10

Loading video...

John Davenport

By John Davenport

Professor of Philosophy, Fordham University

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


It is said that greed and avarice are the oldest human sins. That's wrong. The oldest vice, which is the root of so many others, is the cowardice involved in lying to ourselves, refusing to face difficult truths—and pressuring others to play along. Americans saw the corrosive effects of this problem writ large as the Big Lie about the 2020 election spread and became a test of loyalty among many families, friends, and colleagues.

Now a new ideological distortion is at work. It started after the October 2023 attacks in which Hamas and associated fighters butchered almost 1,200 innocent Israeli civilians in southern Israel. Time-honored principles dictated that Israel had a right to remove this mortal threat from its border. Then came the lie: namely that a just war goal is all that matters. In particular, the new lie says, it does not matter that nearly 57,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza and over 120,000 maimed or injured by Israel's chosen methods of fighting Hamas. According to this lie, if anyone protests Israel's indiscriminate response to Hamas fighters within the general population, that must be because of the protester's antisemitic bigotries.

A young pediatric patient who was evacuated

...

Read More on Opinion

It is easy to succumb to this trickery when real antisemitism—hatred of Jewish people or Judaism as such—is motivating more attacks. The horrendous June 1 terror attack on a Boulder rally for Israeli hostages is only the latest in a rising tide of anti-Jewish violence that all Americans should abhor. Jewish officials and events need and deserve more protection.

But these condemnations that we repeat after each attack do nothing to stop the daily atrocities in Gaza that are the main cause of rising terrorism on U.S. soil. We could soon face train and bus bombings, vehicle rammings, more mass shootings at college campuses and at synagogues, further Molotov cocktail attacks, repeated arson, and more. American Jews in particular may suffer for the global perception that the United States is behind the Netanyahu government's seemingly endless willingness to kill scores of Palestinian civilians at a time in Gaza and the West Bank for tiny military advantages, and to destroy their buildings and towns in orgies of mass collective punishment.

In this situation, simply hardening defenses at home and deporting college students who call out mass murder—including even those who defend Jewish student peers—is very unlikely to prevent a coming surge in terrorism on our shores. Pressuring people to condone Israel's colossal tally of war crimes by threatening them with accusations of antisemitism only cheapens the meaning of essential terms and blurs vital distinctions, just as during the days when young people protesting the use of napalm in Vietnam were called "unpatriotic" or "traitors."

Similarly, refusing to discuss Gazans' need for a peaceful Palestinian state by branding this too as antisemitic only angers people who recognize the gaslighting: they see the scenes of starving Gazans being buried in rubble, shot at aid distribution sites, and burnt by bombs dropped on refugee camps. Every month, more and more young Americans see the trend and extrapolate to an end-point in which most Gazans are dead, in Israeli prisons, or forced out of their homeland. And they know that atrocities committed in Israel's prisoner of war facilities make the crimes that U.S. soldiers committed at Abu Ghraib in Iraq look like child's play.

The longer this lie goes on, the more strained it becomes to insist that the valid goal of ousting Hamas justifies Israel's truly criminal methods of fighting and its appalling refusal even to start planning for Gaza's postwar survival.

To turn this catastrophe around, the Trump administration, our Middle East partners, and any European allies that we still have must create a plan to install a caretaker government and international security force into Gaza so that Israel can withdraw without Hamas reassuming control. They must insist on rebuilding, paid for primarily by Israel, given that nearly everything in Gaza is now in ruins. The plan must credibly build toward a day when a Palestinian state will be established. The plan must also force Israel to stop its bulldozing of buildings, seizure of Palestinian lands, and creation of ever-more Jewish settlements in the West Bank—and pay full reparations for all of these enormous wrongs.

And no, none of that is antisemitic. On the contrary, it is basic decency. Misconstruing such imperatives as taboo expressions of ethnic hatred will only encourage the kind of cognitive dissonance on which totalitarian regimes thrive.

If the U.S. fails to stop Israel's total war on Palestinians and start putting Gaza on a path toward restoration, Americans will pay enormous costs. A quarter of humanity is Muslim; alienating them all to indulge a regime in Jerusalem drunk on revenge is not a smart policy. It will drive Muslim-majority nations into the hands of Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, and other totalitarian dictators, and teach the Global South that our human rights standards are only for show. At home, we will get more anti-Jewish terrorism, followed by rising hatred of immigrants from the Middle East.

And finally, there is the psycho-spiritual price: we lie to ourselves because facing the truth about Israel's crimes against humanity is just too socially painful. Like the Big Lie of November 2020, this new Great Lie about Gaza can only bring moral corruption, internal strife, and suffering to the United States.

John Davenport is professor of philosophy and director of peace and justice studies at Fordham University.

The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines