...
By Darlin Tillery
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When a Dairy Queen cake box was opened, what should have been a magical birthday moment turned into an online outrage scene that even seasoned Redditors called out as a total fail.
Posting on Reddit, user ekando explained that she had ordered a personalized cake for her daughter Norah’s ninth birthday, complete with specific colors, decorations and a custom message.
But when her husband picked up the cake and brought it home, she said the final product was far from what they had requested.
Read More on Life
...
“This was my first time ordering a custom DQ cake,” the original poster (OP) wrote, adding, “My daughter was pretty excited about the candles-all-around-the-cake design.”
According to the order details shown in screenshots, the cake was meant to be a 10-by-14-inch sheet cake with pink lettering reading “Happy 9th Birthday Norah.”
The family selected purple icing for the top border and blue icing for the bottom border.
A Special Request
Norah also had one special request: “I asked her if there was anything special she wanted added, and she requested ‘whipped cream rainbow stars,’” the OP wrote. “Girl loves the whipped cream.”
The order form also included a note asking for the whipped cream stars to appear around the cake if possible. The OP added she understood that the request might cost extra, but hoped the bakery could include at least a few.
Instead, the cake her husband brought home looked completely different.
am i overreacting by being really upset by this
r/DairyQueen
The cake in the photo has multicolored bubble-style letters spelling “Happy Birthday” with purple borders and scattered rainbow sprinkles, but none of the requested candle decorations or whipped cream stars.
The OP said the cake initially didn’t even include her daughter’s name when it was handed to her husband at pickup.
“It looks nothing like what we requested,” she wrote. “These cakes aren't cheap, and it wasn’t even the right design. Or the right message. Or the right colors.”
Still, the situation left her second-guessing whether her frustration was justified, as a friend suggested she might be expecting too much from a fast-food restaurant bakery.
Reddit Reacts
Reddit users, however, overwhelmingly backed the OP, with one writing, “I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all. It looks like a random generic cake.”
Another agreed, adding, “They never made your order. They grabbed a random cake out of the freezer. I would 100% call the manager, and if the manager doesn’t make it right, call the district manager.”
Questions about how to address mistakes like this are common in the restaurant industry. Writing for Food & Wine, hospitality writer Darron Cardosa noted, “Everyone is entitled to make a mistake here and there.”
Dairy Queen Policies
When problems occur, customers often turn to store managers or corporate support for help resolving the issue.
Dairy Queen’s corporate website states that many concerns about orders should be handled directly by the local franchise location.
“DQ restaurants are independently owned and operated franchised locations that have served customers for 85 years,” the company says on its contact page, adding that feedback helps franchise owners maintain product and service standards.
Newsweek has reached out to ekando and Dairy Queen for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.
To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines