
...

By Hugh Cameron
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Cracker Barrel’s store traffic plummeted after the company’s ill-fated attempt at a rebrand in August, according to new data.
According to data from location intelligence platform Placer.ai, cited by Restaurant Dive, store traffic sank 5.3 percent year-over-year in the week after the announcement of a logo change replacing its "Old Timer" figure drew scorn from many across the U.S.—including the White House. The declines continued as backlash grew, with traffic down around 10 percent for the first three weeks of September.
Newsweek has contacted Cracker Barrel via email for comment.
Read More on U.S.

...
Why It Matters
While Cracker Barrel swiftly reverted to its "Old Timer" logo, fallout from the rebrand has been severe. The company’s share price has dropped over 20 percent since the original announcement on August 19, executives have themselves noted declines in visitor numbers, and the entire episode has become a cautionary tale of how minor alterations for a well-known brand can provoke customer outrage and impact a company’s financial footing.
What To Know
According to Placer.ai, the slump which followed the announcement extended into late September, with traffic falling 7.2 percent year-over-year during the week of September 22.
Placer.ai’s figures are broadly in line with the changes Cracker Barrel observed during a recent earnings call on September 17. Chief Financial Officer Craig Pommells said that since August 19, store traffic had declined "approximately 8 percent." Assuming the trend continues, the company anticipates traffic falling around 7 percent for the first quarter of its fiscal year which runs from early August to the end of October.
"We deeply value the strong emotional connection our guests have, not just to the old-timer logo or vintage Americana decor, but to the sense of tradition and nostalgia those represent," said CEO Julie Masino during the call. "That connection is powerful and we recognize there are other areas where we must continue improving, especially in our food and overall guest experience."
David Johnson, founder and CEO of Strategic Vision PR Group, told Newsweek that Cracker Barrel's attempted rebrand sparked such protest "because it contradicted the company’s long-standing values and heritage that customers had connected with for decades."
"The changes—from the logo to the restaurant atmosphere—felt like a rejection of the brand identity that loyal patrons cherished," he said. "Rather than broadening appeal, the shift alienated core customers without attracting meaningful new audiences."
As well as reverting to its original logo after only a week, which Johnson described as a "good start," Cracker Barrel has implemented a number of changes as it attempts to recover from the incident. Last week, it cut ties with Prophet, the San Francisco-based design firm behind the rebrand as well as several restaurant redesigns.
In mid-September, Cracker Barrel announced that it would be closing 14 Maple Street Biscuit Company locations, one of its wholly owned subsidiaries, though it did not state whether this was related to the rebrand when contacted by Newsweek.
What People Are Saying
Cracker Barrel President and Chief Executive Officer Julie Masino, in an earnings release, said: "We thank our guests for sharing their voices and their passion for Cracker Barrel in recent weeks, and we've listened, switching back to our 'Old Timer' logo, hitting pause on remodels, and placing an even bigger emphasis in the kitchen and other areas that enhance the guest experience."
Public relations strategist David Johnson told Newsweek: "Changing the logo was a good start but as sales show the bleeding and the damage is not over. It must work at reassuring its customers that it understands why they were angry and will not undertake a dramatic change. It needs to do a better job of listening to its base. Executives from the company should visit locations throughout the nation and listen to and apologize to customers for the fiasco. It needs to reemphasize its rich story history and reengage with its base."
"It could take a year or longer to fully bring back customers and move on," he added. "Or it is possible that the brand has been so tarnished that it may not fully recover for much longer as has happened with other brands such as Bud Light."
Cracker Barrel shareholder Biglari Capital Corp., in a recent filing calling for the ouster of the CEO, said: "Under the current leadership, the Board and management have pursued initiatives that betrayed the Company’s heritage, alienated loyal customers, and undermined investor confidence. Instead of demonstrating the discipline and stewardship required to protect and enhance a storied brand, management has relied on ill-conceived strategies that have worsened existing challenges rather than solved them, culminating in the disastrous "brand refresh" that has ranked among this century’s worst brand blunders alongside Bud Light and Jaguar."
What Happens Next?
Looking ahead, Cracker Barrel expects total revenue of $3.35 billion to $3.45 billion for fiscal 2026, compared to $3.48 billion in the prior year, alongside a comparable store traffic decline of between 4 and 7 percent.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines