
...

By Khaleda Rahman
National Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
If the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent who shot a woman in Minneapolis on Wednesday is charged with a crime, the case would hinge on whether the shooting was legally justified as self-defense, legal experts told Newsweek.
The case "comes down entirely to self-defense, or lack thereof," said Neama Rahmani, a former federal prosecutor and the president of West Coast Trial Lawyers.
"Law enforcement is held to the same standard as civilians. They can use deadly force only when they or others are at imminent risk of death or serious bodily injury," he added. Rahmani said that based on the videos he reviewed, he did not believe deadly force was legally justified in the case.
Read More on News
Renee Nicole Good, a 37-year-old mother and U.S. citizen, was fatally shot after being approached by a group of ICE agents in Minneapolis on Wednesday. Federal officials have not named the officer who shot Good, but court documents reviewed by Newsweek identified the agent as Jonathan Ross.

...
The Context
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and other Trump administration officials have defended the agent, saying he followed his training and shot Good after he believed she was trying to run him or other agents over with her vehicle.
Videos of the shooting have raised questions about whether it was a case of self-defense. State and local officials have rejected the Trump administration's characterization, with Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey saying video recordings show the self-defense argument is "garbage."
The shooting has prompted calls for Ross to face criminal charges. Vice President JD Vance has said the agent has "absolute immunity," an assessment that legal experts have rejected.
On Thursday, the FBI told Minnesota officials they would not be allowed to participate in the investigation or review key evidence in the shooting, meaning the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension would not have access to evidence to investigate the matter and provide its findings to local prosecutors who could determine whether the agent should face charges. Local prosecutors said they have jurisdiction in the case and are evaluating their legal options.
What To Know
Emmanuel Mauleón, an associate professor of law at the University of Minnesota, told Newsweek that based on what had been reported and videos of the shooting, there was "more than enough evidence to support prosecution and to allow a jury to evaluate criminal liability" in the case.
He said: "The governing question is whether the use of deadly force was objectively reasonable in light of the facts confronting the officer at the moment force was used, including whether there was probable cause to believe the person posed an immediate threat of serious physical harm.
"That is to say, the law asks whether a reasonable officer had a concrete, immediate reason to use deadly force, not whether the officer later claims fear."
Rahmani said reviewing the agent's body camera footage would be crucial evidence in the case.
"The question is, was Good attempting to run over the agent and using her vehicle as a deadly weapon? I've watched the angle of the video from the rear of the woman's vehicle and the one from the front distance."
The agent's body camera footage would be the "most important angle," he said. "But based on these videos alone, I do not think the ICE agent was justified in firing his weapon. The women reversed, then turned all the way to the right. Those are two very important facts that make it appear that she was attempting to flee and not run over the agent."
Mauleón said that because Ross is a federal agent, he will benefit from "additional layers of institutional and legal insulation that can make accountability—both criminal and civil—harder to achieve."
"Federal status can raise barriers to investigation and prosecution even when the underlying conduct warrants scrutiny," he said.
The Department of Justice has pushed back against state efforts to arrest or prosecute federal agents. In October, Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche wrote to California officials to say arrests of federal officers performing their duties would be "illegal and futile," citing the Constitution's Supremacy Clause and federal law.
But legal experts have said that while those protections are significant, the Supremacy Clause does not provide blanket immunity, and federal agents can still face criminal liability if prosecutors determine they acted unlawfully or outside their authority.
Rahmani said the DOJ would not "prosecute the ICE agent in today's political climate," but that prosecutors could seek to charge him with murder or manslaughter under Minnesota law. He added that Good's family could also file a civil lawsuit.
Mauleón expressed concern about federal officials moving to "fix the narrative and narrow the investigation."
He also noted the parallels to the killing of George Floyd by then-Minneapolis officer Derek Chauvin.
"In George Floyd's case, the Minneapolis Police Department's initial statement described a man who died after suffering a medical incident following police custody," he said. "Had it not been for bystander video, his murder likely would have gone under the radar. That history is precisely why premature official narratives should be treated with skepticism, and why Minnesota residents are particularly attuned to that problem."
He added: "Accountability depends on investigators who are not politically invested in defending the officer or the agency involved. When federal authorities centralize control, exclude state participation, and publicly define the meaning of an event before the investigation has run its course, they risk repeating the very failures that Minneapolis knows all too well."
What People Are Saying
Minnesota Governor Tim Walz demanded that state investigators be given a role, telling reporters at a news conference on Thursday: "It feels very, very difficult that we will get a fair outcome. And I say that only because people in positions of power have already passed judgment—from the president to the vice president to Kristi Noem—have stood and told you things that are verifiably false, verifiably inaccurate."
He added: "I will continue to press that we be part of the investigation, that we do the investigation so that Minnesotans can trust what the outcome is."
Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty said in a statement: "After the FBI rescinded its cooperation agreement with the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, our office immediately began exploring all options to ensure a state level investigation can continue.
"If the FBI is the sole investigative agency, the State will not receive the investigative findings, and our community may never learn about its contents. We are speaking to our local partners on paths forward that will allow us to review the investigation and be transparent in our decision making."
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem told reporters at a press conference on Thursday: "They [Minnesota authorities] have not been cut out. They don't have any jurisdiction in this investigation."
Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey wrote on X: "Let's call a spade a spade: Kristi Noem watched the videos and doesn't want an impartial investigation because she knows her narrative about domestic terrorism is bull****."
Vice President JD Vance said during a news briefing on Thursday: "The precedent here is very simple. You have a federal law enforcement official engaging in federal law enforcement action. That's a federal issue. That guy is protected by absolute immunity. He was doing his job.
"The idea that Tim Walz and a bunch of radicals in Minneapolis are going to go after and make this guy's life miserable because he was doing the job that he was asked to do is preposterous."
What Happens Next
It is too soon to know whether the ICE agent who fatally shot Good will face criminal charges.
The investigation by the FBI is ongoing, and Minnesota officials are continuing to demand the state be allowed to investigate the shooting.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines