
...

By Sam Stevenson
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Tony Gonzales’ sudden exit has reshaped a long‑Republican Texas House district, opening an unexpected contest as Democrats test whether scandal, an open seat and a polarizing GOP nominee can shift the race.
Republican Representative Tony Gonzales announced on Monday that he will retire from Congress after an ethics probe, clearing the way for a special election in Texas’ 23rd Congressional District.
His departure hands Democrats a rare opening in a sprawling border district Republicans have expanded their grip on through redistricting.
Read More on Politics
Voters now face a choice between Democrat Katy Padilla Stout and Republican nominee Brandon Herrera in an open-seat race with national implications.
Padilla Stout told Newsweek in an emailed statement: "I call on my opponent, Brandon Herrera, to join me in calling on Governor Abbott to call a special election immediately to ensure that the people of TX-23 do not go without a voice in Congress.
"The hard-working people of this district have not had the full attention of their representative in Congress, as they should.
"They should be afforded an opportunity to elect a representative from this district who shares their values and work ethic."
Newsweek has contacted Gonzales and Herrera via email for comment.
Why It Matters
Open seats are historically more competitive than incumbent races, and Gonzales’ resignation removes a moderate GOP figure who once outperformed his party’s top‑of‑ticket candidates.

...
A Rare Opening in Texas’ Largest District
Texas’ 23rd Congressional District stretches across 27 counties, running from San Antonio westward along the U.S.–Mexico border to El Paso.
It is the largest district in the state by land area, combining suburban neighborhoods, rural ranchland and border communities with vastly different economic concerns.
For more than a decade, Republicans have controlled the seat, aided by redistricting that tilted the district rightward and a recent shift of Hispanic voters toward the GOP.
In 2024, Gonzales won reelection by more than 24 points. President Donald Trump carried the district by a smaller margin of roughly 15 points.
That stability ended when Gonzales withdrew from the race amid admission of an extramarital affair and an ongoing House Ethics Committee investigation.
Democrats See Momentum
Polling conducted for House Majority PAC suggests Democrats see an opening, though the data comes with clear limitations due to its sponsorship.
A recent survey conducted for House Majority PAC by Public Policy Polling, a Democratic-affiliated firm, found Democratic candidate Padilla Stout trailing the GOP’s Herrera by 2 points in a hypothetical head‑to‑head matchup, 42 percent to 40 percent, with 18 percent undecided.
Gonzales’ 24‑point victory in 2024 underscores how sharply the numbers have narrowed since his exit, with partisan‑backed polling suggesting a tighter race.
The same poll shows Padilla Stout with a net‑positive image among voters who know her: 21 percent view her favorably, compared with 17 percent unfavorably, while more than 60 percent remain undecided about her—a sign of both limited name recognition and room to grow.
Herrera, by contrast, enters the race with more defined perceptions: 35 percent of voters hold an unfavorable view of him, compared with 29 percent favorable, according to the poll. Roughly a third said they were unsure.
The TX‑23 polling was conducted among 521 Texas voters from March 10-11. It does not include a margin of error.
Controversies Shape the Contest
The Democratic-backed survey tested voter reactions to several issues tied to Herrera’s past remarks and online videos. According to the Texas Tribune, Democratic groups have pointed to videos from his YouTube channel where they say the Republican candidate has made Holocaust jokes.
Some 58 percent said they were concerned after hearing accusations that he had made antisemitic comments or referenced owning a copy of Mein Kampf—allegations Herrera and his campaign deny.
Herrera’s campaign has argued that such criticisms misrepresent his work as a historical firearms educator and dismiss them as politically motivated attacks.
A campaign spokesman told the Texas Tribune: “Brandon has never done or said anything antisemitic, and he has earned the support of leaders in the Jewish community.”
Democrats have leaned into the contrast, sharing clips from Herrera’s online content as part of their effort to frame him as extreme for the district.
Padilla Stout, a San Antonio attorney and former public school teacher, has said she entered the race after concluding neither Gonzales nor Herrera reflected her values or the district’s needs.
She has positioned herself as a candidate capable of appealing to moderates turned off by Herrera’s style.
The Broader Political Environment
The House Majority PAC poll also points to broader headwinds for Republicans in TX‑23.
On the generic congressional ballot, Republicans lead Democrats by 2 points, 47 percent to 45 percent, with 8 percent undecided—a much closer margin than past cycles.
At the top of the ticket, Trump’s standing in the district is mixed, with 52 percent of voters holding an unfavorable view and 50 percent disapproving of his performance.
Respondents were especially critical of Trump’s handling of economic issues. Majorities said they disapproved of his approach to inflation and affordability, as well as the economy more broadly. His handling of Iran also drew more disapproval than approval among voters surveyed.
Competitive statewide races could further shape turnout. The poll showed Democratic candidates performing competitively in races for governor and U.S. Senate among TX‑23 voters, potentially aiding Democrats down the ballot.
What Prediction Markets Suggest
Beyond polling, prediction markets offer another lens on the race—though one with important limits.
Prediction markets allow traders to buy and sell contracts based on expected outcomes, with prices reflecting collective expectations rather than votes.
Platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket currently favor a Republican win in TX‑23.
As of the time of writing, Kalshi markets place the Republican Party at roughly a 71 percent chance of winning the seat, compared with 31 percent for Democrats.
Polymarket gives Republicans about a two‑to‑one advantage.
These markets tend to reflect historical voting patterns and partisan lean, particularly in districts that have consistently favored one party.
However, they can lag behind new polling data, overweigh past performance and remain sensitive to trading volume rather than campaign fundamentals.
Democrats Balance Optimism With Reality
For Democrats, the path to victory remains narrow.
TX‑23 still leans Republican, and GOP leaders argue the district’s fundamentals have not changed simply because the incumbent stepped aside.
Republicans also point to fundraising disparities, noting Herrera entered the general election with a significant financial advantage built during the primary.
Padilla Stout’s campaign, however, reported a sharp increase in donations following Gonzales’ withdrawal, signaling growing national attention.
Local Democrats say turnout will be decisive, particularly among Hispanic voters who make up a majority of the district’s eligible electorate.
Some party activists point to strong Democratic primary turnout as evidence of renewed engagement after years of slippage, the Texas Tribune reports.
Update 4/15/26, 3:18 a.m. ET. This article has been updated with a statement from Katy Padilla Stout.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines