10

Loading video...

Dan Gooding

By Dan Gooding

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Six years ago, Dan Sullivan entered the final stretch of his reelection campaign with a clear polling lead, a favorable political climate, and an opponent who had never won a statewide office. Today, the Alaska Republican finds himself in a markedly different position, trailing Democrat Mary Peltola in multiple polls, and navigating a less favorable environment as he seeks a third Senate term.

Polling averages compiled by RealClearPolling currently place Peltola ahead by about two points, while a new New York Times/Siena survey released Monday gave her a 7-point lead—a sharp reversal from October 2020 when the survey showed Sullivan leading independent Al Gross by eight points before he ultimately won by 13.

On Monday, Vice President JD Vance sought to boost Sullivan's campaign, appearing at a rally in Fairbanks alongside the senator. Despite current polling, the National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC) appeared confident he would win, hitting out at allegations made by former Peltola staffers to The New York Times that she had angry outbursts and used slurs.

Read More on Politics

"Mary Peltola wished a fellow Alaskan died of a botched abortion, got zero bills signed into law, pushed the far-left to keep energy production shut down and then cashed out as a Lower 48 lobbyist. Peltola puts Alaska last and her Lower 48 donors first," NRSC Regional press secretary Nick Puglia told Newsweek in a statement Monday.

Peltola's campaign pushed back on Puglia's comment, telling Newsweek that Sullivan had pushed up everyday costs for Alaskans.

“After tripling his wealth in the Senate and voting fourteen times for the war in Iran that has created an unprecedented affordability crisis for Alaskans, it’s not surprising that Dan Sullivan and his DC backers are resorting to lies about Mary’s record of delivering for Alaska in a last-ditch effort to hold onto his seat," an Alaskans for Mary spokesperson said in a statement.

"Mary will win this November because Alaskans know that she’s an independent voice who will stand up to anyone – including her own party – to lower costs, take on the rigged system in DC, and put Alaska first.”

Newsweek reached out to Sullivan's campaign for comment.

Senator Dan Sullivan enters the U.S. Capitol on August 7, 2026, in Washington, D.C.

...

Why 2026 Looks Tougher Than 2020

While polling in Alaska has historically underestimated Republican performance, Sullivan enters October in a significantly weaker position than at the same point in 2020.

Six years ago, Sullivan maintained a strong lead over Gross for much of the year, per RealClearPolling. An early July 2020 survey from PPP, a Democrat-leaning pollster, showed the Republican with a 5-point lead. That rose to 8 points in the Times/Siena poll conducted in early October.

The final result saw Sullivan with 54 percent of the vote to Gross' 41.3 percent, a 12.7 percent advantage.

Gross ran as an independent and had never held federal office, but Democrats endorsed him. He emphasized his background as a doctor and fisherman rather than as a partisan politician, with much of his campaign messaging centered on his independence from both major parties.

By late summer and early fall of 2020, some Democrats believed Alaska could be a surprise pickup, with Gross having raised a significant amount of money and polls showing close margins. For Sullivan, the state's longtime Republican lean helped, as did President Donald Trump's popularity.

Fast forward to 2026, and the relationship between Sullivan and the president, whose own popularity has dropped significantly, could be one of the factors harming the senator.

President Donald Trump speaks to Senator Dan Sullivan in the Oval Office of the White House on September 30, 2026.

...

Peltola presents a very different challenge for Sullivan, having held Alaska's only House of Representatives seat from 2022-2025, showing she can win and hold a federal seat as a Democrat.

The political environment has also shifted since 2020. At the time, Trump was still doing well among his base and the wider GOP, holding several key red states in that presidential election.

Now, despite allegations of outbursts by Peltola toward her staffers, which her campaign has explained as a result of grief over her husband and mother, and Sullivan's partnership with the White House on investment in the state, the Democrat is the one leading the polls. On Tuesday, Sabato's Crystal Ball changed its ranking for the Senate race in Alaska from a toss-up to "Leans Democratic."

"Alaska is impacted by the good Democratic environment just like so many other states are, and Peltola is a strong challenger," Kyle Kondik, the managing editor of Sabato’s Crystal Ball, told Newsweek. "Additionally, Alaska has a top-four, ranked choice voting system that wasn't in place in 2020, and the structure of the ballot (Peltola is the only Democrat) likely aids her as well."

Why Republicans Think Sullivan Can Win

Sullivan still has a real chance of keeping his Senate seat, in part because his political history may help him.

Since first winning election to the Senate in 2014, he has never lost a statewide race, and he was consistently underestimated in parts of the 2020 cycle before his victory over Gross. Polling is notoriously difficult in a state that covers a large geographic area and is expensive to survey.

The state itself also plays a key role, still seen as a core Republican state at the federal level, with both Senate seats and the House seat currently held by GOP members. Trump also had strong standing in 2024, carrying the state by a double-digit margin, although, again, changing public sentiment toward the president may have an impact two years on.

Related Story

Republicans Face Midterms Disaster—What Polling Reveals

Republicans Face Midterms Disaster—What Polling Reveals

Republicans are still backing Sullivan, including the president and Vance, who campaigned with the candidate Monday. Super PACs backing Sullivan have also attacked Peltola over the allegations through a TV ad campaign, hoping to focus voters on that issue.

The central question facing the race is whether Alaska's Republican lean is strong enough to carry Sullivan through worsening headwinds, or whether Peltola can turn the coalition that elected her to the House into a Senate-winning majority.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Jason Lemon and Sam Wilson.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines