10
Loading video...

By Joe Edwards
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A proposal to prioritize Lake Mead over Lake Powell is drawing renewed attention after both reservoirs reached record lows and negotiations over the Colorado River’s long-term management failed to produce an agreement among the seven states that depend on its resources.
Why the Colorado River Matters
America's two largest reservoirs plunged to record lows this year amid a multidecadal drought across the Colorado River Basin and a record-low snowpack during the winter of 2025-26.
Read More on Environment
As of Wednesday, Lakes Mead and Powell were each just 27 percent full, according to data from the Bureau of Reclamation, which manages the reservoirs.
The Colorado River's dams and reservoirs help supply water and power to millions of Americans across Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming. Experts and officials have long been sounding the alarm that declining water levels are threatening those vital deliveries.
A recent report from the U.S. Energy Information Administration also found that Southwest hydropower generation hit a record low this summer amid declining water levels in the reservoirs. The report said that, at the end of September, Powell stood just 28 feet above minimum power pool—the elevation needed to generate electricity at Glen Canyon Dam.

...
The “Fill Mead First” proposal would make Mead the river’s primary storage reservoir and use Powell only when Mead is full, a plan that would ultimately require new tunnels to route the Colorado River around Glen Canyon Dam, according to the Glen Canyon Institute, a nonprofit that advocates restoring Glen Canyon and a free-flowing Colorado River.
“We believe designating Mead as the primary storage facility for the Upper and Lower Basin would go a long way toward saving Lake Mead. But, until consumptive use is reduced enough to come into balance with the river's actual supply, all system storage will continue to decline,” Eric Balken, the institute’s executive director, told Newsweek.
“In other words, moving the water currently in Powell to Mead would basically double its storage. But, if the supply and demand imbalance persists, then Mead would still be at risk.”
Reclamation adopted this latter approach in the new operating plans for Lake Powell and Lake Mead that it released late this summer, Rosenberg said.
Risks of Prioritizing One Reservoir
“Lake Powell and Lake Mead are both at low elevations,” David Rosenberg, a professor in the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Utah Water Research Lab at Utah State University, told Newsweek. “In this new era of low reservoir storage and low river flow, prioritizing storage in one reservoir will increase risk for the other reservoir.”
Rosenberg suggested that a more viable strategy would be to define catastrophic water levels for each reservoir and maintain buffer volumes to reduce the risk of losing water deliveries, hydropower, infrastructure or native fish populations.
“Reclamation adopted this latter approach in the new operating plans for Lake Powell and Lake Mead they released towards the end of the summer,” Rosenberg said.
“Maintaining buffer volumes above catastrophic elevations generates continuing benefits for hydropower, infrastructure, and capacity to deliver water whereas, if released, buffer water can only be consumed once by downstream users,” he added.
The proposal could also produce complicated environmental consequences downstream of Glen Canyon Dam.
Jack Schmidt, director of the Center for Colorado River Studies at Utah State University, told Yale Environment 360 that draining Powell could have only partly predictable consequences for river ecosystems below Glen Canyon Dam, including in the Grand Canyon.
“Suddenly the river would have great fluctuations. The river would have much more sediment. The river would be much more turbid,” he said, adding: “It just keeps getting more complicated.”
While Schmidt emphasized the unpredictable ecological consequences, Balken told Newsweek that the aridification of the Southwest and its reservoirs is already transforming ecosystems, hydropower and communities across the entire Colorado River Basin.
“By consolidating what water is left in Mead, we may be able to save that reservoir. Allowing for the full restoration of the Colorado River through Glen Canyon and Grand Canyon would create new economic and environmental opportunities that would be better than the alternative of two massive reservoirs hovering near dead pool,” he said.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: John Fitzpatrick and Rhian Morgan.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines