COVID Live Updates: FDA Committee Disagrees Over Booster Shots For All Adults

Live Updates

A Food and Drug Administration (FDA) advisory panel voted unanimously in favor of the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine booster dose Thursday.

Despite all 19 members of the Vaccine and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee voting "yes" after the lengthy presentation, many members still had concerns over the data they saw from Moderna and the Israel Health Ministry.

The committee will hold a similar hearing Friday to review data on the Johnson & Johson booster dose.

The decision is seen as crucial for both companies and Biden administration's vaccine rollout program, but scientific data, as ever in politics, is only one part of the story and can be read in a number of ways. Studies so far suggest that mixing and matching boosters will work at least as well and could be far better for single-shot J&J recipients - but the FDA panel remains split on the decision.

The Live updates for this blog have ended.

Committee members discuss booster shots for all adults

Following the Moderna booster vote, the FDA advisory committee discussed whether everyone over 18 should receive a third COVID-19 vaccine dose.

Many members disagreed with this notion, saying booster shots were unnecessary in healthy young people.

"I worry about this broad use of boosters," Dr. Paul Offit said. He said he is impressed with continued protection from the first two doses and fears a push for a booster shot will "send the wrong message" to people that they are not protected without three doses.

"The people who are in the ICU aren't there because they haven't gotten a third dose," Offit said. "They are there because they haven't gotten any dose."

Dr. Michael Kurilla said younger people seem to be responding well to the first two doses and he doesn't see a need to start a campaign for boosters for everyone who has ever been vaccinated.

But Dr. Peter Marks, the director of the FDA's Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research, said the committee has to think ahead as COVID-19 variants continue to spread.

"We don't know what we don't know," he said.

Marks said winter could be worse, bringing another variant of concern.

"We can't look at the current pandemic curve and call it a day," he added.

FDA committee shows Friday's voting questions

During the meeting on a third Moderna dose, the FDA advisory committee accidentally showed the voting question for tomorrow's discussion on the Johnson & Johnson booster vaccine.

The hearing Thursday was riddled with technical glitches and audio issues.

Friday, the committee will decide if "available data supports the safety and effectiveness of Janssen COVID-19 vaccine for use under EUA [emergency use authorization] as a booster dose in individuals 18 years and older at least two months after a single dose primary vaccination."

If yes, they will decide if "available data supports that an interval of at least six months between a single primary dose and a booster dose may result in a more robust booster response."

If no, they will decide if "available data supports the safety and effectiveness of Janseen COVID-19 vaccine for use under EUA as a booster dose in individuals 18 years and older at least six months after a single dose primary vaccination."

In a technical glitch, FDA shows the voting question for tomorrow's advisory committee when they meet to discuss a J&J booster ...

— Andrew Dunn (@AndrewE_Dunn) October 14, 2021

Next steps for booster shot approval

The FDA advisory committee voted in favor of offering Moderna's COVID-19 booster shot under emergency use authorization.

The booster would be administered six months after the completion of the primary series for:

  • Individuals 65 years of age or older
  • Individuals 18 to 64 years of age at high risk of severe COVID-19
  • Individuals 18 to 64 years of age who are put at a higher risk of severe COVID-19 due to their occupation

The committee will decide on Johnson & Johnson's booster dose Friday.

With the committee's recommendation, the FDA will make its final decision on whether to approve the vaccine. Then, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) will meet to discuss their recommendation for the vaccines. After that, the CDC Director has the final signoff.

The CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices is already set to meet to discuss boosters on October 20 and 21.

Committee members express concerns about data, despite "yes" votes

The FDA's Vaccine and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee member Dr. Patrick Moore explained why he voted "yes" on the Moderna booster shot, despite his concerns with the data presented.

He said "it is clear" he has "real issues with this vote" and said he voted yes based on "gut feeling" rather than "truly serious data."

Many committee members expressed concerns about the data presented by Moderna and Israeli health officials when discussing the voting question.

Such concerns included the half doses of the Moderna booster, the relevance of the data from Israel for the American population and the risk for people at a greater risk of contracting COVID-19 because of their occupation.

FDA committee votes in favor of Moderna booster shot

The FDA's advisory committee votes in favor of the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine booster shot.

It was a unanimous 19-0 vote to back Moderna's third dose.

White House eyes Dr. Robert Califf to head the FDA

The Biden administration is considering former Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Dr. Robert Califf to lead the agency again, according to a report from the Washington Post.

Califf served as the FDA's deputy commissioner for medical products and tobacco from February 2016 to February 2017.

While Califf is a contender, a final decision has yet to be made.

"There has not been a decision made for the FDA commissioner and we remain grateful to the strong acting leadership at the FDA," a White House official told CNN Thursday.

Dr. Janet Wodcock has served as the acting FDA commissioner for the past nine months. She cannot legally stay on as the acting head of the FDA past November 15 unless a permanent commissioner has been nominated.

Moderna promises to donate1 billion vaccine doses to low-income countries

Moderna's Dr. Jacqueline Miller said Moderna plans to send 50 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccine to COVAX in 2022.

In order to promote global vaccine equity, Miller said Moderna will open localized manufacturing facilities in Africa and send 1 billion doses to low-income countries.

She also added that the reduced 50 mg dosage of the Moderna COVID-19 booster shot will "make more vaccines available for the world."

When asked about the timeline for the manufacturing facilities, Miller could not provide any further information.

FDA will discuss oral COVID-19 treatment November 30

The FDA announced Wednesday that its Antimicrobial Drugs Advisory Committee (AMDAC) will discuss the emergency use authorization request for Merck and Ridgeback's COVID-19 antiviral treatment.

The committee will meet on November 30 to discuss the available data on the use of the oral drug in adults who have tested positive for COVID-19 and are at high risk of hospitalization or death.

"We believe that, in this instance, a public discussion of these data with the agency's advisory committee will help ensure clear understanding of the scientific data and information that the FDA is evaluating to make a decision about whether to authorize this treatment for emergency use," Dr. Patrizia Cavazzoni, director of the FDA's Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, said in a statement.

Biden says approval for booster shots, vaccines for children could come soon

President Biden said the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) will decide on the Moderna and Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 booster vaccines in the coming weeks.

He said those decisions "will be made based on science."

"These boosters are free, available and convenient to get," he said.

He added that the FDA will also decide on approving vaccines for children aged 5 to 11.

"We have purchased enough vaccine for children between the ages of 5 and 11 in the United States," he said, adding that if the vaccine is authorized, "we are ready."

Biden asks the "unacceptably high" number of unvaccinated Americans to get the shot

During a briefing on COVID-19 and vaccinations, President Joe Biden said "now's not the time to let up."

"We have a lot more to do," he said.

Biden did mention the decrease in COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations and said roughly 34 million Americans have gotten vaccinated since July.

However, he said there is an "unacceptably high" number of Americans who are still unvaccinated.

He ended his brief remarks asking those who are still unvaccinated to get their shot.

"We are headed in the right direction," he said, "but we can't let up now."

Israel health officials believe booster dose reduced COVID-19 cases

Data from the Israel Ministry of Health found that the rollout of a third COVID-19 vaccine dose helped decrease coronavirus cases during the fifth wave of the pandemic.

Ron Milo, a professor at Israel's Weitzman Institute, said their data suggest that COVID-19 cases in Israel would have continued to rise exponentially without the booster shots.

"There is no question in my mind now that the break in the curve was due to the booster dose," Dr. Sharon Alroy-Preiss, the director of public health services at the Israel Ministry of Health, said.

Averse effects of booster shot are "comparable" to first two doses, Moderna says

Moderna's Jacqueline Miller said the rates of adverse reactions to the 50 mg booster doses are comparable to those observes after the primary series.

Data from Modera showed that pain at the injection site is the most common solicited local reaction, while headache, fatigue and myalgia are the most common systematic reactions.

Axillary swelling or tenderness were the only adverse reactions that were more frequently reported after booster compared to the first two doses, Miller said.

She added that all reports of the adverse reactions were mild to moderate in severity.

Lower booster dose will increase global vaccine supply, Moderna says

Moderna's Jacqueline Miller said the rationale behind their booster shot selection of a 50 mg third dose is to "use optimal effective dose for boosting."

While the 50 mg booster is a lower dose than the first two shots in the primary series, Miller said this will help "increase worldwide vaccine supply."

Moderna Booster Dose
Jacqueline Miller shares data on the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine booster does. MODERNA

ICYMI: FDA voting question on the effectiveness of the Moderna booster shot

At today's hearing, the FDA Vaccine and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee will consider data on the effectiveness of the Moderna COVID-19 booster shot.

The committee will vote on whether the available data support the safety and effectiveness of the Moderna COVID-19 vaccine as a booster dose at least six months after the first series is complete in three distinct populations.

  • Individuals 65 years of age and older
  • Individuals 18 to 64 years of age at high risk of severe COVID-19
  • Individuals 18 to 64 years of age whose frequent exposure to COVID-19 because of their jobs outs them at a high risk of serious complications of COVID-19, including severe COVID-19

This is similar to the request from Pfizer authorized by the FDA last month.

Here’s the question that will be voted on: #COVID19 #FDA

— Sonia Azad (@SoniaAzadTV) October 14, 2021

Side effects of booster dose are no worse than side effects of first two doses, Israel finds

Officials from the Israel Health Ministry said data shows the severity of side effects from the third dose of the Moderna vaccine is "no higher" than the side effects from the first or second doses.

The "booster does adverse events are not more acute than the first or second dose," according to the data summary.

Officials are looking into the causality of reported cases of myocarditis after receiving the booster shot, but Israel Ministry of Health's Dr. Sharon Alroy-Preis said the rate of myocarditis is low compared to what was seen after the second dose.

Out of 2.5 million booster doses in Israel, there were 17 cases of myocarditis or perimyocarditis, data found.

She added that cases were reported three to five days after the second dose, while this study tested for myocarditis months after the third dose, which may be the reason for the low rates reported after the booster.

Results from Israel booster vaccine program show decrease in infections

Doctors from Israel's Ministry of Health and the country's top medical institutions are giving a presentation to the FDA panel, showing how a widespread rollout of their booster program has improved infection rates.

Results show a sharp decrease in severe infections among vaccinated people - and later among the unvaccinated as well as the benefits of the extra dose move through the population.

Results from Israel's COVID booster program
Results from Israel's booster COVID vaccine program shows a sharp decrease in severe infections among vaccinated people Ministry of Health Israel

FDA data shows waning effectiveness of vaccine

The FDA advisory panel on booster shots has begun discussing the effectiveness of current vaccines.

Dr. Peter Marks told the group that the effectiveness of Pfizer-BioNTech's drug against catching the virus reduces over several months time - but that protection against hospitalization remains high.

FDA graph shows waning effectiveness of vaccines
FDA graph shows waning effectiveness of vaccines Food and Drug Administration

WHO Africa confirms less than five percent fully vaccinated

Dr. Matshidiso Moeti has just told a press conference that less than five percent of people in the continent have been fully vaccinated.

They also pointed towards poor testing regimes in many countries.

Our analysis indicates that as few as one in seven cases are being detected, meaning that the true COVID-19 burden in Africa could be around 59 million cases.

Moeti called on wealthy countries once again to send large shipments of vaccine to the continent "now rather than next year".

British doctor says NHS in England 'in a dire state' as hospitals fill up

The U.K. is facing challenges with COVID, cold, and flu as the weather gets colder and more people become ill.

Around 40,000 people on average are being infected each day in the country and hospital admissions are on the rise once again, prompting concerns from officials that the health service is already struggling to cope.

Every single trust in England is running to full capacity . We are all in dire state and this will get worse . We have no staff to meet the demands on our systems . We need to invest in social and support services as we cannot discharge patients back to the community.

— Junaid rathore (@Jsrathoe69) October 14, 2021

Japanese PM to fight election on COVID

Fumio Kishida has just announced his government will outline its coronavirus response tomorrow - after dissolving the House of Representatives for a general election.

Speaking at a press conference, he said the future of Japan is at stake in the upcoming lower house election on October 31, as he seeks a mandate to lead the country and continue his plan to deal with COVID-19 just weeks after becoming PM on October 4.

Ozzy Osbourne says 'devil' stopped him getting COVID

The Black Sabbath star declined to say whether he had been following COVID restrictions like social distancing or wearing a mask but joked that his avoidance of the deadly virus had something to do with the watchful Lucifer himself.

Osbourne's family, on the other hand, hasn't been so lucky. His wife Sharon Osbourne was hospitalized with Covid in December last year, and one of his daughters also contracted the virus.

My wife had the virus; my daughter had the virus and I never got it. Being a devil worshipper does have its good points!

Ozzy Osbourne says 'devil' stoppedhim getting COVID
Ozzy Osbourne speaks onstage at iHeartRadio ICONS, California Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Healthcare workers playing 'haunting' piano set at 3am goes viral

California judge enters mandate row

Despite being one of the most open states to COVID restrictions throughout the pandemic, a California judge has partially blocked an order taking effect this week that requires state prison employees to be vaccinated against the coronavirus.

The judge, in Kern County, issued a temporary order that prevents enforcement of the vaccine mandate for unionized guards that was due to take effect tomorrow. But the mandate will still apply to other workers at prisons that have healthcare facilities.

The rule is aimed at preventing another COVID outbreak like one that killed 28 inmates and a correctional officer at San Quentin State Prison last year, lawmakers say, but the California Correctional Peace Officers Association continues to strongly oppose the measure.

FDA finds 'lapses' in J&J vaccine data ahead of booster decision, panel split

Scientists who conducted an online review of the shot yesterday - ahead of today and Friday's crunch talks on boosters - said that there were lapses in the data provided by J&J as well as little information on the booster's effectiveness against the Delta variant.

The shaky evaluation leaves the FDA advisory panel split ahead of the discussions - but the group will ultimately need to come to an agreement in the coming days. If it does recommend a booster for J&J, the agency will also need to decide whether recipients should get the shot two months or six months after initial vaccination.

FULL STORY: FDA Split on When or if J&J Vaccine Recipients Need Booster

Delta COVID variant trending downwards but Americans 'can't let our guard down' - JHU

Data from Johns Hopkins University show some positive signs for COVID in the U.S., with the number of new infections dramatically declining and vaccination uptake on the rise once again.

Good news: the delta wave is trending ↘️ in the U.S., and vaccinations are ↗️. But we can't let our guard down yet.

Encourage the people in your life to get vaccinated, and get tested if you have any #COVID19 symptoms

Keep up with the latest trends:

— Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health (@JohnsHopkinsSPH) October 13, 2021

Southwest airlines 'doesn't know' how many of its staff are unvaccinated

The company - nor the Southwest Airlines Pilots Association - could confirm that they know how many pilots are yet to be fully vaccinated against COVID-19.

The airline told employees last week that they would be required to get the vaccine by December 8 - leaving less than two months to enforce the requirement. Mass flight cancellations earlier this week sparked false claims from some social media users and politicians, including Texas Senator Ted Cruz, that pilots and air traffic controllers had either walked off their jobs or called in sick to protest the mandate.

FULL STORY: Southwest Doesn't Know How Many Pilots Unvaccinated Against COVID, Union President Says

Unvaccinated ICU nurse films herself getting escorted out of UCLA hospital

Identified as Tara Vafaeenia, the clip of her has been shared widely by conservative commentators across Instagram and Twitter.

"So, I'm being escorted out of UCLA for standing up for medical freedom, despite coming to work, willing to work," Vafaeenia says in the video.

Chiefs of major international institutions back 40 percent worldwide vaccine target

The bosses of the World Health Organization, World Bank, Internation Monetary Fund, and World Trade Organization have jointly established a task force to ensure at least 40 percent - preferably more - of the world's population are vaccinated by the end of 2021.

The executive appeared on CNN's 'Connect' show last night to talk about the plans.

TONIGHT: If we want to move beyond this pandemic, we must make sure at least 40% of people in all countries are vaccinated by the end of this year. The chiefs of @WorldBank @WHO @IMFNews @wto have established a task force to do just that. Hear from them on @CNNConnect at 7:30 GST

— Becky Anderson (@BeckyCNN) October 13, 2021

Fauci tells pilots to stop worrying about 'career-ending side effects' of COVID vaccine

President Biden's chief medical advisor said yesterday afternoon that airline pilots should be far more concerned about the potential health consequences of contracting COVID-19 than any risk of possible side effects from vaccines.

We have examples of people - they may not necessarily be pilots, maybe there are some - who actually have gotten COVID and have had an unexplained but real impact on their ability to function normally.

Common side effects from all vaccines include a sore arm, a low-grade fever, and other mild flu-like symptoms lasting only a few days.

FULL STORY: Fauci Warns Vaccine-Hesitant Pilots: Getting COVID Should Be Greater Concern

Good morning and welcome to Newsweek's liveblog

FDA officials are preparing to meet today for the beginning of 48 hours of crunch talks over whether to recommend COVID booster shots of the Johnson & Johnson and Moderna vaccines.

Follow Newsweek's liveblog throughout Thursday for all the latest.


Newsweek cover
  • Newsweek magazine delivered to your door
  • Unlimited access to
  • Ad free experience
  • iOS and Android app access
  • All newsletters + podcasts
Newsweek cover
  • Unlimited access to
  • Ad free experience
  • iOS and Android app access
  • All newsletters + podcasts