investigation."

Senator Amy Klobuchar ⬆

A likely replacement for Walz on the Minnesota governor’s ticket, she issued a statement that began "I am praying for the family and loved ones of the woman who was shot and killed" and ended without scoring political points with attacks on ICE or federal agents. In 2026, that passes for statesmanship.

'Abolish ICE' ⬆

A fringe slogan once as politically toxic as "defund the police." Now former Bush administration official and veteran conservative commentator Bill Kristol is saying it. The shooting accomplished what a thousand family separation protests that birthed the slogan in Trump’s first term couldn't—making a far-leftist issue respectable in neoconservative circles.


Originally a staple of Newsweek's print edition, Conventional Wisdom used arrows to track whose stock was rising or falling in the political circus. We're reviving it in the digital age because the problem it lampooned—hyperbole and partisan certainty masquerading as insight—has only intensified.

CW assigns arrows—up, down, or sideways—to the figures and forces shaping current events. The arrows don't predict the future or claim special insight. They capture the prevailing winds of the moment, uncluttered by tribal howling. In an era when partisan media reinforces rather than questions assumptions, CW operates from the center—skeptical of left and right alike, committed to puncturing inflated reputations and recognizing overlooked truths.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines