Donald Trump Temu

...

Andrew Stanton

By Andrew Stanton

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump's proposed tariffs are expected to have a significant impact on popular Chinese e-commerce websites like Shein and Temu by eliminating something known as the "de minimis" loophole.

Newsweek reached out to the White House, Shein and Temu for comment via email.

Why It Matters

The president announced blanket tariffs on imports from Canada, China and Mexico to go into effect Tuesday. Trump cited concerns about trade deficits and stopping the flow of fentanyl into the United States to justify the tariffs, which many economists warn could lead to higher prices for American consumers or cause other economic disruptions.

Read More on News

As part of the tariffs, Trump is ending the "de minimis exception," which allows companies to avert paying duties on imports worth $800 or less when shipping packages to customers in the U.S.

Ending this loophole could have impacts for popular e-commerce cities like Shein and Temu, which have skyrocketed popularity over the past few years for U.S. consumers drawn to their cheap prices and fast turnarounds. The retailers, however, have drawn scrutiny over issues like their impact on the environment and workers rights.

What to Know

These popular e-commerce websites have used the loophole to get around paying duty fees on their goods, allowing them to cheaply deliver their products to American consumers directly from China.

Donald Trump Temu

...

A Congressional Research Service report released last week found these low-value packages totaled $66 billion in 2023, up from $5.3 billion just five years earlier in 2018, underscoring the growth of these companies.

About 67 percent of imports using the loophole came from China between 2018 and 2021, according to the report. Shein and Temu account for 17 percent of the U.S. discount market, and many economists point to the loophole as a reason for their explosive growth in the U.S.

Higher Prices, Longer Delivery Times: Experts Weigh in on Impact for Americans

Closing the loophole may have short-term consequences for these companies and American consumers, William Alan Reinsch, senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) told Newsweek on Monday.

"Getting rid of 'de minimis' will hurt those companies in the short term, but it appears they have concluded their customers are willing to tolerate slower delivery if they can still get favorable prices," he said.

Ryan Monarch, a professor of economics at Syracuse University, told Newsweek prices will be driven up not only by the tariffs themselves, but also the increased costs with complying with customs rules.

There will be added costs both from sellers, who will need to prepare paperwork and calculate the value of each package as well as U.S. customs workers who will be tasked with enforcing the new policy, he said.

"Part of the reason the exemption exists in the first place is that it didn't seem worth it to try to do all of the work to examine all of these packages and imported things that are of such low value," he said.

Shein

...

In total, a 25 to 30 percent price increase would not be "outlandlish," Monarch said. It's difficult to predict the full impact, but companies are unlikely to eat the costs of these fees, he added.

"We should expect that those prices are going to go directly onto American buyers. Research has shown that Chinese suppliers pass on those prices completely."

This also means consumers in the U.S. should expect to wait longer to receive their purchases, Monarch said. He suggested this will disproportionately impact lower income consumers who are more likely to purchase from these cheap e-commerce sites.

While Monarch said ending the loophole doesn't make sense from an economic perspective, he said there are non-economic justifications, including curbing the influx of fentanyl into the country — an issue the White House has specifically noted as justification for the tariffs. But officials could also do this by addressing demand for the drug, rather than the supply, he noted.

Sophia Busch, assistant director at the Atlantic Council's GeoEconomics Center, told Newsweek companies like Shein and Temu may also lower their before-duty import prices to continue appealing to U.S. consumers, but noted based on past trade wars that American consumers are likely to end up facing higher prices.

"It may make it more difficult for these companies to sell to U.S. consumers, as their business models are build around the low prices that are possible through this loophole," Busch said.

There is speculation the companies could ship in bulk to U.S. warehouses, paying the duties, and then ship their products to customers, Reinsch said. Another alternative could be to channel shipments through other countries, though the legality of that move would be "questionable," Reinsch said.

'De minimis' was first implemented in 1938, but has undergone changes over the years and has faced bipartisan calls for further scrutiny. In 2015, Congress upped the limit from $200 to $800.

Reinsch said the goal of raising the limit was "facilitating more trade in what they assumed would be benign, small packages," but that evidence shows it became a means for drug shipments and fast fashion to circumvent duties.

Biden Administration Planned Crackdown on 'De Minimis'

Trump isn't the first president to eye the loophole.

The Biden administration said last year it planned to crack down on the use of 'de minimis' by these companies. The White House said in a statement in September the increase in the loophole's use "makes it more challenging to enforce U.S. trade laws, health and safety requirements, intellectual property rights, consumer protection rules" and block synthetic drugs from entering the country.

Congressional Democrats urged Biden to use executive authority to end the loophole.

"These imports threaten U.S. manufacturers, hurt union workers and local
retailers, and expose American consumers to great risk by flooding the market with fake and sometimes dangerous imported goods, including fentanyl and precursor chemicals from China," a coalition of Democrats led by former Oregon Representative Eearl Blumenauer wrote in a letter last fall.

What People Are Saying

JUUL Labs in a statement: "Over the past four years, criminals have used smugglers' tactics to exploit this loophole and flood the U.S. with illegal Chinese vapor products, which now account for approximately 70% of the market. This key provision of the America First Trade Agenda empowers our law enforcement agencies to stop the flow of illegal Chinese vapor products and further secure our border."

Matt Stoller, researcher for American Economic Liberties Project, on X: "I don't think the de minimis loophole is really closed for low value product sellers SHEIN, Temu, and Amazon. Yes they have to now pay tariffs, but they don't have to comply with formal customs procedures. That would be the big change."

What Happens Next

The implementation of tariffs was set to begin Tuesday, though the White House agreed to pause the levies on Canada and Mexico for 30 days after President Trump spoke with the leaders of those countries hours before the tariffs were set to kick in. The China tariffs remained in place as of Monday afternoon.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines